Monday 21 September 2015

quantum mechanics - What is the most general expression for the coordinate representation of momentum operator?



I have a question about deriving the coordinate representation of momentum operator from the commutation relation, $[x,p]= i$.


One derivation (ref W. Greiner's Quantum Mechanics: An Introduction, 4th edi, p442) is as following: $$ \langle x|[x,p]|y \rangle = \langle x|xp-px|y \rangle = (x-y) \langle x|p|y \rangle. $$ On the other hand, $ \langle x|[x,p]|y \rangle = i \langle x|y \rangle = i \delta (x-y)$. Thus $$ (x-y) \langle x|p|y \rangle = i \delta(x-y). \tag{1} $$


We use $(x-y) \delta(x-y) = 0$. Take the derivative with respect to $x$; we have $\delta(x-y) + (x-y) \delta'(x-y) = 0$. Thus $$ (x-y) \delta'(x-y) = - \delta(x-y). \tag{2} $$


Comparing Eqs. (1) and (2), we identify $$ \langle x|p|y \rangle = -i \delta'(x-y). \tag{3} $$


In addition, we can add $\alpha \delta(x-y)$ on the right-hand side of Eq. (3), i.e. $$ \langle x|p|y \rangle = -i \delta'(x-y) + \alpha \delta(x-y), $$ and $[x,p] = i$ is still satisfied. We can also add $$ \frac{\beta}{\sqrt{|x-y|}}\delta(x-y)$$ on the RHS of Eq. (3). Here $\alpha$ and $\beta$ are two real numbers.


My question is, what is the most general expression of $\langle x|p|y \rangle$? Can we always absorb the additional term into a phase factor like Dirac's quantum mechanics book did?


Thank you very much in advance.



Answer



We start by mentioning a couple of standard formulas


$$\tag{1} \psi(x)~=~\langle x | \psi \rangle, $$



and


$$\tag{2} \langle x | y \rangle ~=~\delta(x-y).$$


The canonical commutation relation (CCR) is


$$\tag{3} [\hat{x}, \hat{p}] ~=~i\hbar{\bf 1}. $$


The standard Schrödinger position representation reads


$$\tag{4}\hat{x}~=~x, \qquad \hat{p}~=~-i\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial x}.$$


We may conjugate the standard Schrödinger position representation (4) by an unitary operator $\hat{U}=e^{-if(\hat{x})}$, where $f:\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}$ is a given differentiable function. In this way we obtain an unitary equivalent position representation


$$\tag{5}\hat{x}~=~x, \qquad \hat{p} ~=~-i\hbar e^{-if(x)}\frac{\partial}{\partial x}e^{if(x)} ~=~-i\hbar\frac{\partial}{\partial x}+ \hbar f^{\prime}(x),$$


of the CCR (3). The standard Schrödinger position representation (4) corresponds to $f\equiv {\rm const}$. For a general irreducible representation of the CCR (3), see the Stone-von Neumann Theorem.


The representation (5) implies



$$\tag{6} \langle x | \hat{p} |\psi \rangle~=~(\hat {p} \psi)(x) ~=~-i\hbar e^{-if(x)}(e^{if}\psi)^{\prime}(x) ~=~-i\hbar\psi^{\prime}(x)+ \hbar f^{\prime}(x)\psi(x). $$


From (6) we conclude that the momentum matrix elements reads


$$\tag{7} \langle x | \hat{p} |y \rangle~=~-i\hbar\delta^{\prime}(x-y)+ \hbar f^{\prime}(x)\delta(x-y)$$


in the representation (5).


Finally, here and here are two other Phys.SE posts that also discuss ambiguities in $x\leftrightarrow p$ overlaps.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...