While deriving Hamiltonian from Lagrangian density, we use the formula H = π˙ϕ−L.
But since we are considering space and time as parameters, why the formula H = πμ∂μϕ−Lis not used?Is there any particular book/lecture notes dealing with these kind of issues in theoretical physics, I would love to know them?
Answer
Vladimir's answer has the right essence but it is also misleading, so let me clarify.
The formula H=∑ipi˙qi−L
When you have field theory, both the Hamiltonian and the Lagrangian may be written as spatial integrals of their densities. H=∫d3xH,L=∫d3xL
However, what's wrong about your reasoning is the assumption that both the Hamiltonian density and the Lagrangian density are Lorentz-invariant. While the Lagrangian density is a nice scalar, so it is Lorentz-invariant (the density at the origin, at least), and it's because the integral of it is the Lorentz-invariant action which should be stationary, the same is not true for the Hamiltonian and its density.
The Hamiltonian is intrinsically linked to the time direction: it is the generator of the translations in time (the spatial counterparts of the Hamiltonian are the spatial components of the momentum); it is the energy, the 0th component of a 4-vector, H≡p0. So the argument that this formula should be Lorentz-covariant is invalid, your proposed formula is wrong, and the right formula was justified at the beginning of my comment.
No comments:
Post a Comment