Sunday 12 May 2019

electromagnetism - Resistance between two points on a conducting surface


Suppose we have a cylindrical resistor, with resistance given by $R=\rho\cdot l/(\pi r^2)$


Let $d$ be the distance between two points in the interior of the resistor and let $r\gg d\gg l$. Ie. it is approximately a 2D-surface (a rather thin disk).


What is the resistance between these two points?



Let $r,l\gg d$, (ie a 3D volume), is the resistance $0$ ?




Clarification: A voltage difference is applied between two points a distance $d$ apart, inside a material with resistivity $\rho$, and the current is measured, the proportionality constant $V/I$ is called $R$. The material is a cylinder of height $l$ and radius $r$, and the two points are situated close to the center, we can write $R$ as a function of $l$, $r$ and $d$, $R(l,r,d)$, for small $d$.


The questions are then:
What is $$ \lim_{r \rightarrow \infty} \lim_{l \rightarrow \infty} R(l,r,d) $$
What is $$ \lim_{r \rightarrow \infty} \lim_{l \rightarrow 0} R(l,r,d) $$



Answer



Potential for 2D problem


Let's start with a 2D disk and try to solve the general problem for infinitesimally flat disk. I will change notations a bit -- the surface resistance will be $\sigma$ and the radius of the disk will be $a$.


Starting with basic electrodynamics:



$\vec{j} = -\sigma\frac{\partial u}{\partial \vec{r}},\, div\vec{j}=0\,\Rightarrow\,\Delta u = 0$ with the boundary condition: $\vec{n}\cdot\vec{j} = 0 \Rightarrow \vec{n}\frac{\partial u}{\partial \vec{r}} = 0$


Let's first consider the current $I$ flowing into the surface in the centre and uniformly flowing away from the edges. solution for potential is well known:


$U(r,\phi) = -\frac{I}{2\pi\sigma}\, \ln r$


I use the conformal map $z\to a\frac{z-s}{a^2-s*z}$ to "shift the centre" into the point $s=x_{source}+iy_{source}$. The potential is then:


$U(r,\phi) = -\frac{I}{2\pi\sigma}\, \ln\left|a\frac{re^{i\phi}-s}{a^2-s^*re^{i\phi}}\right|$


Now I substract the similar potential, with different parameter $d=x_{drain}+iy_{drain}$ to compensate the outgoing flow. Obtaining:


$U(r,\phi) = -\frac{I}{2\pi\sigma}\, \ln\left|\frac{re^{i\phi}-s}{re^{i\phi}-d} \cdot\frac{a^2-d^*re^{i\phi}}{a^2-s^*re^{i\phi}}\right|$ or $U(z) = -\frac{I}{2\pi\sigma}\, \ln\left|\frac{z-s}{z-d} \cdot\frac{a^2-d^*z}{a^2-s^*z}\right|$


This is the harmonic function, satisfying the boundary conditions. You can play here with it.


Interpretation of the solution


The potential is divergent in points $s$ and $d$. This happens because the resistance is strongly dependend on the microscopic details of the problem. Indeed -- as you get closer to the source -- all your current have to pass through smaller and smaller amount of conductor. And in the limit of infinitely small source you get infinite resistance.



Formulation issue


I admit that while solving I first fixed the current and then found the potential, while you formulated the problem differently -- "set the potential here and there and find the current". But let us use logic:



  1. Nonzero current leads to infinite voltage: $I\neq0\,\Rightarrow\,\Delta U \to \infty$.

  2. If $A\Rightarrow B$, then $!B\Rightarrow !A$.

  3. $\Delta U\mbox{-finite}\,\Rightarrow\,I=0$


At finite voltage you'll get zero current or, equivalently, infinite resistance.


What happens in 3D case?


Same thing. Just consider single pointlike source -- and the potential $U\sim\frac{1}{r}$ is divergent. Don't need to go into further details.



"Cutoffs"


In order to move on I introduce the "cutoffs" -- new small (real) quantities $\epsilon_{s,d}$ which denoting "sizes" of the source and the drain. Using them I obtain the voltage:


$U(d+\epsilon_d)-U(s+\epsilon_s)=\frac{I}{2\pi\sigma}\left[\ln\frac{\epsilon_s}{|s-d|}+\ln\frac{\epsilon_d}{|s-d|} +\ln\left|\frac{a^2-s^*d}{a^2-|s|^2}\cdot\frac{a^2-sd^*}{a^2-|d|^2}\right|\right]$


Scales


Putting together everything above. One can say that in the problem there are four (or, even five) scales:



  1. Radius of the disk.

  2. Thickness of the disk.

  3. Distance between contacts $|s-d|$

  4. Sizes of those contacts $\epsilon_{s,d}$



Since you are talking about "points" -- then first we have to take $\epsilon_{s,d}\to0$, right? But if $\epsilon_{s,d}$ is much smaller that any other scale then they introduce divergent contribution into the resistance. And any other detail of the problem becomes irrelevant.


Therefore, the answer to your question is: The resistance between two points is infinite, whatever the geometry of the problem is.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...