Friday, 24 November 2017

nuclear physics - What does the Atomic Form Factor mean?



I was reading Nuclear Physics and the author mentioned something about the atomic form factor, something in relation to the Fourier transform of the spatial distribution of the electric charge. but I don't know what it means. What is the physical interpretation of the atomic form factor?



Answer



There are a variety of ways one could answer this. As you note, the form factor is the Fourier transform of the spacial distribution of the electric charge density. The subtlety with this definition is that for a composite system such as a nucleus (or atom, or nucleon), defining a "net charge density" that is just a function of spacial coordinates, i.e. $\rho(x, y, z)$, is an approximation. The exact description of an atom or nucleus is given by a many-body wavefunction.


That aside, $\rho(x, y, z)$ for an atom or nucleus can be roughly interpreted as the charge density associated with an effective potential that is arrived at by averaging over the motion of the constituent particles. The form factor $f(Q)$ is Fourier transform of this.


Consequently, one should expect the form factor associated with an atom to deviate from zero around $1/(10^{-10} \textrm{m})$ and $1/(10^{-15} \textrm{m})$. The former corresponds to electronic degrees of freedom (e.g. the "wavefunction" of the electrons) and the latter corresponds to nuclear degrees of freedom.


The form factor $f(Q)$ will provide a measure of the interaction of between the atom and an incident photon with momentum $Q$. Consequently, photons with a wavelength $\sim 10^{-10} \textrm{m}$ (i.e. visible or UV light) or $\sim 10^{-15} \textrm{m}$ (i.e. gamma rays) will interact strongly with the atom by coupling to the electronic or nuclear degrees of freedom, respectively.


One can also define other kinds of form factors that correspond to different sorts of interactions (e.g. magnetic, the strong force, etc.).


homework and exercises - 5D Ricci Curvature


As part of a hw problem for a class, we're supposed to be deriving the equivalence given in equation 2.3 of this paper http://arxiv.org/abs/1107.5563. I was wondering if there is some special relation involving the Ricci Curvature in 5d's relationship to one in 4d. Since with a general metric like the one given in 2.1, calculating the Christoffel symbols would seem to be an enormous and not particularly smart idea.




newtonian mechanics - Deriving torque equation from Newton's 2nd Law


I'm trying to understand the derivation of the torque equation $\vec{r} \times \vec{F} = I \alpha$. My textbook derives this easily enough from Newton's 2nd Law for a single point with mass $m$ and radial distance $r$, with the force applied at the same distance $r$, as (if we drop the vector notation for simplicity) $F=ma=m(r\alpha)$, so $rF=mr^2 \alpha = I\alpha$. (Note, there are both 'ay's and 'alpha's there; they look similar.)


The textbook stops there and concludes that the equation holds for any rotating body. But then I tried this derivation for two points positioned along a rigid, massless rod (which points perpendicular to an axis about which it rotates). If there's a point-mass $m_1$ a distance $r_1$ from the axis of rotation and another point-mass $m_2$ at a distance $r_2$, and the force is applied at (for example) distance $r_2$, I get $F=m_1 a_1 + m_2 a_2 = m_1 r_1 \alpha + m_2 r_2 \alpha$, so $r_2 F= (m_1 r_1 r_2 + m_2 {r_2}^2 )\alpha$. But $m_1 r_1 r_2 + m_2 {r_2}^2$ isn't the correct value for $I$ here. What am I missing?




cosmology - What fraction of baryonic matter is in stars?


We know from big bang nucleosynthesis that baryonic matter accounts for about 5% of the universe's total mass-energy density. What is the current best estimate of how much of this is in the form of stars? I'm guessing that this would be known only very roughly. It seems like you would just have to survey large volumes of space for stars and larger structures made out of stars. Although galaxies may pretty efficiently cycle their hydrogen and helium through stars, I would assume that there is a lot of hydrogen out there in the spaces between superclusters that has never had a chance to form a star and never will.


related: How do we estimate $10^{23}$ stars in the observable universe?




Thursday, 23 November 2017

bosons - Time of flight images of Bose-Hubbard model


on the website of Immanuel Bloch, you can find time of flight images of bosonic particles inside an optical lattice for different values of the depth of the lattice.


(http://www.quantum.physik.uni-mainz.de/bec__experiments__mottinsulator.html.en)


enter image description here


Can someone precisely explain this picture? To what does the distance between the interference peaks refer to?



Answer



This is a time-of-flight image, and it therefore refers to the momentum distribution of the atoms. As explained in the original Nature paper (10.1038/415039a), the distance between the peaks (in the picture, i.e., in the momentum space) is $2\hbar k$, where $k = 2\pi/\lambda$ is the wavenumber corresponding to the periodicity of the lattice with $\lambda$ being the laser wavelength.


