Friday, 2 October 2015

quantum mechanics - Creating a QM state of definite position in Fock space


I'm wondering if somebody could help me to finish a simple calculation. Let me first provide motivation for the question below: I would like to write a QM amplitude in the 'QFT-style', as $$\langle \phi_2 (t_2) \phi_1(t_1) \rangle = \langle 0 | \hat{\phi}_2(0) \operatorname{e}^{-i H (t_2 - t_1)} \hat{\phi}_1 | 0 \rangle $$ Here I assumed that $\hat{\phi}_{1,2}$ are Hermitean, which in general does not necessary have to be true.


OK, now the question: I would like to know which operator creates the position eigenstates in QM. Here's my attempt to find its matrix elements in the position representation: \begin{gather} \hat{\mathcal{O}} |0\rangle = |x\rangle \qquad \text{(by definition)}\\ \langle x'| \hat{\mathcal{O}} |0\rangle = \langle x'|x\rangle = \delta(x-x')\\ \int \operatorname{d}x''\langle x'| \hat{\mathcal{O}} |x''\rangle \langle x''|0\rangle =\delta(x-x')\\ \end{gather}


Here comes the dependency on Hamiltonian - we can proceed no further without specifying the particular form of $H$, and so of $\langle x'' | 0 \rangle$. Of course, for simplicity we begin with the harmonic oscillator.


$$\langle x | 0 \rangle = \pi^{-1/4} \operatorname{e}^{-x^2/2}$$


Where I chose $\dfrac{m \omega}{\hbar} = 1$ for convenience. Hence, one gets: $$\pi^{-1/4}\int \operatorname{d}x''\langle x'| \hat{\mathcal{O}} |x''\rangle \operatorname{e}^{-(x'')^2/2} =\delta(x-x')\\ $$


Can anyone help me to find $\langle x'| \hat{\mathcal{O}} |x''\rangle $? For sure, I don't expect $\hat{\mathcal{O}}$ to be a 'nice' operator, since it does not define a properly normalised state. I expect it to be some kind of distribution, whose kernel I would like to know.



UPDATE 1


Few clarifications about the statement of the question:



  • The question is about a $1$-d QM problem, with a single degree of freedom. In principle, it is NOT related to QFT.

  • Starting from the line where I chose the particular form of Hamiltonian (QHO) and of the ground state, the definition of vacuum is $\hat{a} |0\rangle = 0$, where $\hat{a}$ is the usual QHO annihilation operator.


UPDATE 2


@AccidentalFourierTransform has suggested the following: $$\langle x' |\hat{\mathcal{O}} | x''\rangle= \pi^{1/4} \operatorname{e}^{+(x'')^2/2} \operatorname{e}^{i x'' (x-x')} / (2\pi) $$


Being substituted into the previous line, this clearly leads to the correct result. Now my question is whether such definition can indeed define a (nice at least in certain sense) operator. What confuses me is the factor $\operatorname{e}^{+(x'')^2/2}$ together with the fact that we are integrating over $x''$.



Answer




Well, you asked for a start, not a nice operator---but I suspect some coherent state/displacement operator review or paper has it nicely. I hasten to frame the issue, and you might choose to carry it out more efficiently.


You are seeking a representation-changing operator $\hat{\mathcal{O}}(x)$ taking you from Fock states (eigenstates of the number/energy operator) to eigenstates of the position operator $\hat{X}$ with eigenvalue x. The operator will be a function of x and creation operators.


I use the conventions of Sakurai & Napolitano, QM, (2.3.21), $$ |n\rangle= \frac{a^{\dagger ~n}}{\sqrt{n!}} |0\rangle $$ and, significantly, since you are using the entire Fock space,(2.3.32), $$ \langle n| x \rangle= \frac{1}{\pi^{1/4}\sqrt{2^n~n!}}~ (x-\partial_x)^n~ e^{-x^2/2} ~. $$


You then posit your basis change, $$ |x\rangle= \hat{\mathcal{O}}(x) |0\rangle= \sum_0^\infty c_n (x) |n\rangle, $$ and use the above relation, as you did for n=0 to determine the coefficients c(x).


