Saturday, 2 May 2020

quantum field theory - Assumptions in the LSZ reduction formula


In Srednicki, Chapter 5, it is said that the LSZ reduction formula holds only under the assumptions $$ \langle 0|\phi(x)|0\rangle =0 \qquad\text{and} \qquad \langle k|\phi(x)|0\rangle =e^{-ikx}$$


I don't understand why the first assumption (and a related one discussed in the chapter) is necessary. It seems that the assumption follows from Lorentz invariance.



We know, using only the fact that $\phi(x)$ is a Lorentz scalar, that $$ [P^{\mu},\phi(x)]=i\partial ^{\mu}\phi(x)$$


Then, we have $$ a^{\dagger}(k)=-i\int d^3x \; e^{ikx}[-i\partial_0\phi(x)+\omega \phi(x)]$$


Therefore, \begin{equation} [P^{\mu},a^{\dagger}(k)] = -i\int d^3x \; e^{ikx}[\partial_0\partial^{\mu}\phi(x)+i\omega \partial^{\mu}\phi(x)]\\ =\int d^3x \; e^{ikx}\partial^{\mu}[-i\partial_0\phi(x)+\omega \phi(x)]\\ =-\int d^3x \; \partial^{\mu}(e^{ikx})[-i\partial_0\phi(x)+\omega \phi(x)]\\ =-ik^{\mu}\int d^3x \; e^{ikx}[-i\partial_0\phi(x)+\omega \phi(x)]\\ =k^{\mu} a^{\dagger}(k) \end{equation}


This shows that $a^{\dagger}(k)|0\rangle$ is now an eigenvector of $P^{\mu}$ of eigenvalue $k^{\mu}$. So we have: $$ a^{\dagger}(k)|0\rangle = \lambda |k\rangle $$


It seems to me that it has two implications:


One is that $$ \langle 0|a^{\dagger}(k)|0\rangle = 0$$ and hence $$ \langle 0|a(k)|0\rangle = \overline{\langle 0|a^{\dagger}(k)|0\rangle}=0$$


Then, doesn't it imply $$\langle 0 | \phi(x) | 0 \rangle = 0$$ only from the assumption that $\phi(x)$ is a Lorentz scalar? (Without any renormalization assumption)


The second consequence is that $$ \langle k',n|a^{\dagger}(k)|0\rangle = 0$$ for any $k'\neq k$.


If so, why did Srednicki spend so much effort to prove that $$ \langle k',n|a_1^{\dagger}(t)|0\rangle \rightarrow 0\qquad \text{as}\qquad t\rightarrow \pm \infty$$




No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...