Thursday, 1 January 2015

string theory - How Exactly Does Linear Regge Trajectories Imply Stability?


(for a more muddled version, see physics.stackexchange: What's with Mandelstam's argument that only linear regge trajectories are stable?)


There is a 1974 argument of Mandelstam's that linear Regge trajectories implies stability, from "Dual-Resonance Models" from 1974, sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0370157374900349. Expand the Regge trajectory function $\alpha(s)$ in a dispersion relation with two subtractions:


$$ \alpha(s) = b + as + {1\over i\pi} \int_0^\infty {\mathrm{Im}(\alpha(s'))\over s-s'} ds'$$


The imaginary part of $\alpha(s)$ gives the decay of the string states, since where it hits an integer tells you where the poles are. So if the string resonances are exactly stable, then the imaginary part is zero, and the trajectory is linear.


This argument bugged me for these reasons:




  • It seems to work just as well with two subtractions, three subtractions, etc. Can you conclude that exactly quadratic or exactly cubic Regge trajectories are also stable? What is a quadratic or cubic trajectory?

  • The Regge trajectory function appears in the exponent, so you have to take a log to extract it. Why is it clear that it has a representation like the above, without a cut contribution at negative s?

  • In string theory, the trajectories are linear when they are long-lived, but the trajectory function doesn't look as fundamental today. Is there a more modern formulation of this, which would tell you which string limits are non-interacting just from a condition on the spectrum?


Mandelstam generously emailed me a short remark, saying essentially that the trajectory function imaginary part is a lifetime, and indeed this is obvious from the fact that it gives the position of the resonances, but I am still confused regarding the questions above.


Even a partial answer would be appreciated.




special relativity - Effects of FTL travel on time




The twin paradox explains, using relativity theory, what happens to a person travelling close to the speed of light. When he returns to Earth, he finds his twin brother much older because the traveller's clock moved slower. If we took this example to an extreme, what would happen if the traveller went FTL speed? Would he get younger? How do I write down, mathematically, the equations to solve this problem? (I know it is physically impossible, but it should be mathematically possible.)



Answer



If we fix a coordinate frame on the Earth, where the stationary twin is living, then the trajectory of the travelling twin in four-dimensional spacetime forms a line called the world line. If we assume the travelling twin heads out then back along the $x$ axis (so we can ignore $y$ and $z$) then the world line looks something like:


Twin


The elapsed time measured by the travelling twin is called the proper time, $\tau$, and is simply the length of the world line i.e. the length of the blue line. However we have to calculate this length using the Minkowski metric (again supressing the $y$ and $z$ axes):


$$ c^2d\tau^2 = c^2dt^2 - dx^2 $$


We need to integrate this equation to get $\tau$, and we do it by rearranging to give:


$$ \tau = \int_A^B \sqrt{1 - \frac{v^2(t)}{c^2}} \, dt \tag{1} $$


where we have used the fact that $dx/dt$ is simply the coordinate velocity $v$ - note that the velocity is a function of time. To calculate the elapsed time for the twin simply choose your form for $v(t)$ and do the integral.



By now (I hope) you're thinking that this turned out to be surprisingly simple, and indeed it is pretty straightforward. It also shows us immediately why you can't have a coordinate velocity faster than light. If $v \gt c$ then $v^2/c^2 \gt 1$ and consequently $1-v^2/c^2 \lt 0$. This means you have to take the square root of a negative number and the elapsed time becomes imaginary. But the elapsed time is a real scalar - it is literally just the time shown on a clock carried by the travelling twin - so it can't be imaginary.


It is, as you say, mathematically possible to do the calculation for an FTL trajectory, but it gives a physically meaningless result.


measurements - Confusion with regards to uncertainty calculations


Let’s say we have a scenario of a ball being released from the top of the building. This can be modeled simply with the kinematics equation $S=ut +\frac{1}{2}at^2$, which reduced to $S=\frac{1}{2}at^2$. We are given $\Delta t, t, \Delta S, S$, are we are to find $a, \Delta a$.


Firstly, I have no problems calculating the absolute portion of the uncertainty.


Here is my problem: Differentiating $S=\frac{1}{2}at^2$ gives me $\frac{\Delta S}{S}=\frac{\Delta a}{a}+2\frac{\Delta t}{t}$. However, substituting these values gives me a wrong value of $\Delta a$.


The correct approach should have been to rearrange the equation to $a=\frac{2S}{t^2}$, and then solve $\frac{\Delta a}{a}=\frac{\Delta S}{S}+2\frac{\Delta t}{t}$. As can be seen, there appears a contradiction.


