Tuesday, 5 December 2017

optics - Detailed form of light waves in vacuum and how to test it experimentally?


Consider a light wave in vacuum.



  • Do the $\vec{B}$ and $\vec{E}$ fields have to be orthogonal to each other? Since you can add constants to a solution to Maxwell's equation it doesn't seem neccesary from theory.


  • How would one measure if the $\vec{B}$ and $\vec{E}$-vectors of a light wave are perpendicular?




  • Must it be a plane wave? How to determine that by measurement?





  • Must $\vec{E}$ and $\vec{B}$ be in phase? How to test this experimentally?




Edit:


A part of my question is covered in Does the direction of propagation of the natural light is perpendicular to the direction of electric and magnetic field making up natural light? but that question is closed and the answers doesn't help. However my question is more about experiment than theory, so is a different question.




Monday, 4 December 2017

quantum mechanics - Physical examples of wave function that is stationary in space and varying in time. Something like $Psi(x,t) = psi(t)e^{-ikx}$


We know time independent Schrodinger equation, where the wave function is stationary in time and varies in space. Simple examples are, particle in an infinite potential well, and the Hydrogen atom, which is a particle in a time independent, radially attractive electric field.



What I wonder and would like to know is that, is there any real world situation where the wave function is stationary in space and varying in time, something on the lines of "space-independent Schrodinger equation", if it exists. (I don't know its formula or its existence, even in theory).


Something like $$\Psi(x,t) = \psi(t)e^{-ikx}$$. I'd like to know if any simple examples exist and also its physical interpretations. I am just super curious. (The observable still being assumed as bounded self adjoint linear operators), everything about QM still intact.




quantum mechanics - What is expectation values of this anti-commutator $langle { Delta hat x,Delta hat p} rangle~?$


What is expectation values of this anti-commutator $\langle \{ \Delta \hat x,\Delta \hat p\} \rangle~?$


where the $\Delta \hat p=\hat p-\langle \hat p \rangle$ and $\hat p$ is momentum operator and so $\Delta \hat x=\hat x-\langle \hat x \rangle$ and $\hat x$ is position operator operator.




quantum mechanics - Naive interpretation of Galilean invariance of the TDSE


I was told today by someone smarter than myself that the time-dependent Schroedinger equation in one dimension was invariant under a Galilean transformation of $(x,t)$, namely under


$$\begin{cases}x'=x+ut\\t'=t\end{cases}.\tag{1}$$


Going to check this, I looked at the time dependent Schroedinger equation of a free particle.



$$i\hbar\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial t} = -\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{\partial^2\psi}{\partial x^2}\tag{2}$$


Computing the transformation of the differential operators via the chain rule:


$$\begin{cases} \frac{\partial}{\partial x}=\frac{\partial t'}{\partial x}\frac{\partial}{\partial t'}+\frac{\partial x'}{\partial x}\frac{\partial}{\partial x'} = \frac{\partial}{\partial x'} \\ \frac{\partial}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial t'}{\partial t}\frac{\partial}{\partial t'}+\frac{\partial x'}{\partial t}\frac{\partial}{\partial x'} = \frac{\partial}{\partial t'}+u\frac{\partial}{\partial x'} \end{cases}$$


and plugging all of this back into $(2)$ gives the TDSE in the relatively inertial frame $(x',t')$.


$$i\hbar\left(\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial t'}+u\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial x'}\right)=-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{\partial^2\psi}{\partial x'^2}\tag{3}$$


This would imply that there's some additional term like $i\hbar u\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial x'}$ in the equation that represents an asymmetry under $(1)$. We have that said term is not zero (for that would imply that the wavefunction is space-independent in the relative frame, which is clearly not the case). Clearly I've misunderstood something here - is $(2)$ not Galilean invariant after all?



Answer



In your derivation you've implicitly assumed that the wavefunction does not change its values when you go to the Galilean boosted frame. In other words, you've assumed $\psi'(x', t') = \psi \bigl(x(x',t'), t(x',t') \bigr)$. However, this isn't right.


The wavefunction encodes information about a particle's momentum, so when you go to a different frame the wavefunction must change to represent the momentum the particle has in the new frame. For example, in the case of a plane wave, $\psi(x, t) = e^{i(kx - \omega t)}$. When you boost by velocity $u$, the wave's $k, \omega$ must change to match the new momentum and energy, like $k' = k + mu/\hbar$ and $\omega' = \hbar k'^2 / 2m$. So it's not the same function anymore; it has different wavelength and frequency, above and beyond the simple change of coordinates.


In other words, the Schrödinger equation is Galilean-invariant not in the sense that the same solution works after a boost, but in the sense that there exist solutions representing waves traveling at all different speeds. A boost maps a solution with $k, \omega$ to another solution with $k', \omega'$. (And for solutions that are not plane waves, we can use the Fourier transform to decompose them into plane waves, boost each one, and recompose them.)