The good news is that the answer, $$ |x\rangle= \sum_0^\infty \frac{1}{\pi^{1/4}} ~ \frac {(x-\partial_x)^n a^{\dagger ~n}}{2^{n/2} n!} e^{-x^2/2 }|0\rangle $$ exponentiates, as often, $$ \hat{\mathcal{O}}(x)= \frac{1}{\pi^{1/4}} e^{(x-\partial_x)~ a^\dagger /\sqrt{2} } ~ e^{-x^2/2 }, $$ and the exponential of operators is straightforward to split by use of the degenerate CBH identity, since $[x,-\partial] =1$, so $\exp(-a^{\dagger ~2}/4) \exp(xa^\dagger/\sqrt{2})\exp(-a^\dagger \partial_x /\sqrt{2})$ and thus you get the exponential of the gradient ∂ on the right, thus a translation operator: it translates the exponent of the x-Gaussian to $-(x-a^\dagger/\sqrt{2})^2/2$, so, finally, $$ \hat{\mathcal{O}}(x)= \frac{1}{\pi^{1/4}} e^{-x^2/2} e^{\sqrt{2} xa^\dagger} e^{-a^{\dagger ~2}/2} =\frac{e^{x^2/2}}{\pi^{1/4}} e^{-(a^\dagger-\sqrt{2} x)^2/2} . $$ As a lark, you may check that, since $a$ acts as a derivation w.r.t. $a^\dagger$, $$ \frac{(a+a^\dagger)}{\sqrt 2} ~\hat{\mathcal{O}}(x) |0\rangle= x~\hat{\mathcal{O}}(x) |0\rangle ~, $$ so an eigenstate of $\hat{X}$.


I have not checked the delta-orthogonality of $\langle y|x\rangle$ states here.


Edit: I found out today that this is but Prob. 14.4.a) of M Schwartz's book on QFT. In any case, working out the <x|p> in 312004 yields the plane wave, and inserting complete momentum states and integrating over them trivially produces the δ-function normalization $\langle y| x\rangle\propto \delta(x-y)$ sought.


Edit II: This is, in fact, reducible to the celebrated Segal-Bargmann transform, Def 2 & Corollary 1, should you wish to pursue it more formally and stick labels on it.


Edit III : I am being repeatedly asked about the connection of this oscillator vacuum $|0\rangle$ to the translationally invariant vacuum of Dirac's book, the awesome standard ket, $\lim_{p\to 0} |p\rangle\equiv |\varpi\rangle$, for which $\hat{p} |\varpi \rangle =0$ and $\langle x | \varpi\rangle=1/\sqrt{2\pi \hbar}$, as well as $\langle x | \hat{x}|\varpi\rangle=x/\sqrt{2\pi \hbar}$.


The relation is actually $|\varpi\rangle= \exp (a^\dagger a^\dagger /2) |0\rangle /(\pi \hbar)^{1/4}$, implicit in the above, but evident in this obscurely placed answer. By inspection, this state is in the kernel of $\sqrt{2} \hat{p}=a-a^\dagger$.



Thursday, 1 October 2015

energy - What is the symmetry which is responsible for conservation of mass?


According to Noether's theorem, all conservation laws originate from invariance of a system to shifts in a certain space. For example conservation of energy stems from invariance to time translation.


What kind of symmetry creates the conservation of mass?



Answer



Mass is only conserved in the low-energy limit of relativistic systems. In relativistic systems, mass can be converted into energy, and you can have processes like massive electron-positron pairs annhillating to form massless photons.


