Sunday 24 May 2020

symmetry - Noether's theorem under arbitrary coordinate transformation


Noether's theorem states that every differentiable symmetry of the action of a physical system has a corresponding conservation law.


Suppose our action is of the form $S = \int d^4x\, \mathcal{L}(\phi,\partial_\mu\phi).\tag{1}$


if $x \rightarrow x'$ then if $S \rightarrow S'$ where
$S' = \int d^4x'\, \mathcal{L'}(\phi',\partial_\mu\phi').\tag{2}$


But from calculus we know that $S=S'$ so does that mean that every change of variable correspond to a conserved quantity? why the quantities conserved under Poincare transformation, for example, is more especial?



Answer




The action shown in the question is a functional of $\phi$, not of $x$. A change of the integration variable $x$ is just a relabeling of the index set. It does not transform the dynamic variables $\phi$ at all, so no: a change of variable does not correspond to a conserved quantity.


More explicitly, if $y(x)$ is a monotonic smooth function of $x$, then $$ \int d^4y\ {\cal L}\left(\phi\big(y(x)\big),\, \frac{\partial}{\partial y_\mu}\phi\big(y(x)\big)\right) = \int d^4x\ {\cal L}\left(\phi(x),\frac{\partial}{\partial x_\mu}\phi(x)\right) \tag{1} $$ identically, for any ${\cal L}$ whatsoever (as long as it depends on $x$ only via $\phi$). This is just a change of variable (a relabeling of the index-set), and there is no associated conserved quantity.


In contrast, suppose that the action has this property: $$ \int d^4x\ {\cal L}\left(\phi\big(y(x)\big),\, \frac{\partial}{\partial x_\mu}\phi\big(y(x)\big)\right) = \int d^4x\ {\cal L}\left(\phi(x),\frac{\partial}{\partial x_\mu}\phi(x)\right). \tag{2} $$ Unlike equation (1), equation (2) is not identically true for any ${\cal L}$ and any $y(x)$, though it may be true for some choices of ${\cal L}$ and $y(x)$. The transformation represented in equation (2) replaces the original function $x$, namely $\phi(x)$, with a new function of $x$, namely $\phi\big(y(x)\big)$. This is the kind of transformation we have in mind when we talk about Poincaré invariance and its associated conserved quantities: it is a change of the function $\phi$ which we then insert into the original action, not a change of the integration variable.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...