On the top left the system is in the superfluid (Bose-Einstein condensed) phase, as indicated by the peaks. All the atoms are completely delocalized over the whole lattice, and they thus are coherent.


On the bottom rightmost picture, the peaks are gone, thus there is no phase coherence. The system is in the Mott phase, where each atom is trapped in a single site.


In between the two extremes the Superfluid/Mott phase transition takes place. There, as the depth of the lattice is increased, the atoms first become localized a tiny bit (indicated with the extra peaks appearing and gaining strength), and then the incoherent background takes over (the system forms the layered-cake structure of several Mott states with different occupancy).



thermodynamics - Flame shape and size (length) depending on gravity




How would the shape and size of a flame, e.g. from a simple candle depend on gravity? Suppose all the relevant information is known, including candle dimensions and chemical composition, atmosphere properties (chemical composition, pressure etc.), and anything else.



Answer



After some searches I found this little paper. I will give only a short answer to the question, for details you can read the paper.


So, according to the results obtained for the model in the paper:




  1. the flame length:



    • increases as the gravity level increases from $0g_e$ to $3g_e$

    • decreases from $3g_e$ to $60g_e$


    • and blows off at higher gravity levels




  2. the maximum width of the flame decreases as the gravity level increases.




In the next figure can be observed the evolution of the flame from $0g_e$ to $5g_e$.  Flame shape contours contours at various gravity levels


However, if the top surface of the wick is made inert, the model predicts that the flame blows off at $6g_e$.


$g_e$ - gravity at the level of Earth surface.



quantum mechanics - Is the molecular term ${}^1Sigma^-$ possible in a molecule?


The old question How to understand this symmetry in the wavefunctions of a diatomic molecule? explores how it is possible for a quantum state to have zero angular momentum about a given axis (giving it a term $\Sigma$) while using multi-electron effects to stay parity-odd with respect to reflections in planes that contain that axis.



One of the things that fall out of that analysis is that, if this is done using a two-electron system, then the orbital part of the state needs to be odd under exchange, which forces the spin part to be even and therefore forces the spin representation to be a triplet, making the full term symbol ${}^3\Sigma^-$.


My question here is: is it possible to use more than two electrons, coupled in some clever way, to whittle that spin representation down to a singlet, for a full term symbol of ${}^1\Sigma^-$? If so, what is an explicit example? What is the minimal number of electrons needed for such a term? Or are there other restrictions in place that make that term impossible no matter how you try?



Answer



From a chemistry perspective (so I am afraid this might not be as rigorous as you guys usually like, but it is what I can offer), we would usually use group theory to determine the term symbol for the molecule. tom has kindly provided the examples of dioxygen and dinitrogen. Since these molecules are centrosymmetric, the term symbol technically should include a gerade/ungerade label as well, i.e. $^1\Sigma_\mathrm g^-$ or $^1\Sigma_\mathrm u^-$, but it's not particularly important.


Using dioxygen as an example ($D_{\infty\mathrm h}$ point group, character table here) and ignoring the core 1s-electrons, the ground state has the electronic configuration $(1\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\sigma_\mathrm u)^2(2\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\pi_\mathrm u)^4(1\pi_\mathrm g)^2$. A quick sketch of the MO diagram is provided below.


MO diagram of dioxygen


The first ten electrons are all paired up and collectively transform as the totally symmetric irreducible representation, i.e. $\Sigma_\mathrm g^+$, so from a symmetry point of view we only need to consider the top two electrons. Both electrons are in a $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbital, and collectively these transform as the direct product of $\Pi_\mathrm g$ with itself. (Irreducible representations are labelled with capital Greek letters, whereas small letters are used for MO symmetry labels.)


$$\Pi_\mathrm g \times \Pi_\mathrm g = \Sigma_\mathrm g^+ + [\Sigma_\mathrm g^-] + \Delta_\mathrm g$$


This means that a $(\pi_\mathrm g)^2$ configuration can have an overall symmetry of either of these three, depending on how the electrons are configured. Now, the square brackets come into play: these represent antisymmetrised direct products, i.e. spatial wavefunctions which are antisymmetric upon permutation of the two $\pi_\mathrm g$ electrons. In order to satisfy the Pauli exclusion principle, this must be paired with the symmetric spin wavefunction, i.e. a triplet spin function. Likewise, the symmetric spatial wavefunctions $\Sigma_\mathrm g^+$ and $\Delta_\mathrm g$ must be paired with the antisymmetric singlet spin function.


