Sunday, 16 October 2016

homework and exercises - Is this symmetry factor in Peskin wrong?


I am trying to compute the symmetry factor of a Feynman diagram in $\phi^4$ but i do not get the result Peskin Claims. This is the diagram I am considering


enter image description here


$$\left(\frac{1}{4!}\right)^3\phi(x)\phi(y)\int{}d^4z\,\phi\phi\phi\phi\int{}d^4w\,\phi\phi\phi\phi\int{}d^4v\,\phi\phi\phi\phi$$


my attempt is the following: there are 4 ways to join $\phi(x)$ with $\phi(z)$. There are then 3 ways to connect $\phi(y)$ with $\phi(z)$. Then, there are 8 ways to connect $\phi(z)$ with $\phi(w)$ and 4 ways to contract the remainning $\phi(w)$ with $\phi(v)$. Finally the there are 6 ways to contract the $\phi(w)$ and the three $\phi(v)$ in pairs


$$\left(\frac{1}{4!}\right)^3\dot{}4\dot{}3\dot{}8\dot{}4\dot{}6=\frac{1}{6}$$


but the result claimed in Peskin (page 93) is $1/12$. What am I doing wrong?



Answer





What am I doing wrong?



The expansion of $e^x$ is: $$ e^x=1+x+x^2/2+x^3/3!+\ldots $$


From expanding the expression: $$ \left<\phi_x\phi_y\exp{\left(-\frac{\lambda}{4!}\int dz \phi_z^4\right)}\right>\;, $$ the third order term is: $$ \left< \phi_x\phi_y\frac{1}{3!}{\left(\frac{-\lambda}{4!}\right)}^3\int dz \int dw \int dv \phi_z\phi_z\phi_z\phi_z \phi_w\phi_w\phi_w\phi_w \phi_v\phi_v\phi_v\phi_v \right> $$


There are four (4) ways to connect x to z and then three (3) ways to connect y to z. There are four ways (4) to connect one of the remaining zs to a w and four ways to connect the other remaining z to a v (4), this can be done for either of the two remaining zs (2), i.e., the "third" z can connect to w or the "fourth" z can connect to w. There are six (3!) ways to connect up the remaining ws and vs. And finally, there is nothing special about "z", I can treat "w" the same way as "z" or "v" the same way as "z", so that gives another factor of three (3).


So the overall symmetry factor is: $$ 4*3*4*4*2*3*2*3\frac{1}{3!}\frac{1}{4!^3}=\frac{1}{12} $$


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...