Wednesday, 15 July 2020

quantum mechanics - Why doesn't the Schrödinger equation contain a term of mc2?


Admitting the ansatz


ψ=ei(kxωt)

then k2=ψ12ψx2
and


ω=iψ1ψt


If one admits that the total energy (E) is related to momentum (p) as E=p22m+U, admiting also the De Broglie relations E=ħω; p=ħk it follows that



ħ22m2ψx2+Uψ=iħψt


This is Schrödinger's equation. This equation is said to be non relativistic because of its use of E=p22m+U (rigorously speaking though, it is non relativistic because it is not Lorentz invariant).


However, starting from the relativistic total energy equation


E=11v2c2mc2=T+mc2


Where, T is the kinetic energy and mc2 the particle’s self energy. Now, using the expansion of 11v2c2mc2


E=mc2+mv22+3mv48c2+5mv616c4+...


and ignoring members dividing by c (because we are considering vc). It becomes


E=12mv2+mc2=T+mc2=p22m+mc2


or


p22m+mc2=ħω=ħ2k22m+mc2



So, mc2 do not vanishes even under classical approximation.


Admitting that Planck's and De Broglie's equations holds in every situation and that E in Planck equation is the total energy, substituting equation (2) and (3) into (7) the Schrödinger equation “would” have the form


ħ22m2ψx2+mc2ψ=iħψt


Now we could postulate this equation, making the steps of getting it less fundamental then the end result.


I tried to consider that Tmc2 in Schrödinger equation, but I realize that an electron in hydrogen atom moving with half the speed of light (using classical equations as we are analyzing Schrödinger’s equation) it would have less than 100keV (64keV if my math is not wrong) of kinetic energy, but 511keV of self energy.


So, my question is: why Schrödinger equation do not have an mc2 term, if ħω is supposed to be the total energy and not just the kinetic energy.



Answer



Just because to introduce the constant added term mc2I to the Hamiltonian operator would be equivalent to redefine ψψ=eimc2t/ψ. This sort of phases do not matter in QM. You cannot see them by measuring any observable. Pure states are actually operators of the form |ψψ| and you see that these phases cancel each other.


Instead, if the mass were replaced by a mass operator with discrete spectrum the picture would change. In the classical limit the rapid temporal oscillations of the phases (I am assuming that the mass is big if compared with the typical energies of the system), would destroy the coherence of superpositions of different masses giving dynamically rise to superselection rule of the mass Bargmann's superselection rule (see here or here).


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...