Sunday, 4 October 2015

interactions - Are fundamental forces conservative?


I wonder whether fundamental forces are conservative.



First of all, I'm not sure if we can talk about conservative forces, since to study electromagnetism, weak and strong interactions we need QFT.


For gravity, I'd that it's not conservative, because energy conservation doesn't even apply.



Answer



The notion of "conservative forces" is not in any way fundamental. What's fundamental is that we're able to assign a number to the state of a system, and that number is conserved.


The relatively uninteresting notion of a "conservative force" can be applied only to a force that can be expressed as a vector field that depends only on position. That means it's meaningful for Newtonian gravity and for electrostatics, but not for any other force that could be considered fundamental. Re the nuclear forces, see Do strong and weak interactions have classical force fields as their limits? .


General relativity has local conservation of energy-momentum, which is expressed by the fact that the stress-energy tensor has a zero divergence. A mass-energy scalar or energy-momentum vector isn't something that can be defined globally in GR for an arbitrary spacetime.


WP says (Gugg, where was the link from?):



However, general relativity is non-conservative, as seen in the anomalous precession of Mercury's orbit. However, general relativity can be shown to conserve a stress-energy-momentum pseudotensor.




The first sentence is wrong, because Mercury's anomalous precession can be described in terms of a test particle moving in a Schwarzschild metric. The Schwarzschild metric has a timelike Killing vector, so there is a conserved energy-momentum vector for test particles.


The second sentence is also misleading, since it doesn't make the global/local distinction. What's conserved locally isn't a pseudotensor, it's a tensor (the energy-momentum vector). Globally, there are various pseudotensors that can be defined, and the fact that they're pseudotensors rather than tensors means that they're fundamentally not well-defined quantities -- they require some specially chosen system of coordinates.


particle physics - why is there no ninth gluon?


A teacher of mine told me once that there were no ninth gluon because such a one should be white and interact infinitely far, and no one has been observed. Is there also a theoretical reason?




reference frames - Intensity of Hawking radiation for different observers relative to a black hole



Consider three observers in different states of motion relative to a black hole:


Observer A is far away from the black hole and stationary relative to it;


Observer B is suspended some distance above the event horizon on a rope, so that her position remains constant with respect to the horizon;


Observer C is the same distance from the horizon as B (from the perspective of A), but is freefalling into it.


All of these observers should observe Hawking radiation in some form. I am interested in how the spectra and intensity of the three observations relate to one another.


My previous understanding (which might be wrong, because I don't know how to do the calculation) was that if you calculate the radiation that B observes, and then calculate how much it would be red shifted as it leaves the gravity well, you arrive at the spectrum and intensity of the Hawking radiation observed by A. I want to understand how the radiation experienced by C relates to that observed by the other two.


The radiation fields observed by B and C are presumably different. B is being accelerated by the tension in the rope, and is thus subject to something like the Unruh effect. C is in freefall and therefore shouldn't observe Unruh photons - but from C's point of view there is still a horizon ahead, so presumably she should still be able to detect Hawking radiation emanating from it. So I would guess that C observes thermal radiation at a lower intensity than B, and probably also at a lower temperature (but I'm not so sure about that).


So my question is, am I correct in my understanding of how A and B's spectra relate to one another, and has anyone done (or would anyone be willing to do) the calculation that would tell us what C observes? References to papers that discuss this would be particularly helpful.



Answer



This paper discusses these issues in a fairly comprehensible way. Faraway observers (like your observer A) see thermal Hawking radiation with an effective temperature given by the Hawking temperature $$T_H := \frac{\hbar c^3}{8 \pi G M k_B},$$ where $M$ is the black hole's mass.



If an observer on a string is very slowly lowered toward the black hole (so that her $dr/d\tau$ is very small), then the effective temperature increases without bound and diverges at the horizon, so your observer B inevitably gets burned up. (You can think of her as needing unboundedly large acceleration to stay out of the hole, so that she sees a huge Unruh radation. More realistically, of course, the string would break first.) See Figure 1 of the paper, which refers to the temperature observed by a strongly accelerated observer at constant $r$ as the "fiducial temperature" $T_\text{FID}$.


If an observer free-falls into the black hole, the effective temperature that she observes (which the paper calls the "free-falling at rest temperature" $T_\text{FFAR}$) gradually increases from $T_H$ very far away to $2 T_H$ at the horizon (your observer C), also plotted in Figure 1. You might think that her thermometer hitting $2 T_H$ would give her a local probe of exactly when she crosses the horizon, which would violate the equivalence principle. But this is not the case, for a subtle reason given below Fig. 1:



We note that our method gives a physically reasonable answer for $T_\text{FFAR}$ at all values of $r ≥ 2m$. However, the precise numerical value $T_\text{FFAR} = 2TH$ at the event horizon has limited operational meaning. First of all, as was discussed in the introduction, the local free-fall temperature is not a precise notion. On top of this, a freely-falling observer passing through the horizon has only a proper time of order $m$ left before running into the curvature singularity at $r = 0$, and since the characteristic wavelength of thermal radiation at $T ∼ 2T_H$ is also of order $m$, the observer cannot measure temperature to better than $O(1/m)$ precision near the horizon. Although our result for the free-fall temperature is thus only qualitative in the region near the event horizon, it does confirm the expectation expressed in early work of Unruh [13] that an infalling observer will not run into highly energetic particles at the horizon.