Further substitution of $S=82m,\Delta S=1m,t=4.1s, \Delta t=0.2s$ to solve for $a, \Delta a$ using the second equation and then putting this value back into the first gives me a contradiction.


I would like to know which one is correct and which should be used because both seem correct to me.


I have discovered that the addition/subtraction of uncertainties is as follows. Let’s say $(A\pm\Delta A)+(B\pm\Delta B)=(C\pm\Delta C)$.


Then $C_{max}=(A+\Delta A)+(B+\Delta B), C_{min}=(A-\Delta A)+(B-\Delta B)$. Referring back to the definition of uncertainty, $C+\Delta C$ is the average of the minimum and maximum of $C$, thus giving us $C=A+B$ and $\Delta C=\Delta A+\Delta B$.



Using this principle, I am however confused by what I get. $C_{max}=(A+\Delta A)(B+\Delta B), C_{min}=(A-\Delta A)(B-\Delta B)$. Expanding, I got $C=AB +\Delta A\Delta B$, which was contradictory to what I have learnt. I got $\Delta C=A\Delta B + B\Delta A$, which was correct though... This raises a new problem, as I am now unsure as to why the rule applies to multiplication.



Answer



So I am pretty sure the difference between your two equations depends on what you actually measured and what you are calculating from those measurements.


Think of it this way: One of your two equations (before your addition to the question), tells you how to calculate an uncertainty from the uncertainties of your measurements. In other words, these equations are not relationships between any uncertainties you want. You use the measured quantities on the right to find the uncertainty of the value on the left. You never actually measured the value on the left. (Although if you did a different experiment to directly measure the value on the left, then you would want it to be consistent with said calculations).


newtonian mechanics - Why does locking the rear tires on a vehicle cause it to spin?



Handbrake Turns are often used in motor-sports and stunt driving to turn around tight corners. Essentially, the driver applies the handbrake as he enters the turn, in order to "kick out" the back end and slide the vehicle around the corner.


However, applying the handbrake hard enough to lock the rear wheels while traveling straight will cause the rear of the vehicle to "kick out". Given enough speed, the vehicle will spin 180 degrees.


Why do sliding wheels on a car want to "get in front" of rolling wheels?



Answer



They don't want to get in front of the rolling wheels -- at least, not intrinsically.


When you are turning, your front wheels stop going forwards so much, and start going sideways. As Newton taught us, a great way to think about such things is that an object in motion will tend to keep moving however it is moving. There are sideways forces on the front wheels created by the friction of the wheels with the ground, slowing down its forward speed, and transferring that into sideways speed. So that's how "objects keep moving" works out for the front side of your car: forces act on it to stop its forward motion and create sideways motion. Now let's examine how this principle works for the backside of your car.


Normally, there is an "easy direction" for the back of your car to move -- in the direction of the wheels -- and a "hard direction" to move -- perpendicular to that direction. This creates side-forces which keep your rear wheels "following" your front wheels. They have a less-steep turn than the front wheels but also they start acting a few meters before the front wheels do, so they tend to take turns tighter, which is why it's harder, e.g., to forwards-perpendicular-park on your right rather than your left (if you've just been succeeding unconsciously or always back-in: when you forwards-perpendicular-park to the right, you usually have to swerve left pre-emptively to give your rear wheels room to take the turn, because taking that turn tighter than the front wheels would otherwise mean hitting the car occupying the spot 1 before the one you want to park in).


When you pull the handbrake, or your rear wheels hit ice, hydroplane, or go airborne, you set these two directions on equal footing: your rear wheels then are not so well "guided" by these side forces, and mostly just want to keep going forward, with a slight pull induced by the front tires. Even worse, as @BillN notes, they now have a lower coefficient of friction than those stabilizing forces did, so slowing them down to rest becomes harder.


In the worst case, the front wheels stop their forward motion entirely while the rear wheels are still sliding. The ensuing driver panic usually means that they stop doing whatever they were doing, and brake: the rear wheels will then pull the car entirely around until the front wheels stop the slide. This is, you guessed it, why it turns 180 degrees and not some other number like 270 or such.[1]


In the case of a handbrake turn, the front wheels follow a curve that is so tight that would cause the back wheels, since they take the turn tighter, to hit the curb or worse. Allowing the rear wheels to slide in the forward direction of motion means that they instead "kick out" (keep going in a straight line rather than following the curve of the front wheels), effectively pivoting the car about its front wheels. So the mechanism is not special: it is just that things which have forward momentum need forces to guide them off of it, and the strong forces which keep the backside of the car guided towards the front have been exchanged for weaker forces which slow down the backside of the car without having a preferred direction.




