Thursday, 23 November 2017

What is the difference between solutions of the diffusion equation with an imaginary diffusion coefficent and the wave equation's?


The diffusion equation of the form:


$$ \frac{\partial u(x,t)}{\partial t} = D\frac{\partial ^2u(x,t)}{\partial x^2} $$


If one chooses a real value for $D$, the solutions are usually decaying with time.


However, in some situations in physics, most notably the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, one sees an equation of similar form to the diffusion equation, but with a complex diffusion coefficient, i.e $D=i\,D'$.


This causes the equation's solutions to osculate instead of decay with time because


$$ \exp(-Dt)=\exp(-iD't) $$


Which is why the Schrödinger equation has wave solutions like the wave equation's.



It seems like one can transform the diffusion equation to an equation that can replace the wave equation since the solutions are the same.


This does not make much intuitive sense to me, so I think my understanding of the solutions of the wave and diffusion equation is not complete. What is the difference, if any, in the set of solutions of the diffusion equation with an imaginary diffusion coefficient and the wave equation's?



Answer



Both Schrödinger and Wave Equation have plane wave solutions, that's right. The difference is the dispersion relation, which is quadratic for the Schrödinger equation and linear for the wave equation. This is important, because the Schrödinger equation was designed to correctly reproduce the quadratic dispersion relation that was observed for electrons.


(You can show that by fourier-transforming both equations both in space and time and solving for $\omega(k)$.)


cosmology - Universe expands ... compared to what?


I keep hearing that universe expands. Since all is relative, the expansion must be relative to something. And since universe is all there is ... You got my point.


The only points of reference are inside the universe itself. Bonds forming, their length measured in wavelengths, etc. Red shifting of light tells us things fly away. So our point of reference is only light. (am I missing something?)



Here is my question. In a thought experiment, would it be valid to say that properties of light are somehow changing around us if we keep the size of the universe constant? If yes, what are the consequences of this line of thought? Would it give us any additional insight into what's going on?




Proof of conservation of energy?


How is it proved to be always true? It's a fundamental principle in Physics, that is based on all of our currents observations of multiple systems in the universe, is it always true to all systems? Because we haven't tested or observed them all. Would it be possible to discover/create a system that could lead to a different result?



How are we 100% sure that energy is always conserved? Finally, why did we conclude it's always conversed? What if a system keeps doing work over and over and over with time?



Answer




How is it proved to be always true? It's a fundamental principle in Physics, that is based on all of our currents observations of multiple systems in the universe, is it always true to all systems? Because we haven't tested or observed them all. Could it possible that we discover/create a system that could lead to a different result?



A physical theory, and also the postulates on which it is based can only be validated, that means that every experiment done shows that the theory holds and in this case energy conservation holds. A physical theory can be proven only to be false even by one datum, and then the theory changes. Example: classical mechanics fails at relativistic energies, when mass turns into energy, and classical energy is not conserved. A relativistic mechanics was developed that still has conservation of a more generally defined energy.



How are 100% sure that energy is always conserved? Finally, why did we conclude it's always conversed?



We cannot be sure, as I said above. If we find even one case where the newer energy definition fails than the postulate fails and new propositions will be studied. It has not failed up to now in our laboratory and observational experiments.



In any case, the framework is important, classical conservation of energy still holds for non relativistic energies, for example.



In general relativity conservation of energy-momentum is expressed with the aid of a stress-energy-momentum pseudotensor. The theory of general relativity leaves open the question of whether there is a conservation of energy for the entire universe.



For cosmological matters see another entry in this forum on the law of conservation of energy.


Wednesday, 22 November 2017

electrostatics - Electric potential vs potential difference


What is the difference between electric potential and potential difference? In our course book, they are given as separate topics but their definition is given the same.



Answer



What is the difference between "electric potential" and "potential difference"?




What is the difference between age and age difference?


If $\text{age}(\text{person})$ is the function so that $\text{age}(\text{you})$ is your age, $\text{age}(\text{mom})$ is your moms age and $\text{age}(\text{dad})$ is your dads age, then $\Delta\text{age}:=\text{age}(\text{dad})-\text{age}(\text{mom})$ is the age difference of your parents.





The elecrical potential $\Phi$ refers to a quantity with some numberic value. It is usually dependent on space and time $\Phi(\vec x,t)$, so it's a field where for every place and moment you get some number.