The case of observer C illustrates an important subtlety regarding Hawking radiation. It's often stated that Hawking radiation is just the Unruh radiation seen by an observer near the horizon accelerating away from it in order to keep from falling in. But this is not quite correct, as explained in this answer, because Unruh radiation is a flat-spacetime effect and spacetime is curved near an event horizon. If they were truly equivalent, then a freefalling observer would not observe any Hawking radiation, but in fact observer C does. But for a very large black hole, the curvature at the horizon (as measured, say, by the Kretschmann scalar $$R_{\mu \nu \rho \sigma} R^{\mu \nu \rho \sigma} \big|_{r = 2GM} = \frac{48 (G M)^2}{(2 G M)^6} = \frac{3}{4 (GM)^4}$$ ) becomes arbitrarily small. So near the horizon of a very large black hole, Hawking radiation and Unruh radiation become essentially the same thing, and indeed a freefalling observer sees negligible Hawking radiation (at an arbitrarily low temperature $2 T_H \propto 1/M$).


Edit: I should clarify that the temperature you observe as you free-fall through the horizon depends on your speed, or more precisely, how far away you were from the horizon when you were released from rest. $T_\text{FFAR}$ is the temperature that you observe if you are both inertial ("free-fall") and have proper velocity $dr/d\tau = 0$ ("at rest"). The paper https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.02532 explains this in more detail, distinguishes between the observed temperatures of the outgoing and incoming radiation, and elaborates on the distinction between the Hawking and Unruh effects. Thanks to Akoben for pointing this out.


quantum mechanics - Reference Request: Basis-independent formulation of tensor networks



I could not find any references for a basis-independent formulation of tensor networks: All papers I have found use pretty much (explicitly or implicitly) the canonical computational basis by defining tensors as lists of complex numbers.


While this is certainly ok from the perspective of "I want to compute stuff", it is not when trying to look at the bigger picture, i.e. realizing tensor networks as certain string diagrams in the category of finite dimensional Hilbert spaces.


Does anyone know of a resource that addresses this?




Saturday, 3 October 2015

mathematics - Generating numbers with cubes


I saw an interesting calendar in a shop. It is composed of two cubes with numbers written on their 6 sides. By placing these cubes side by side one can make any day of the month from 1 to 31 (even 32). This tickled my mathematical curiosity and made me wonder: what is the largest contiguous range of numbers you can make with 3 cubes? Bonus question: what happens if you allow cubes to be flipped, so 6 can become 9 and vice versa?


This problem is similar to this Counting numbers with 3 dice but here we don't require 0-padding, so the answer is different. For example, here we can use a single die to represent single-digit numbers.



Good luck!



Answer



I really enjoy puzzles like these.



The largest number with 3 dice would have to be 98 (without flipping), since we would need two occurrences of every digit from 1-9 to get past the multiples of 11, plus a 0 somewhere for the tens.
This adds up to 19 (2 x 9 + 1), but we only have 18 (3 x 6) faces. So my solution for without flipping is:
[ 0, 1, 3, 4, 6, 7 ]
[ 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8 ]
[ 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9 ]
Which can count to 98. The procedure for building up the dice is simply counting up and making sure to have two of each number (except 0) on difference dice.




Bonus question:



As for flipping, we can remove the 9, since 6s can be used.
Now we can get up to 99, but for 100 we need another 0.
So I tried swapping the 9 for 0:
[ 0, 1, 3, 4, 6, 7 ]
[ 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 8 ]
[ 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 0 ]
This allows counting up to 110, but it can not make 111, since that requires three 1s, which we don't have.




Curiosity:



I played around with 2 dice, and without flipping, the maximum is indeed 32:
[ 0, 1, 2, 4, 6, 8 ]
[ 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 9 ]
But with flipping, the maximum is 43 (since 44 is unreachable):
[ 0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 7]
[ 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8]




mathematics - The Great Houdini's awesome card guessing trick (1)


The Great Houdini is performing again! A guy from the audience arbitrarily chooses $52$ cards from a huge stack. He shuffles the cards and announces to Houdini that there are $a$ spades, $b$ hearts, $c$ clubs and $d$ diamonds. Houdini now has to guess the suits in the deck one by one. After every guess, the guy from the audience reveals the current card and everybody (including Houdini) sees the correct suit.




Houdini's strategy: At any moment in time, Houdini knows the numbers of remaining suits in the deck. Houdini always guesses a suit that occurs the highest number of times (ties are broken arbitrarily).



Question: What is the smallest possible number of correct guesses under Houdini's strategy (over all possible values of $a,b,c,d$)?



Answer



The smallest possible of correct guesses is max(a, b, c, d): every other suit could come up first and he would guess the most likely one over and over until nothing was left but those, and then he would get all the rest correct.


Can one define a "particle" as space-localized object in quantum field theory?


In Peskin and Schroeder, while discussing creation and annihilation operators for a Klein-Gordon field (p.22), the authors say, as we all know the creation operator $a_p^{\dagger}$ acts on vacuum to produce a state with momentum $p$ having energy equal to $\sqrt{p^2+m^2}$. Then they state: "It is quite natural to call these excitations particles, since they are discrete entities that have the proper relativistic energy-momentum relation. (By a particle we do not mean something that must be localized in space; the creation operator creates particles in momentum eigenstates)"


This clashes with my previous conception of a particle to be something localized in space; a point particle located at point $(x,y,z)$ for example, or an extended massive object occupying certain region in space. Form above should I conclude that no such concept of space-localized point-particle exists in quantum field theory? I am not familiar with the process of visualizing something in coordinate space which is known to be localized in momentum space. Please help.




Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...