Monday, 20 January 2020

symmetry - Lagrangian is isotropic in space


In Landau & Lifshitz Mechanics, while deriving the properties of Lagrangian of a free particle in inertial frame, he uses the following points $:$




  1. As space is homogeneous in inertial frame, a particle will follow same law of motion at 10 m from origin as it would follow at 5 m. Since equation of motion is contained in $L$, hence $L$ should be independent of radius vector $\vec{r}$.




  2. Similarly, since the $L$ of the particle should behave in the same manner regardless of the time I measure it, it is therefore independent of the current time $t$.





  3. Now since space is isotropic, $L$ should be independent of velocity $\vec{v}$, and should in fact be a function of $\lvert\vec{v}\rvert^2$.




In point 3) I have a problem in conceptually understanding it. For me isotropic means that all directions are the same, so for a given position of a particle, if I measure it from some angle $\theta$ and again at some other angle $\phi$, then the $L$ obtained in both the cases will be same. But what I think the author is trying to say is that a particle moving in a certain direction given by $\vec{v_1}$ is the same as it's movement in another direction given as $\vec{v_2}$ if $\lvert\vec{v_1}\rvert = \lvert\vec{v_2}\rvert$


First of all, I don't think it should be same, because I don't think it is equivalent to isotropic of space. Morover if I have to say such a thing about $L$ dependence on $\lvert\vec{v}\rvert$, then I think I could argue it with homogeneity of space hence not requiring the isotropic principal (again I think isotropic is contained in homogeneity in general).


In a nutshell I want to understand the application of isotropic of space in inferring the $\lvert\vec{v}\rvert^2$ depedence of $L$.



Answer



The general idea is that if the laws governing the system are independent on some parameter that may be





  1. distance of experiment from origin $r$ (not $\vec r$ by the way)




  2. time of experiment $t$




  3. direction of experiment $(θ, φ)$




then the Lagrangian should be independent on that parameter.



In the case of point 3, that means specifically that L might be any function of the magnitude of the velocity $\left| \vec v \right|$ , but must not depend on the direction of $\vec v$.


Of course, "any function of $\left| \vec v \right|$" and "any function of $v^2$" are mathematically equivalent.


As an aside, any such independence on some parameter implies, per Noether's wonderful theorem, to a conservation law : here 1) momentum, 2) energy, 3) angular momentum.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...