Saturday, 18 April 2015

newtonian mechanics - Is conservation of momentum and energy valid for non-inertial frames?


Conservation laws of momentum and energy are said to be the most basic principles of physics. Are they also valid for non-inertial frames, and in what way?



Answer



Regarding total momentum conservation, the point is that in non-inertial reference frames inertial forces are present acting on every physical object. Momentum conservation is valid in the absence of external forces.


However, if these forces are directed along a fixed axis, say $e_x$, or are always linear combinations of a pair of orthogonal unit vectors, say $e_x,e_y$, (think of a frame of axes rotating with respect to an inertial frame around the fixed axis $e_z$ with a constant angular velocity), conservation of momentum still holds in the orthogonal direction, respectively. So, for instance, in a non-inertial rotating frame about $e_z$, conservation of momentum still holds referring to the $z$ component.


Mechanical energy conservation is a more delicate issue. A general statement is that, for a system of points interacting by means of internal conservative forces, a notion of conserved total mechanical energy can be given even in non-inertial reference frames provided a technical condition I go to illustrate is satisfied.


Let us indicate by $I$ an inertial reference frame and by $I'$ the used non-inertial frame. Assume that our physical system is made of a number of points interacting by means of conservative true forces depending on the differences of position vectors of the points, so that a potential energy is defined and it does not depend on the reference frame.


If the origin of $I'$ has constant acceleration with respect to $I$ and the same happens for the angular velocity $\omega$ of $I'$ referred to $I$ (it is constant in magnitude and direction), then only three types of inertial forces take place in $I'$ and all them are conservative but one which does not produce work (Coriolis' force). In this case, the sum of the kinetic energy in $I'$, the potential energy of the true forces acting among the points and the potential energy of the inertial forces appearing in $I'$ turns out to be conserved in time along the evolution of the physical system.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...