Friday 6 May 2016

electromagnetism - An example which contradict to Newton's 3rd law?


Let a,b be two charged particles. $$\vec{r}_a(0)=\vec{0}$$ $$\vec{r}_b(0)=r\hat{j}$$ $$\vec{v}_a(t)=v_a \hat{i}$$ $$\vec{v}_b(t)=v_b\hat{j}$$


In which both $v_a$ and $v_b$ $<

Then


$$\vec{E}_{ab}(0)=\frac{q_a}{4\pi \epsilon r^2}\hat{j}$$


$$\vec{B}_{ab}(0)=\frac{\mu q_av_a}{4\pi r^2} \hat{k}$$


$$\vec{E}_{ba}(0)=-\frac{q_b}{4\pi \epsilon r^2}\hat{j}$$


$$\vec{B}_{ba}(0)=\vec{0}$$


Note that $v_a$ and $v_b$ $<

Hence


$$\vec{F}_{ab}(0)=q_b(\vec{E}_{ab}+\vec{v}_b \times \vec{B}_{ab})$$ $$=\frac{q_a q_b}{4\pi \epsilon r^2}\hat{j}-\frac{\mu q_av_a v_b}{4\pi r_b^2} \hat{i}$$


But


$$\vec{F}_{ba}(0)=-\frac{q_aq_b}{4\pi \epsilon r^2}\hat{j}$$



Consequently $$\vec{F}_{ab} \ne -\vec{F}_{ba}$$


This result contradict to Newton's 3rd law!! But I cannot find any error... It troubled me.



Answer



The details of your analysis are not quite right - that's not what the electric field of a moving charge looks like, for example. This is probably because you haven't learned all the rules of electromagnetism yet. Still, the spirit of your question is hitting at an important point.


Charges do not conserve momentum and don't obey Newton's third law. You have to include the momentum of the electromagnetic field to see conservation laws hold.


There's an accessible discussion in section 8.2 of Griffiths "Introduction to Electrodynamics" if you would like a little more math.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...