Thursday 14 April 2016

newtonian mechanics - Will a spinning object come to rest?



Will a sphere spinning on its own axis come to rest given enough time, provided no other forces act upon it?


I know that if you have two spinning spheres in the depths of space and orbiting each other they'll eventually stop spinning -- they'll tidally lock each other. The internal friction of the shifting tidal bulge eventually overcomes the rotation.


But I don't see what forces would stop a sphere from rotating around its own axis, in absence of other forces. And yet, each point on the sphere (except points along the axis) is experiencing accelerated motion, which implies a force.


My intuition says that something must maintain the acceleration of each point, which implies that the acceleration causes internal stress. I know this to be true macroscopically (the sphere will have an equatorial bulge), but what forces maintain the acceleration of each particle, and will the stresses ever overcome the rotation of the sphere?


Clarification: I am not considering infinitely rigid spheres or point particles. I'm wondering about actual non-rigid macroscopic spheres, such as planets.



Answer



An isolated body that doesn't exchange any angular momentum with the outside universe will never stop spinning (by conservation of angular momentum). There is no way to absorb angular momentum within the body in internal degrees of freedom; the angular momentum must be transported away if you want to stop.


For example: if something is not rigid, you could have what's called "differential rotation", where maybe the crust of the planet (say) is spinning one way, but the core is spinning the opposite way. Ignore the problem of how to make this happen, just imagine it does. The core has one angular momentum, while the crust has another. But we just add them up, and they have to add to the total angular momentum of the planet initially; it won't be able to stop entirely. You can redistribute angular momentum, but you cannot dissipate total angular momentum within an isolated object, and you cannot make the total angular momentum go to zero without transferring it to the outside universe.


Tidal locking is just another way to redistribute angular momentum. Tidal locking happens because the angular momentum of (to take the most familiar example) the Earth's spin is transported to the angular momentum of the Moon's orbit. The way this happens is that little mound of matter that's raised on the Earth doesn't quite point toward the Moon because Earth's spin carries it a little. And this little bulge exerts a gravitational pull on the Moon, making it speed up (gaining angular momentum). Newton's Third Law tells us that an equal and opposite force is exerted on the Earth, causing its rotation to slow down (losing angular momentum).


To emphasize, that angular momentum gets transferred from a spin to an orbit. And this happens because the Moon is actually orbiting, and thus raising a tide. So, to answer your question in the comments of Olof's answer, tidal locking won't generally stop an object's rotation entirely, because the other object will always be orbiting it. Tidal locking could, in principle, eventually just make the Earth spin at just the right rate so that it rotates as often as the Moon orbits. (Though I think the numbers don't work out.) In fact, this is what happened to the Moon, which is why we only ever see one face.



No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...