Tuesday, 21 March 2017

special relativity - Why is not ${(Lambda^T)^mu}_nu = {Lambda_nu}^mu$?


I am following lecture notes on SR. The author writes that the following is equivalent:


$$\Lambda^T\eta\Lambda = \eta \iff \eta_{\mu \nu} {\Lambda^\mu}_\rho{\Lambda^\nu}_\sigma = \eta_{\rho \sigma}. \tag{1}$$ This surprises me, because


$$ {(\Lambda^T)^\mu}_\nu = {\Lambda_\nu}^\mu.\tag{2} $$


And so I expected it to be $$\Lambda^T\eta\Lambda = \eta \iff \eta_{\mu \nu} {\Lambda_\rho}^\mu{\Lambda^\nu}_\sigma = \eta_{\rho \sigma}.\tag{3}$$ Why is this wrong?



Answer





  1. OP's three equations should read $$\Lambda^T\eta\Lambda ~=~ \eta \quad\iff\quad (\Lambda^T)_{\rho}{}^{\mu}~\eta_{\mu \nu}~ \Lambda^{\nu}{}_{\sigma} ~=~ \eta_{\rho \sigma} ,\tag{1'}$$ $$ (\Lambda^T)_{\nu}{}^{\mu} ~:=~\Lambda^{\mu}{}_{\nu} ,\tag{2'} $$ $$\Lambda^T\eta\Lambda ~=~ \eta \quad\iff\quad \Lambda^{\mu}{}_{\rho}~\eta_{\mu \nu}~ \Lambda^{\nu}{}_{\sigma} ~=~ \eta_{\rho \sigma} .\tag{3'}$$





  2. In more detail: Let $V$ be $n$-dimensional $\mathbb{R}$-vector space with a basis $(e_{\mu})_{\mu=1, \ldots, n}$. Let $V^{\ast}$ be the dual vector space with the dual basis $(e^{\ast \nu})_{\nu=1, \ldots, n}$. Let $$\Lambda~=~e_{\mu}~ \Lambda^{\mu}{}_{\nu}\otimes e^{\ast \nu}~ \in~V\otimes V^{\ast}~\cong~{\cal L}(V;V)$$ be a linear map from $V$ to $V$. Let us call the positions of the indices on $\Lambda^{\mu}{}_{\nu}$ for the NW-SE convention, cf. a compass rose. Let $$\Lambda^T~=~e^{\ast \nu}~ (\Lambda^T)_{\nu}{}^{\mu}\otimes e_{\mu}~\in~V^{\ast}\otimes V~\cong~{\cal L}(V^{\ast};V^{\ast})$$ be the transposed linear map from $V^{\ast}$ to $V^{\ast}$. Note that $(\Lambda^T)_{\nu}{}^{\mu}$ is written in the SW-NE convention. Let $$\eta~=~e^{\ast \mu}~\eta_{\mu\nu}\odot e^{\ast \nu}~\in~{\rm Sym}^2V^{\ast}~=~V^{\ast}\odot V^{\ast}$$ be an (indefinite) metric, i.e. an invertible element in the symmetrized tensor product. A (pseudo)orthogonal map $\Lambda$ satisfies by definition $$\Lambda^T\eta\Lambda~=~\eta.$$ See also this related Phys.SE post.




No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...