What is conserved (in theories obeying special relativity, at least) is mass energy--this conservation is enforced by the time and space translation invariance of the theory. Since the amount of energy in the mass dominates the amount of energy in kinetic energy ($mc^{2}$ means a lot of energy is stored even in a small mass) for nonrelativistic motion, you get a very good approximation of mass conservation. out of the energy conservation.


quantum field theory - Srednicki's Path Integrals: Ground-State to Ground-State Transition Amplitude in the Presence of a Perturbation


Srednicki's Quantum Field Theory mentions the following at the end of the unit on path integrals in non-relativistic quantum mechanics:


Assume that the total Hamiltonian is of the form,



$$ H = H_0 + H_1, $$



where $H_0$ is the exactly solvable part and $H_1$ is treated as a perturbation.


Without the presence of the perturbation, the ground-state t0 ground-state transition amplitude in the presence of external forces/classical sources is:




$$ \langle 0 | 0 \rangle_{f,h} = \int \mathcal{D}p \; \mathcal{D}q \; \exp \Bigg [i \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} dt \; (p\dot{q} - (1- i\epsilon)H_{0} + fq + h p \Bigg ]. \tag{6.21} $$



In the presence of the perurbation, the amplitude is now given by:


enter image description here


Questions:


1) To get equation $(6.22)$, how can we take the exponential inside the integral, make the necessary manipulations and then take the exponential outside the integral. This seems very ad-hoc to me. How and when do we know that the these steps are valid? Doesn't this required justification from mathematical analysis?


2) More importantly, I don't get the first term involving the perturbing Hamiltonian. Why do we have functional derivatives in its argument? How did it come out to be? Why don't we similarly have functional derivatives in the argument of $H_0$ as well? What's the distinction?


Note: The factor of $(1 - i \epsilon)$ has been suppressed in $(6.22)$.



Answer






  1. First of all, note that a general mathematically rigorous definition of functional integrals is a well-known open problem in mathematics. One route is to try to construct the functional integral as an appropriate continuum limit of a lattice model over a discretized space-time $M$.




  2. If we for simplicity write the phase space coordinates collectively as $z^I:=\{q^i; p_i\}$; the sources as $j_I:=\{f_i; h^i\}$; and the action $$S[z]~=~S_0[z]+S_1[z], $$ $$ S_0[z]~=~ \int_{\mathbb{R}} \! dt \left(p_i\dot{q}^i - H_0\right), \qquad S_1[z]~=~ -\int_{\mathbb{R}} \! dt~H_1; \tag{A}$$ then we may formally write eqs. (6.21) and (6.22) as $$ Z[j]~=~\int \!{\cal D}z~e^{\frac{i}{\hbar}S_0[z]} \exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} S_1[z]\right\} \exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} \int_{\mathbb{R}} \! dt ~j_I z^I \right\} \tag {6.21}$$ $$~=~ \int \!{\cal D}z~e^{\frac{i}{\hbar}S_0[z]} \exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} S_1\left[\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\delta}{\delta j}\right]\right\} \exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} \int_{\mathbb{R}} \! dt ~j_I z^I \right\} $$ $$ ~=~\exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} S_1\left[\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\delta}{\delta j}\right]\right\} \int \!{\cal D}z~e^{\frac{i}{\hbar}S_0[z]} \exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} \int_{\mathbb{R}} \! dt ~j_I z^I \right\}.\tag {6.22}$$ In the last step we pulled a factor (that doesn't depend on the functional integral variable $z^I$) outside of the functional integral.




  3. The reason of the appearance of functional derivatives has to do with infinitely many degrees of freedom in field theory. Functional derivatives are a huge topic by themselves. Here we will only mention that the functional derivatives become partial derivatives if we go to a discretized/lattice model. E.g. in the step from eq. (6.21) to eq. (6.22) is used a functional generalization of the elementary formula $$ f\left(\frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\partial}{\partial j} \right)e^{\frac{i}{\hbar} j_Iz^I} ~=~ f(z)e^{\frac{i}{\hbar} j_Iz^I} ,\tag{B} $$ which holds for suitable nice functions $f$. Alternatively, the step may be viewed as a generalization of $$ \frac{\hbar}{i}\frac{\delta}{\delta j_I(t)} \exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} \int_{\mathbb{R}} \! dt^{\prime} ~j_J(t^{\prime}) z^J(t^{\prime}) \right\} ~=~z^I(t)\exp\left\{ \frac{i}{\hbar} \int_{\mathbb{R}} \! dt^{\prime} ~j_J(t^{\prime}) z^J(t^{\prime}) \right\} .\tag{C} $$ See also this related Phys.SE post.





cryptic crosswords - Creatures of Darkness


The shadows are scary! I feel like there are beasts watching me everywhere I go...


