Wednesday, 27 August 2014

electromagnetism - Are the field lines the same as the trajectories of a particle with initial velocity zero


Is it true that the field lines of an electric field are identical to the trajectories of a charged particle with initial velocity zero? If so, how can one prove it?


The claim is from a german physics book from Nolting "Grundkurs theoretische Physik 3 - Elektrodynamik" page 51, let me quote:



Man führt Feldlinien ein und versteht darunter die Bahnen, auf denen sich ein kleiner, positiv geladener, anfangs ruhender Körper aufgrund der Coulomb-Kraft (2.11) bzw. (2.20) fortbewegen würde.



In english:



One introduces field lines and means trajectories along which a small, positively charged, initially resting body moves due to the Coulomb-foce (2.11) resp. (2.20).




2.11 is just the coulomb law, 2.20 is $F = q E$.


(If someone has a better translation, feel free to edit it).


I don't see why this should be true. So it would be great to see a proof or a counterexample with solved equations of motion.


For a magnetic field this claim is obviously wrong since the Lorentz Force depends linearly on the velocity.


Are there other physical fields where the claim is analogously true?


Edit: The answers show that the claim is not true in general but holds in the special case of a highly viscous medium. Is this also the case for moving charged cotton along the field lines in air, as shown in this animation: http://www.leifiphysik.de/web_ph09_g8/grundwissen/01e_feldlinien/01e_feldlinien.htm ?


Do you have any references or more details for this viscous media limit?


Do you have any computational counter example why it doesn't hold in general or a simulation which shows that?




No comments:

Post a Comment