This argument might be a bit unsatisfying since it relies on physical intuition about the meaning of wavelength and frequency, rather than being a purely mathematical derivation. I wonder if you might be able to derive it more rigorously from some operator-algebraic considerations, or some such.


Sunday, 3 December 2017

special relativity - Clock in a sealed box at half the speed of light. How would it know it is moving?


Consider a clock enclosed in a sealed box here on earth syncronized with my wrist watch. I send the boxed clock around the galaxy a couple of times at half the speed of light (or the full speed of light..). I hear that the clocks will be out of sync when the boxed clock comes back on earth.

Is that true?
How would the boxed clock know it was moving when it was actually stationary in reference to the box?
I hear explanations about how when traveling from point A to point B, time and space became one. I do not understand that, but that's besides the point. In this question point A is same as point B. So the clock has come back to where it started. Does the time for the moving clock somehow come back to be in sync with the wrist watch ?
Would the effects of departing the earth at c cancel out because of the effects of approaching when the jurney is over?




Scientist propose solution to quantum measurement problem, explain further


Link to Article


The scientists




In their recent opus magnum, Theo Nieuwenhuizen (Institute of Physics, UvA) and colleagues claim to have found a solution to the so-called quantum measurement problem



Their claim



After reviewing the literature on measurement models, they focus on the so-called Curie-Weiss model for quantum measurements. The joint dynamics of the tested system coupled to the measurement apparatus now produces results that explain the measurement postulates. It shows that the off-diagonal terms ("cat-terms") disappear in a physical process due to the coupling to the apparatus, on a basis selected by the interaction Hamiltonian. The registration of the measurement outcomes by the pointer of the apparatus occurs because the measurement triggers the transition from the initial metastable state to one of the stable final states; the apparatus being large, this means an amplification of the signal. The transition of the pointer variable from its initial metastable state to one of the final stable states is a process with classical features, such as the dumping of excess free energy in the bath.



I am by no means a physicist, but I do enjoy trying to understand some of the issues they face. From what I've read this quantum measurement problem, well is a problem. Could someone explain why it is a problem, and how these scientist from the Institute of Physics propose to solve it? (as layman as possible)



Answer



“quantum measurement problem” is a not real "problem" which these authors say they offer a "physical way out of a mathematical embarrassment” to something that is certainly not an embarrassment. Instead quantum uncertainty is what nature tells us about what is and what we can know. They are reported to conclude that the "dynamical instabilities inside the apparatus near the end of the measurement." can permit the statistical outcomes without need for a physical collapse. But no collapse nor multiple universes are really needed at all. That gets to the point that QM is not classic physics and trying to make it that is not productive. The reporting is that:


"The statistical formulation of quantum mechanics, though abstract and minimalist, is sufficient to explain all relevant features. Since alternative interpretations involve unnecessary assumptions of one kind or another, the authors advocate the usage of the statistical formulation in physics education of quantum mechanics."



So their conclusion is correct but I don't get why they think they have added anything - that is unless somehow saying that some large collection of quantum states that we call a measuring device can form a meta-stable state that then does not collapse when an observation is made. Although it is controversial to say this it is I think most correct to say that there is no wave function collapse. there is no measurement problem. Uncertainty is inherent. QM requires that we give up usual notions of reality but it requires little beyond HS math to follow. The description of the wave function is a math language that best allows us to describe what nature allows us to predict or know. It has withstood all tests. It is absolutely clear that one cannot separate measurer and measured. It requires no collapse to provide it's answers and it tells us that we cannot know more than probabilistic outcomes for what we choose subjectively as observations.


quantum mechanics - How is the Hanbury-Brown and Twiss effect used to measure the size of stars?


I understand what an Hanbury Brown and Twiss (HBT) interferometer does, but how can this be used to measure the apparent angular diameter of some object?


What is the mathematical explaination?



Answer



An HBTI works in a very similar manner to a Fizeau / Michelson stellar interferometer. But in an HBTI, a correlation is made between fluctuations of amplitude (intensity) at points across a surface, unlike a Fizeau/Michelson which correlates fluctuations in phase. The timing of these fluctuations is much longer and this leads to a much larger tolerance in path length differences than with phase interferometers.


It can be shown[1][2] that the visibility $V$ at a baseline $d$ is equal to: $$V^{2}=\gamma^{2}= \frac{\langle I_1 * I_2 \rangle}{\langle I_1 \rangle \langle I_2 \rangle}$$


Where $I_1$ and $I_2$ are the measurements at two separated detectors, and the angle brackets indicate time averages.



[1] The Intensity Interferometer, Hanbury Brown.
[2] Optical Stellar Interferometry, Labeyrie.


Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...