  1. Yes, this happens on snow or when the rear wheels are underinflated and hydroplane. As an anecdote: When I was practicing for my driver's license we did some snow driving, because my Dad wanted me to be prepared for anything. I actually saw someone start fishtailing on slushy snow and slowed way the hell down myself, and the event indeed ended with traffic stopped and the poor dude was faced backwards, and we were looking face-to-face. He was ghost-white and I was pretty awestruck by the dangers of driving.


newtonian mechanics - Why do objects move when you apply a force that's equal in magnitude to the friction?



If the friction on an object is 200 N and you apply 200 N, it seems, the forces should immediately cancel each other out since the friction and your applied force go in opposite directions, leaving you with an object that is motionless. Yet, from what I've read, that's not the case. I feel like I'm misunderstanding something. Could it be I'm wrong about needing to apply 200 N initially? Might the amount of force I actually need be greater, but instantaneously decrease to 200 N?





electric circuits - Differential resistance vs. $R = frac{U}{I}$


Resistance is defined as $R = \frac{U}{I}$. If Ohm's law holds, $U(I)$ is a linear function and the slope of the curve is equal to the resistance $R$.


I realized only recently that if $U(I)$ is a non-linear function, the slope of the function is no longer equal to the resistance as defined above. We then have two kinds of resistances:




  • the differential resistance $r(I) = \frac{d U}{d I} (I)$ (which is equal to the slope of the curve at the point $I$)




  • "ordinary" resistance $R(I) = \frac{U(I)}{I}$.





My questions:



  • Is the quotient $R(I) = \frac{U(I)}{I}$ used to describe devices with non-linear current-voltage characteristics at all? (I am aware of the fact that $R$ isn't a property of the device in this case but it may still be a sensible concept)

  • If both $R(I)$ and $r(I)$ are used, when do I use which one?

  • What can we say about the relationship of the two quantities in general?


Example: Let's have a look at the current-voltage characteristic of a tunnel diode (see image below, taken from Wikipedia). I am not really familiar with how this device operates but it illustrates my question. For "ordinary resistance", we have $R(i_1) = \frac{v_1}{i_1} \ll R(i_2) = \frac{v_2}{i_2} $ while for the differential resistance we have $r(i_1) = r(i_2) = 0$ (/edit: As freecharly noted, this is wrong. Actually, we have $r(i_1) = r(i_2) = \infty)$


So there's some justification to say that if we apply the constant voltage $v_2$ that the resistance is bigger than the resistance if we apply the constant voltage $v_1$, and there's also some justification to say that the resistance is zero infinity in both cases. How is the termonology actually used?


enter image description here



/edit: I edited the phrasing of the question and included an example in order to make things more clear.




mathematical physics - Infinitely many planets on a line, with Newtonian gravity


(I apologize if this question is too theoretical for this site.)


This is related to the answer here, although I came up with it independently of that. $\:$ Suppose we
have a unit mass planet at each integer point in 1-d space. $\:$ As described in that answer, the sum
of the forces acting on any particular planet is absolutely convergent. $\;\;$ Suppose we move planet_0
to point $\epsilon$, where $\: 0< \epsilon< \frac12 \:$. $\;\;$ For similar reasons, those sums will still be absolutely convergent.
Now we let Newtonian gravity apply. $\:$ What will happen?



If it's unclear what an answer might look like, you could consider the following more specific questions:

planet_0 will start out moving right, and all of the other planets will start out moving to the left.

Will there be a positive amount of time before any of them turn around?
(As opposed to, for example, each planet_n for $\: n\neq 0 \:$ turning around at time 1/|n|.)


Will there be a positive amount of time before any collisions occur?


"Obviously" (at least, I hope I'm right), planet_0 will collide with planet_1. $\:$ Will that be the first collision?


How long will it be before there are any collisions? $\:\:$ (perhaps just an approximation for small $\:\epsilon\:$)



Answer



The acceleration of planet number $n$ except for the planet $0$ will go like $-1/n^3$ because the shift of planet $0$ from zero to $\epsilon$ is equivalent to adding a "dipole" (a pair of positive and negative mass, relatively shifted) at the location $0$ relatively to the balanced (but unstable) uniform chain and this dipole acts with inverse cube, instead of the inverse law.


We see that indeed the planets $+1$ and $-1$ are most affected and fastest to get some acceleration. However, planet $-1$ will move to the left, away from a potential collision. Nevertheless, planet $-2$ is trying to escape from planet $-1$, although by a smaller speed, but that will be enough to guarantee that the $0-1$ collision will be the first one. Other collisions will follow. You may numerically simulate it – the problem isn't integrable even for small $\epsilon$, I think, simply because you're interested in the moments when the distance $\epsilon$ grew to a large number $O(1)$, anyway.


Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...