Saturday, 16 December 2017

general relativity - Do all the spacelike curve terminate at the spatial infinity $i_0$ in the Penrose Diagram of a Schwarzchild black hole?


Let's restrict to the radial direction, so the metric can be expressed as


$ds^2=-(1-r_S/r)dt^2+(1-r_S/r)^{-1}dr^2$


with $r_S$ the Schwarzchild radius. Expressed in Kruskal coordinates, the metric is


$ds^2=4(r_S^3/r)e^{-r/r_S}(-dT^2+dR^2)$


Further coordinate transformation brings the infinity into finite coordinate values:


$\tan\frac{\tau+\rho}{2}=T+R=\sqrt{r/r_S-1}e^{(r+t)/2r_S}$


$\tan\frac{\tau-\rho}{2}=T+R=\sqrt{r/r_S-1}e^{(r-t)/2r_S}$



You can verify that the ranges of $\tau$ and $\rho$ are


$\tau\in(-\pi/2,\pi/2), \rho\in(-\pi,\pi)$


As we know that, the spatial infinity is defined at two points: $\tau=0, \rho=\pm\pi$. Now,I want to verify that all spacelike curves ($t(r),r$) parametrized by $r$ terminate at the spatial infinity and finally, I end up with counterexamples.


Because the curve $(t,r)$ is spacelike, its length is positive,


$-(1-r_S/r)(\frac{dt}{dr})^2+(1-r_S/r)^{-1}>0\Rightarrow \frac{dt}{dr}<(1-r_S/r)^{-1}$


only considering a outgoing spacelike curve outside of the horizon. So


$dt<\frac{dr}{1-r_S/r}=dr_*$


Here, $r_*$ is the tortoise coordinate. We can assume $dt=dr_*+f(r)dr$. $f(r)$ should be positive definite and not a constant function. Now, in terms of $f(r)$, we have


$\tan\frac{\tau+\rho}{2}=(r/r_S-1)e^{r/r_S}\exp[r_S^{-1}\int^r_{r_0} f(r')dr']$


$\tan\frac{\tau-\rho}{2}=-\exp[-r_S^{-1}\int^r_{r_0} f(r')dr']$



We can thus consider the behavior of the above express at $r\rightarrow\infty$. Defintely, the first expression is $+\infty$, but since $\int^r_{r_0} f(r')dr'$ is not necessarily infinite (for example, $f(r)=1/r^2$), the second expression is not necessarily $-\infty$.


Therefore, we cannot conclude that all spacelike curves terminate at the spatial infinity $i_0$ in the case of a Schwarzchild spacetime.


But all the books state the opposite. What is wrong with my calculation?




No comments:

Post a Comment