I first explain my reasoning. I know that a Schwarzschild metric is the right metric outside any spherical object, but I also know that it is correct in the empty space. So I thought: why we don't talk about Hawking's radiation for a star? Because, I thought, the metric inside a star in not the same outside. So I thought that an event horizon was necessary because, since inside of it all the matter tends toward the singularity, all the space time (singularity excepted) is described by the Schwarzschild metric, and so I can quantize a field using that metric. However, in Rindler space it's not so. In Rindler space I still have horizons, but now the Rindler coordinates describe only some part of the whole space time (they cover only the Rindler Wedges), and still I have Unruh effect. So what I thought before cannot be the reason for the importance of the horizon. So I ask, what is the horizon function, both in Schwarzschild and Rindler space?
Answer
One should always be wary of argument that rely on coordinates, since they are just a tool to describe the spacetime. Rindler coordinates are somewhat convenient for accelerated observers but you can derive the Unruh effect in Minkowski coordinates just fine (this is done in the Review of Modern Physics on the Unruh effect, by Crispino, Matsas and Higuchi for instance).
To understand the importance of horizons we must consider what is a thermal bath. There are two ways to do so. The first one is to say that you know you are in a thermal bath if the expected value of the number operator is a thermal distribution. The second one is that a thermal bath is a mixed state whose density matrix is given by the Boltzmann form $e^{-\beta H}$. The second way implies the first, but the first does not imply the second, because you might have thermal distribution for the number operator but still have significant correlations between degrees of freedom such that the state is not strictly thermal.
In the first definition the horizons are not necessary, only that the trajectories of observers behave in such a way as to produce the thermal distribution in the number operator.
In the second definition the horizon does play a role. The Minkowski vacuum is a pure state but there is no transformation in quantum mechanics that send a pure state to a mixed state, in this case the thermal one. What does happen in the Unruh effect is that accelerated observers have a horizon separating them from the rest of spacetime. In other words there are degrees of freedom of the field inside the horizon which are not accessible to the observer. And in quantum mechanics whenever you do not have access to certain degrees of freedom you must trace over them in you current state. So given a Minkowski vacuum, if you trace over all degrees of freedom inside the horizon you get a thermal state of Boltzmann form.
In short, the horizon is relevant because it means there are degrees of freedom in the field which the observer cannot measure. The ignorance regarding this part of the field is what converts a pure state to a mixed state (in this case a thermal one)
No comments:
Post a Comment