What kind of person would be able to handle the dark well? (Your answer will be an 8-letter phrase. The crossword will give you the first word, which must be paired with a thematic second word.)


enter image description here



A grotesque vane - it is packed with blood (4)
A lady is the ruler of Dalmasca (4)
Against getting tea in shell-like structure (6)

Aged cloak is one that requires exposure to air (6)
Also abundant nightmarish dullahan heads (3)
Archaically send back royal ambassador (6)
Cried loudly, was ultimately mugged, beheaded. (6)
Distortion from blunder in removal of tissue, removing heart from belly (10)
Expert locking in unknown incendiary (4)
Fiend is concealed by rejected water god (4)
Finances filled with red (9)
Grandpa lost his way and became tainted heathen (5)
Half of border is an administrative division, in summary (3)

Half-twisted evocator in sheltered bay (4)
Hard poop location (5)
In computer science, first elements of assembled records (6)
Increase engine speed both ways, with nothing left inside spinner (6)
Inflexible metal bond (4)
Inflicts pain, after a point leading to cries of anguish (5)
Invisible, unnoticeable at first alongside five directions (6)
Is an aboriginal person (3)
Legacy from one's invasion of revolutionary territory (4)
Lycanthrope door secretly unlocked in the old days (4)

Most unsavory, horrible livestream: chopping feet (6)
One who wanders around as a pilot with no leader (6)
Outdated practice followed by eastern, old city (3)
Parade in southern harbor (7)
Playful, curvacious, opulent, Circean, stripped, like Morrigan Aensland (10)
Plenty, endless cost in recession (3)
Politician inside is making small devils (4)
Related to sound of melting coins (8)
Reportedly look at ocean (3)
Roll the dice to use enchantments (4)

Roll with exclamation of excitement next to level's end (7)
Runner hidden in senior man with no special abilities (6)
Shadows around a dreadful brume (6)
Short fish to be measure of capacity (3)
Sin and after hesitation start to repent (3)
Sorceress woman precedes uncomfortable sensation (5)
Space inside vacuous gristle is what determines heredity (4)
Sphere or ball beginning (3)
Start to bring preliminary survey to Welsh community (6)
Sum is wrong, leading to moments of hesitation (3)

Tear spiral salad (7)
Terrible ire in the one who voiced witches Sayaka Miki and Nene Odagiri (3)
Their first mistake leads to dread (6)
Venomous snake can be all over the place: PSA (3)
Young dog and cat, for example, going after remarkably hollow crook getting a tool (7)



Clarification note / Apology:



I just noticed there is an ambiguity in the placement of the words in the grid. You can use any possibility to get the same final answer, but I wouldn't have left it there if I had seen it earlier.




Hint:



Looks like some clues were not clearly visible in the dark... These seem to be their original forms:


Finances filled with red (5)
In computer science, first elements of assembled records (4)
Increase engine speed both ways, with nothing left inside spinner (8)
Legacy from one's invasion of revolutionary territory (5)
Parade in southern harbor (5)
Related to sound of melting coins (5)
Roll with exclamation of excitement next to level's end (5)

Runner hidden in senior man with no special abilities (8)
Tear spiral salad (6)
Young dog and cat, for example, going after remarkably hollow crook getting a tool (10)


Answer



Many people in the puzzling chat (The Sphinx's Lair) have collaborated to put together a solution.


Warning: the big spoiler block here is a picture of the finished puzzle; if you're looking for a solution to just one clue, scroll down.



enter image description here




First we have the "normal" clues:



These appear in the white spaces in the board.