All in all, for the ground state electronic configuration of dioxygen $(1\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\sigma_\mathrm u)^2(2\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\pi_\mathrm u)^4(1\pi_\mathrm g)^2$, we have the permissible term symbols $^1\Sigma_\mathrm g^+$, $^3\Sigma_\mathrm g^-$, and $^1\Delta_\mathrm g$. Obviously, this does not contain the desired $^1\Sigma_\mathrm g^-$, and that is why it does not appear as one of the lower-energy terms in the NIST webbook. There's a good chance you know all of this already, but I thought it helpful to set the scene (and maybe future readers do not know it, so it can't hurt).





The way to circumvent these symmetry-restricted direct products, and hence to obtain the $^1\Sigma_\mathrm g^-$ term symbol, is to make sure that the two electrons are not in the same $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbital. As long as this is the case, there is no longer any restriction on which spatial wavefunctions can be paired with which spin wavefunctions. If you (hypothetically) promote one electron to the next-highest $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbital, such that you have an electronic configuration of $(1\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\sigma_\mathrm u)^2(2\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\pi_\mathrm u)^4(1\pi_\mathrm g)^1(2\pi_\mathrm g)^1$, then the $^1\Sigma_\mathrm g^-$ term symbol is no longer symmetry-forbidden. [This $2\pi_\mathrm g$ orbital would be formed from overlap of the 3p orbitals of oxygen.]


Why is this so? I actually don't know how to explain this intuitively, but I can demonstrate it with a concrete wavefunction. Let's label the two lower-energy $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbitals by $\psi_{a+}$ and $\psi_{a-}$, and the two higher-energy $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbitals by $\psi_{b+}$ and $\psi_{b-}$. The sign $\pm$ indicates the direction of the angular momentum projection along the internuclear axis: $\pi$-type orbitals come in pairs of $+1$ and $-1$ units of these angular momentum. Now consider the following wavefunction (I ignore normalisation).


$$\Psi = \psi_{a+}(1)\psi_{b-}(2) - \psi_{a-}(1)\psi_{b+}(2) + \psi_{b-}(1)\psi_{a+}(2) - \psi_{b+}(1)\psi_{a-}(2)$$


The maths is easy, but fiddly. The effect of reflection in a plane causes the interchange of $+$ and $-$ labels, and you can verify that this turns $\Psi$ into $-\Psi$, i.e. the term symbol has a minus sign. The net projection of angular momentum onto the internuclear axis is zero, hence $\Sigma$. Lastly, the overall wavefunction is symmetric with respect to interchange of the two particles (interchange the labels 1 and 2). Consequently, it must be paired with the antisymmetric spatial spin function, which is the singlet wavefunction $\alpha(1)\beta(2) - \beta(1)\alpha(2)$. This is the $^1\Sigma_\mathrm g^-$ that you are looking for.


Return for a while to the case where the two electrons were in the same $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbitals. If you replace all the $b$'s with $a$'s in the above wavefunction, it simply vanishes to zero: this wavefunction is no longer physically permissible if we are talking about two electrons in the same $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbitals.




This state would no doubt be ridiculously high in energy. It's certainly not listed in the NIST WebBook, which instead lists a state of symmetry $^1\Sigma_\mathrm u^-$, as opposed to $^1\Sigma_\mathrm g^-$ which I've been talking about. This is much easier to access. All you need to do is to promote one $1\pi_\mathrm u$ electron to the $1\pi_\mathrm g$ orbitals, which gets you to an electronic configuration of $(1\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\sigma_\mathrm u)^2(2\sigma_\mathrm g)^2(1\pi_\mathrm u)^3(1\pi_\mathrm g)^3$.


From a symmetry perspective, the $\pi$ orbitals with three electrons may be thought of as having one hole instead of three electrons. So, the allowed term symbols are simply given by


$$\Pi_\mathrm g \times \Pi_\mathrm u = \Sigma_\mathrm u^+ + \Sigma_\mathrm u^- + \Delta_\mathrm u$$



and again, since the holes are in different $\pi$-type orbitals, there is no need to account for the antisymmetrisation in square brackets. This is how you obtain the $^1\Sigma_\mathrm u^-$ state which is $33\,057~\mathrm{cm^{-1}}$ above the $^3\Sigma_\mathrm g^+$ ground state.


For dinitrogen you need to promote one electron from the $\pi_\mathrm u$ orbital to the empty antibonding $\pi_\mathrm g$ orbital, such that you have one $\pi_\mathrm u$ hole and one $\pi_\mathrm g$ electron. Again following the same formula you can obtain the $^1\Sigma_\mathrm u^-$ state.


Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...