Tuesday, 27 October 2020

x rays - Do free-electron lasers actually lase?


Free-electron lasers are devices which use the motion of highly energetic electron beams to produce bright, coherent radiation in the x-ray regime. More specifically, they start with a high-energy electron beam and feed it into an undulator, which is an array of alternating magnetic fields designed to make the electron beam move in a 'zigzag' path with sharp turns on either side, emitting synchrotron radiation during each turn.



The radiation thus produced is added up over successive turns, and it is produced coherently via self-amplified spontaneous emission.



One common question frequently posed of this setup is: is this actually a laser? That is, does it have population inversion, and is the radiation actually emitted via stimulated emission in some suitable understanding of it? People in the know tend to answer in the affirmative, but I've yet to see a nice explanation of why - and definitely not online. So: do FELs actually lase?



Answer



You are missing a crucial aspect of the dynamics of a Free Electron Laser: microbunching. This comes from the fact that although electrons at different energies share basically the same velocity $c$, they have different oscillation amplitudes in the undulator, therefore they shift longitudinally.


Since you mentioned the SASE mechanism let me expand around it: the noise in the initial electron distribution will guarantee you some peaks which will start to radiate coherently (the power going with $N^2$). As the radiation slips through the bunch (remember that photons go straight, while electrons are wiggled) it exchanges energy with it, triggering energy modulations. But, as we saw before, these result in a longitudinal shift therefore we get additional density modulations at the radiation wavelength.


The result is that your initially long bunch slowly splits in a number of very short (micro) bunches, all of them radiating coherently, with a great boost of the radiation intensity gain. Of course the microbunching can not continue endlessly, indeed it comes to saturation, where the dynamics becomes strongly non linear and the gain is stopped.


While microbunching develops, the radiation increases up to saturation.


Therefore for sure you have light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation: the initial radiation stimulates microbunching leading to even more radiation, obviously this is not the standard interpretation of atomic physics, but in common English it fits perfectly. The population inversion might be seen it in the microbunching factor: the initial, more or less uniform, beam is completely "inverted", while, as long as the microbunching develops this is lost up to the saturation.


For some read up (and also source of the nice picture): FEL@Desy.de (use the menu on the left)


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...