A grotesque vane - it is packed with blood (4)



VENA: (VANE)*



A lady is the ruler of Dalmasca (4)




ASHE: A+SHE



Against getting tea in shell-like structure (6)



CONCHA: CON+CHA



Aged cloak is one that requires exposure to air (6)



AEROBE: AE+ROBE




Also abundant nightmarish dullahan heads (3)



AND: A_+N_+D_



Archaically send back royal ambassador (6)



RENVOY: R+ENVOY



Cried loudly, was ultimately mugged, beheaded. (6)




SOBBED: S+[-r]OBBED



Distortion from blunder in removal of tissue, removing heart from belly (10)



ABERRATION: AB(ERR)[-l]ATION



Expert locking in unknown incendiary (4)



PYRO: P(Y)RO




Fiend is concealed by rejected water god (4)



OGRE: d(OG RE)taw<



Grandpa lost his way and became tainted heathen (5)



PAGAN: (GRANDPA-RD)*



Half of border is an administrative division, in summary (3)




BOR: BOR[der]



Half-twisted evocator in sheltered bay (4)



COVE: (EVOC)*



Hard poop location (5)



STERN: double definition




Inflexible metal bond (4)



IRON: double definition



Inflicts pain, after a point leading to cries of anguish (5)



WAILS: W (compass pt.) + AILS



Invisible, unnoticeable at first alongside five directions (6)




UNSEEN: U+NSEEN (5 directions)



Is an aboriginal person (3)



SAN: S+AN



Lycanthrope door secretly unlocked in the old days (4)



OPED: OPE D




Most unsavory, horrible livestream: chopping feet (6)



VILEST: (VILEST[ream])*



One who wanders around as a pilot with no leader (6)



VIATOR: [-a]VIATOR



Outdated practice followed by eastern, old city (3):




URE: UR+E



Playful, curvacious, opulent, Circean, stripped, like Morrigan Aensland (10)



VOLUPTUOUS



Plenty, endless cost in recession (3)



LOT: TOL(l)<




Politician inside is making small devils (4)



IMPS: I(MP)S



Reportedly look at ocean (3)



SEA: homophone



Roll the dice to use enchantments (4)




CAST: double definition



Shadows around a dreadful brume (6)



UMBRAE: (A+BRUME)*



Short fish to be measure of capacity (3)



TUN: TUN[-a]




Sin and after hesitation start to repent (3)



ERR: ER+R



Sorceress woman precedes uncomfortable sensation (5)



WITCH: W+ITCH



Space inside vacuous gristle is what determines heredity (4)




GENE: EN inside G_E



Sphere or ball beginning (3)



ORB: OR+B(all)



Start to bring preliminary survey to Welsh community (6)



BRECON: B+RECON




Sum is wrong, leading to moments of hesitation (3)



UMS: (SUM)*



Terrible ire in the one who voiced witches Sayaka Miki and Nene Odagiri (3)



ERI: (IRE)*



Their first mistake leads to dread (6)




TERROR: T+ERROR



Venomous snake can be all over the place: PSA (3)



ASP: (PSA)*





These clues together fill up the board, leaving us with a few more clues:


In computer science, first elements of assembled records (4),(6)




C(A_ R_)S leads to JAGUAR (car brand)



Increase engine speed both ways, with nothing left inside spinner (8),(6)



REV(O+L)VER leads to OCELOT (a character from Metal Gear Solid)



Legacy from one's invasion of revolutionary territory (5),(4)



FRU(I)T< leads to KIWI




Parade in southern harbor (5),(7)



S+PORT leads to CRICKET



Related to sound of melting coins (5),(8)



(SONIC)* leads to HEDGEHOG (video game character)



Roll with exclamation of excitement next to level's end (5),(7)




WHEE+L leads to HAMSTER



Runner hidden in senior man with no special abilities (8),(6)



S(MUGGLE)R leads to COYOTE. We, the solvers, inferred COYOTE from the state of the board; "S(MUGGLE)R" was provided by ffao after the fact to complete this solution.



