Thursday, 10 August 2017

newtonian mechanics - When can one write a=vcdotdv/dx?


Referring to unidimensional motion, it is obvious that it doesn't always make sense to write the speed as a function of position. Seems to me that this is a necessary condition to derive formulas like:


v2=v20+2xx0adx


In fact, in the first step of the demonstration (the one I saw, but I think that this step is crucial) it's required to write a=dv/dt=(dv/dx)(dx/dt), that doesn't make sense if v isn't a function of x.


When can one rigorously write v=v(x)?



Answer



This is going to be essentially the same in content as Jerry Schirmer's response, but I thought you might like to hear it in more mathematical terms. The velocity function v is defined as v(t)=˙x(t) Let's take the domain of the position function to be the open interval (t1,t2) and suppose that it has the property that given any point x0 in the range of x, there is a unique point t0 in its domain (t1,t2) such that x(t0)=x0. Then there exists a function x1 (the inverse of x) defined on the range of x satisfying x1(x(t))=t Now we define a function ˉv on the range of x by ˉv(x)=v(x1(x)) It is common to abuse notation here and use v in place of ˉv for this function, but let's keep things notationaly rigorous. Then on one hand the chain rule gives ddtˉv(x(t))=dˉvdx(x(t))˙x(t)=dˉvdx(x(t))v(t) While on the other hand we use the definition of ˉv to write ddtˉv(x(t))=ddtv(x1(x(t)))=dvdt(t)=a(t) and combining these observations gives the identity you wanted a(t)=dˉvdx(x(t))v(t) Notice that if we indulge in the usual abuse of notation, then we can simply write this as a=vdvdx



No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...