Friday, 10 January 2020

special relativity - Appearance of an angle of inclination on a horizontal rod moving upwards after a Lorentz Transformation



If i have in one inertial reference frame called S:(x,y,z,t) a rod with lenght l in the plane z=0 and parallel with the x axis, moving with a velocity u in the direction of the y axis, so i think therefore that the extreme points of the rod can be given in S by P1:(x1,y1,z1,t1)=(x1,ut1,z1,t1)

P2:(x2,y2,z2,t2)=(x1+l,ut1,z1,t1)


Given that there is a inertial reference frame S:(x,y,z,t) ; in relation to which the reference frame S is moving with velocity v in the x direction, and such that in the time t=0 both reference frames coincided, and after that, the z axis continued parallel to the z axis as did the y axis parallel to y axis and the x axis continued in the same direction as the x axis.


So to get the points P1 and P2 in the frame S i tried to do the lorentz inverse transform in each point as it is shown bellow:


P1P1{x1=γ(x1+vt1)y1=y1=ut1z1=z1t1=γ(t1+vc2x1)


P2P2{x2=γ((x1+l)+vt2)=γ((x1+l)+vt1)y2=y2=ut2=ut1z2=z2=z1t2=γ(t2+vc2(x1+l))=γ(t1+vc2(x1+l))


But then if t2=t1 there would be no y axis inclination as the problem sugests, what i am doing wrong ?



Answer




Hint : We have here 3 frames and 2 Lorentz Transformations. (1) Frame S(x,y,z) (2) frame S(x,y,z) moving with respect to S(x,y,z) with velocity v=(v,0,0) along the common x,xaxis (3) frame S(x,y,z), the rest frame of the rod, moving with respect to S(x,y,z) with velocity u=(0,u,0) along the common y,yaxis.


I suggest to take a look in my answer therein : General matrix Lorentz transformation




EDIT


We have here two 2+1-Lorentz transformations. So the axes z,z,z are ignored.


enter image description here


From Figure 01 :


Lorentz Transformation from S{xyη,η=ct} to S{xyη,η=ct} [xyη]=[coshζ0sinhζ010sinhζ0coshζ][xyη],tanhζ=vc

or X=LX,L=[coshζ0sinhζ010sinhζ0coshζ]


enter image description here


From Figure 02:



Lorentz Transformation from S{xyη,η=ct} to S{xyη,η=ct} [xyη]=[1000coshξsinhξ0sinhξcoshξ][xyη],tanhξ=uc

or X=LX,L=[1000coshξsinhξ0sinhξcoshξ]
Note that because of the Standard Configurations the matrices L,L are real symmetric.


From equations (01) and (02) we have X=LX=LLXX=ΛX

where Λ the composition of the two Lorentz Transformations L,L Λ=LL=[1000coshξsinhξ0sinhξcoshξ][coshζ0sinhζ010sinhζ0coshζ]
that is Λ=[coshζ0sinhζsinhζsinhξcoshξcoshζsinhξsinhζcoshξsinhξcoshζcoshξ]


In the following it's necessary to have the inverse transformation Λ1 which could be determined from : Λ1=L1L1

For the inverse transformations L1,L1 we have respectively L(ζ)=[coshζ0sinhζ010sinhζ0coshζ]L1=L(ζ)=[coshζ0sinhζ010sinhζ0coshζ]
L(ξ)=[1000coshξsinhξ0sinhξcoshξ]L1=L(ξ)=[1000coshξsinhξ0sinhξcoshξ]
so Λ1=[coshζ0sinhζ010sinhζ0coshζ][1000coshξsinhξ0sinhξcoshξ]=[coshζsinhζsinhξsinhζcoshξ0coshξsinhξsinhζcoshζsinhξcoshζcoshξ]


We need also the velocity vector, let w, of the translational motion of the frame S(x,y) with respect to the frame S(x,y). This vector is the relativistic sum of two orthogonal velocity vectors v=(υ,0),u=(0,u)(1)
w=v+uγυ=[υ,(1υ2c2)12u],γυ=(1υ2c2)12=coshζ

not to be confused with the relativistic sum of two collinear velocity vectors pointing to the same direction wυ+u1+υuc2
From (09) we have wxc=υc=tanhζwyc=uγυc=tanhξcoshζ(wc)2=(wxc)2+(wyc)2=1(1coshζcoshξ)2=γ2w1γ2wγw=(1w2c2)12=coshζcoshξ=γυγu