Tear spiral salad (6),(7)



ROCKET (triple def.) leads to RACCOON (video game character)




Young dog and cat, for example, going after remarkably hollow crook getting a tool (10),(7)



SO+C[roo]K+PUP+PET leads to CATFISH



Finances filled with red (5),(9)



C(R)ASH leads to BANDICOOT (video game character)



From the final board,




we can see that the extra clues fit neatly into the gaps in the existing board, sometimes overlapping existing clues. Where they intersect (highlighted in yellow), they spell out NIGHT.





What kind of person would be able to handle the dark well?



Given the hint that there are two themed words in the final solution, we infer that this person is a NIGHT OWL.



Can a chess player promote all pawns to queens?


In standard chess rules, a pawn is promoted if it reaches the far side of the board. Usually, the pawn's owner chooses to promote it to a queen.


Is it possible for one player to eventually promote all their pawns to queens, in a legal game of chess? Assume the opposing player plays "perfectly badly" to allow this. However, if the game reaches checkmate, it must stop.



Answer



This 40 move solution on lichess works, and while it may not be the most orderly solution, it is impossible to create a solution in fewer moves since I'm using optimal pawn movement at every step and no other pieces (6 fields to move, 2 in the initial move, so 5 moves for each pawn to promote).


PGN of the game:


1. e4 f5 2. exf5 Kf7 3. f6 Nh6 4. fxe7 Kg8 5. e8=Q Ng4 6. f4 h6 7. f5 Kh7

8. f6 Qe7+ 9. fxe7 Nc6 10. exf8=Q Nge5 11. g4 Nf7 12. g5 Kg6 13. gxh6 Kf5
14. hxg7 Nb4 15. g8=Q Rh5 16. h4 Rg5 17. h5 Nc6 18. h6 Nb4 19. h7 Nc6
20. h8=Q Nb4 21. d4 Nc6 22. d5 b5 23. dxc6 Bb7 24. cxd7 Bd5 25. d8=Q Be6
26. c4 Rh5 27. cxb5 Rg5 28. b6 Rh5 29. bxc7 Rb8 30. c8=Q Rb5 31. a4 Rg5
32. axb5 Rh5 33. b6 Rg5 34. bxa7 Rh5 35. a8=Q Rg5 36. b4 Rh5 37. b5 Rg5
38. b6 Rh5 39. b7 Rg5 40. b8=Q

GIF:


40 move solution


special relativity - If a photon is exists in 'timeless' state, how can objects around it move?




My understanding is that light does not experience time. In attempting to understand what the universe would be like from the perspective of a photon, the answer I get is that the universe would be essentially 'frozen'. Answers I've seen describe the photon in a universe where it can move through space, but with events around it not moving at all in time.


So...from my frame of reference, it takes about 4 hours for light to go from Neptune to where I am on Earth. Conceivably I could move somewhere during that time to dodge the photons. But if from the photons perspective I don't have time to move out of the way, then there is a paradox of sorts.


Therefore I must be missing something here. Can someone explain how the motion of other things is possible from the perspective of a photon?




quantum mechanics - How is instantaneous action at a distance governed by a specific frame of reference?


Instantaneous action at a distance may occur due to an experiment being performed within a train. A particle may decay in the middle of the train, and when decaying it may split into 2 entangled particles that fly apart in opposite directions. Let's say that these particles are photons. When measuring properties of one particle when it reaches one end of the train, it is said that this will instantaneously affect the other particle at the opposite end of the train.


However, if this experiment was performed again as the train passed by a train station, observers at the train station do not see the two photons reach the two opposite ends of the train at the same time, thus to them there is no instantaneous action at a distance taking place at all.


Thus how is it that what appears to the obsevers on board the train to be instantaneous action at a distance is physically confined to this one frame of reference only ?


Edit: I will add to the details here, that the photons are said to be in superposition of states until being first measured at one end of the train or the other. Which end measures first may depend on the accuracy of the experiment that was set up. But either way both photons are said to be in superposition of states until that moment that they reach the train ends, +/- measurement error.




Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...