By potential difference $\Delta\Phi$ one denotes the difference between two such values taken at different positions. For example, $$\Delta\Phi:=\Phi(\vec x_2,t_0)-\Phi(\vec x_1,t_0)$$ is the potential difference of the field $\Phi(\vec x,t)$ for the two points $\vec x_2$ and $\vec x_1$ at the particular moment $t_0$.


So for example, if you have a one-dimensional capacitor with electical potential $\Phi(l)$, with one plate at the position $l=0$ and the other at position $l=L$, then the potential difference $\Delta\Phi$ for these two points is the number you compute via $\Phi(L)-\Phi(0)$.




I think your question might arise because only the potential difference is the physical quantity which determines the electical field and therefore the acceleration of charges. While as age difference between persons as well as age of one person are both interesting quantities with practical value (Did I miss my mom's bithday? Am I allowed to drive? How much years will I get for homicide?), the value of the electical potential as such will eventually only be used to compute potential differences.


homework and exercises - Preventing a block from sliding on a plane (with friction)


Assume a small square block $m$ is sitting on a larger wedge-shaped block of mass $M$ at an upper angle $\theta$ such that the little block will slide on the big block if both are started from rest and no other forces are present. The large block is sitting on a frictionless table. The coefficient of static friction between the large and small blocks is µs. With what range of force $F$ can you push on the large block to the right such that the small block will remain motionless with respect to the large block and neither slide up nor down?


This question really is not too complicated without friction acting upon the small block (Preventing a block from sliding on a frictionless inclined plane)


But what happens when we add friction to the system? Why is it considered static, if at rest, the mass would slide down the plane?





astronomy - What objects/states of objects with absolute magnitude do we know of?


For measuring distances the knowledge of absolute magnitude or luminosity is often crucial, especially for very big distances. Unfortunately we can't measure the diameter of far distant objects and calculate and derive absolute magnitude due to resolution limits.


That's why objects or better named states in the life cycle of specific objects, like Type Ia supernovas, are so important.


What additional objects do we know of sharing this property? Are there objects theoretically predicted to have a absolute magnitude but until now not yet discovered? Name the object and the spectral range of emitted light or particles.



Answer



The jargon for what you are looking for is "standard candles": things whose luminosities we can determine without knowing their distance. They are of particular interest to astronomers because they can be used to measure distances.


There are many such objects, but all of them should be treated with some caution. In no case is our knowledge of the luminosity perfect, and in many cases there is large intrinsic scatter. Generally, our knowledge is not of the form "all objects of type x have luminosity y", but more of the form "for objects of type x, the luminosity is correlated with parameters a, b, and c according to complicated equation foo." The physical origin of complicated equation foo is much better understood in some cases than in others, and in all cases needs to be empirically calibrated. Particularly if the physical origin of the correlation is poorly understood, we may not know if or how the calibration changes with the age of the universe. Because we see very distant objects as they were when the universe was younger, this limits our ability to use them as distance measurements to great distances.


In all cases one needs to be careful to take the redshift into account, as the part of an objects rest spectrum which, say, appears blue nearby, may appear red or even IR when the same object is more distant. (See k-correction.) In many cases, a range of wavelengths may be used (at least in the visual or IR), but the calibration may be different for different rest wavelengths. If you observe the all objects through the same filter, you will be observing different objects at different rest wavelengths.


Here are some standard candles:





  • Cepheid variable stars (see 2000ApJS..128..431F) are very bright, and their luminosity is strongly correlated with their luminosity, making them excellent standard candles.




  • RR Lyrae variable stars also follow such a relationship (2003LNP...635...85B), but are fainter.




  • Type Ia supernova are very bright, and their peak luminosity can be estimated from their change in luminosity over time.





  • The tip of the red giant branch in the HR diagram (2000ApJS..128..431F) is one bright feature of the HR diagram that can be used. Blue supergiants have also been proposed as possible standard candles (see 2003LNP...635..123K).




