Friday, 23 June 2017

newtonian mechanics - Massless string Paradox


If we introduce the notion of a massless string to denote the fact that net force on a massless string will always be $0$, since it is massless. How can these massless strings ever accelerate when force on them is $0$?


As an example consider two blocks joined by a massless string , you push a block, the other block accelerates and so does the massless string . But massless string has no net force .



How to resolve this paradox?



Answer



$F=ma$. If $F=0$, and $m=0$, $a$ can be anything. Most physical laws are not "A causes B". They usually say that "A and B can coexist in these conditions". So, it is not necessarily "Force causes acceleration". It is "an accelerating body can coexist with a force if $F=ma$"


The net force on a massless string is always 0 -- it has to be (otherwise it will have infinite acceleration). Whenever we draw free body diagrams of systems that contain massless strings, we always take a tension force $T$ that represents the string "pulling" the body. Take the reaction force of $T$ on the string and you'll notice that the string is always in equilibrium.


For example, take this system, where someone is pulling a set of two boxes interconnected by a string:


enter image description here


Note that the reaction force of $T$ (in red) on the string balances itself.


For a more complicated system, take the following:


enter image description here


(I've taken a massless smooth pulley here. If the pulley wasn't smooth, then the tensions in the two portions of string would be different. If it wasn't massless, the force from the ceiling would be different)



In this system $T$ balances out on the string as well. This is precisely why we say that a section of string exerts $T$ on both ends — to maintain equilibrium.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...