Friday, 2 June 2017

homework and exercises - 4-Momentum conservation for particle annihilation


Disclaimer: this is a homework question, so I am happy with just a hint or the expressions needed to proceed with my understanding.


I am working on the momentum conservation of a particle/anti-particle annihilation process, and I have been asked to show that the annihilation of a particle with a finite mass and its anti-particle cannot lead to the emission of only one photon.


I understand why this happens: the conservation of momentum. However, I would like show this in a more sophisticated 4-momentum proof...how would I go about showing that momentum is conserved for two photons but it is not conserved when the annihilation process creates just one photon...?


This may be a duplicate of: Proving the conservation of 4-momentum for a particle collision $A+B\to C+D$



Answer



There are many possible proofs. Here is one that involves some practice with four-vectors. I write with mostly-minus metric st $p^2=m^2$.


You can write four-momentum conservation as $$ p_1 + p_2 = a $$ Now Minkowski-square, finding $$ 2m^2 + 2 p_1 \cdot p_2 = 0 \Rightarrow p_1 \cdot p_2 < 0$$ Try to show that the latter inequality is impossible. Hint: evaluate the Minkowski product in the rest frame of $p_1$ or $p_2$.



Alternatively, as @Danu suggests, think about the centre of momentum frame, in which $\vec p_1 + \vec p_2 =0$. Can a photon have zero momentum but non-zero energy?


No comments:

Post a Comment