  • The simple surface brightness of a galaxy is useless as a standard candle: the number of stars per square arcsecond rises as the distance squared, while the luminosity of an individual star falls as the distance squared, so the surface brightness is independent of distance. However, even in a galaxy where the stars are distributed according to some smooth function (as in an elliptical galaxy like M87), the surface brightness isn't perfectly smooth, because the stars are of finite brightness: the stars are randomly distributed according to the smooth function, and by chance some places have more stars than others. The roughness of the galaxy can therefore be used to measure the luminosity weighted mean luminosity of the stars in the galaxy, and this can be used as a standard candle of sorts. This is the "surface brightness fluctuation" (SBF) method of distance measurement, introduced in 1988AJ.....96..807T.




  • Large clusters of galaxies usually have a bright giant elliptical galaxy near the center. These are called "Brightest Cluster Galaxies" (BCGs). BCGs have a fairly consistent luminosity; see 1995ApJ...440...28P.




  • Planetary nebulae can have a wide range of luminosities, but there is a well defined upper limit to how bright they can be (see 1989ApJ...339...39J and associated articles). So, if you measure the number of planetary nebulae in a galaxy as a function of luminosity, the "planetary nebula luminosity function" (PNLF), the cutoff at the bright end can be used as a standard candle.





  • The peak of the globular cluster luminosity function (GCLF) seems to be consistent across different galaxies, so the luminosity at which there are the most globular clusters in a given galaxy can be used as a standard candle. The physical reason for this consistency is not well understood. See 2006AJ....132.2333S.




  • For spiral galaxies, there is a relationship between the the rotation curve and luminosity, the "Tully-Fisher" relation (1977A&A....54..661T). See also the Faber-Jackson relation (1976ApJ...204..668F) and Fundamental plane for elliptical galaxies.




  • There may be a relationship between the radius of the broad line region of an active galactic nucleus and its luminosity. See Watson el al. (2011).





electromagnetism - How many possible electromagnetic wavelengths are possible?


Disclaimer: Please keep in mind that I am a young highschool student with no background in physics, this research was done in the course of an hour, and my reasoning could very well be wrong.


After a short conversation about color, I did some thinking, and read this question. The answer claims that there are $\infty^{\infty}$ colors


My first problem is the definition of colors, I'm going to simplify this (although it's not the same thing) as electromagnetic frequencies. This is what I mean when I refer to color in the rest of this question


The problem with $\infty^{\infty}$ colors is that the plank length exists. This causes two problems to arise with $\infty^{\infty}$. If $l_p$ is assumed to exist (as it is), this means the smallest distance in the universe is $l_p$. So, all wavelengths of light can be divided into a set, of the wavelengths produced by objects at $0^{\circ}$ Kelvin to $\infty^{\circ}$ Kelvin. According to this logic, there are simply $\infty$ colors.


Things are complicated further, when you introduce the Plank Temperature ($P_t$). $P_t$ is the theoretical limit temperature of the universe (at least for the purposes of light and color) Because an object hotter than $P_t$ will produce light with wavelengths shorter than $l_p$. This would introduce an upper limit on colors too.



Wouldn't this mean that the total number of possible colors is equal to however many plank lengths difference there is between an electromagnetic wave produced by a 0 degree object and a $l_p$ object? And therefor far less than $\infty$? Does this reasoning make sense at all?



Answer



I will give a speculative answer - open to suggestions for improvement:


While mathematicians understand the difference between $\infty$ and $\infty^{\infty}$, I am not sure such distinction is terribly helpful for physicists - or how you would prove one versus the other. And if you are worrying about the distinction, you are not a typical high school student...


Frequency of a photon is an ill-defined property: in order to measure the frequency to an accuracy $\Delta \omega$, I need to measure for a length of time $t=\frac{1}{\Delta \omega}$. Since the universe has a finite age, it is simply not possible to determine (or define) the energy of any photon to greater precision than that - which effectively means that the number of distinct frequencies that exist in the EM spectrum (in the sense that they could be distinguished) is limited.


To claim there are more possible frequencies is something that I don't believe could be proven... Note also that the question you linked in your question (and the answers thereto) touch on the fact that "color" as perceived is in principle any combination of wavelengths; and if you can have "any number of photons with any infinite number of wavelengths", you do indeed end up with $\infty^{\infty}$ combinations. But the question in your title is just about "possible wavelengths" - and if we accept that a given photon has just one wavelength (one energy - within the bounds of uncertainty) then you go back to "countably infinitely many".


Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...