Now, let a rod of length at rest in frame S parallel to the xaxis, see Figure 03. The end points of the rod are observed in S simultaneously at a given time moment t so we have two events 1 and 2 separated by the space-time vector ΔX=[ΔxΔyΔη]=[x2x1y2y1c(t2t1)]=[00]


enter image description here


In frame S the two events are observed as two events 1 and 2 separated by the space-time vector ΔX=[ΔxΔyΔη]=[x2x1y2y1c(t2t1)]

which is connected with ΔX by the Λ1 transformation ΔX=Λ1ΔX
From equations (08) and (12) we have [ΔxΔyΔη]=[coshζsinhζsinhξsinhζcoshξ0coshξsinhξsinhζcoshζsinhξcoshζcoshξ][00]
so Δx=coshζ,Δy=0,Δη=cΔt=sinhζ


enter image description here


Equation (16) is represented in Figure 04. But this view is not a snapshot of the rod at a given time moment t in S(x,y). To the contrary, it's a montage of snapshots of the points along the rod, each point shown at its own time moment. So, the end 1 of the rod is shown on its position at the time moment t1, the end 2 of the rod is shown on its position at the time moment t2 and an intermediate point 3 with coordinate x3[x1,x2] at the time moment t3 t3=t1+x3x1x2x1(t2t1)

To observe the rod at a given time moment t in S(x,y), for example at t1, we must return the end point 2 from its position at time t2 to its position at time t1 since 1 is already shown at time t1.



enter image description here


This is done in Figure 05. Since the rod is in translational motion with velocity vector w in frame S(x,y), the two positions of 2 at time moments t1,t2 are separated by the vector w(t2t1) and from equations (11.1),(11.2),(16) we have wΔt=wcΔη=(wxc,wyc)sinhζ=(tanhζ,tanhξcoshζ)sinhζ

so wΔt=(sinhζtanhζ,tanhζtanhξ)
From details in Figure 05 about the lengths of line segments tanθ=tanhζtanhξcoshζ=sinhζtanhξ
but sinhζ=coshζγυtanhζυ/c=γυυc,tanhξ=uc
so tanθ=γυυuc2=(1υ2c2)12υuc2
For the length S of the inclined rod in frame S we have from the orthogonal triangle in Figure 05 2S=(coshζ)2+(tanhζtanhξ12)2=[1υ2c2(1u2c2)]2
so S=1υ2c2(1u2c2)


From (22) and (24) we have verifications of the following two special cases :




  1. If u=0 then θ=0, the rod is moving parallel to the xaxis with speed υ , contracted from to /coshζ.




  2. If υ=0 then θ=0, the rod is parallel to the xaxis with unchanged length moving in the direction of the yaxis with speed u.







Numerical Examples : {υ/c=0.60u/c=0.40}===={tanθ=0.30θ=16.70oS=0.835}


{υ/c=0.80u/c=0.60}===={tanθ=1.00θ=45.00oS=0.768}


{υ/c1u/c1}===={tanθ+tanθθ90.00oS}!!!!!!




(1) We can derive equations (11.1),(11.2) for the components of the velocity vector w using the Lorentz transformation L1 between frames S,S instead of equation (09)(the last is given without proof and comes from on a general 3+1-Lorentz Transformation)


So, suppose that the origin O of frame S is a particle moving in frame S with velocity vector
u=(dxdt,dydt)=(0,u)

From equation (06) for the Lorentz transformation L1 [dxdydη]=[coshζ0sinhζ010sinhζ0coshζ][dxdydη]
dx=coshζdx+sinhζdηdy=dydη=sinhζdx+coshζdη
dividing (ft-03a) and (ft-03b) by (ft-03c) dxdη=coshζdx+sinhζdηsinhζdx+coshζdη=coshζ(dxdη)+sinhζsinhζ(dxdη)+coshζdydη=dysinhζdx+coshζdη=(dydη)sinhζ(dxdη)+coshζ
From (ft-01) having in mind that η=ct,η=ct dxdη=0,dydη=uc=tanhξ
Inserting expressions (ft-05) in (ft-04a,b) we have finally wxc=dxdη=tanhζ=υcwyc=dydη=tanhξcoshζ=uγυc





------Figure 06 : The Length------ Figure 07 : The Angle------


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...