Wednesday, 3 January 2018

Will relative velocity of light exceed $c$?



Suppose I'm standing a few light minutes away from a light emitting object, as soon as the light is turned on, I project myself towards the object with some speed. Will the relative velocity of my speed and $c$ add up to give a velocity higher than speed of light?




classical mechanics - What makes a theory "Quantum"?


Say you cook up a model about a physical system. Such a model consists of, say, a system of differential equations. What criterion decides whether the model is classical or quantum-mechanical?


None of the following criteria are valid:




  • Partial differential equations: Both the Maxwell equations and the Schrödinger equation are PDE's, but the first model is clearly classical and the second one is not. Conversely, finite-dimensional quantum systems have as equations of motion ordinary differential equations, so the latter are not restricted to classical systems only.





  • Complex numbers: You can use those to analyse electric circuits, so that's not enough. Conversely, you don't need complex numbers to formulate standard QM (cf. this PSE post).




  • Operators and Hilbert spaces: You can formulate classical mechanics à la Koopman-von Neumann. In the same vein:




  • Dirac-von Neumann axioms: These are too restrictive (e.g., they do not accommodate topological quantum field theories). Also, a certain model may be formulated in such a way that it's very hard to tell whether it satisfies these axioms or not. For example, the Schrödinger equation corresponds to a model that does not explicitly satisfy these axioms; and only when formulated in abstract terms this becomes obvious. It's not clear whether the same thing could be done with e.g. the Maxwell equations. In fact, one can formulate these equations as a Dirac-like equation $(\Gamma^\mu\partial_\mu+\Gamma^0)\Psi=0$ (see e.g. 1804.00556), which can be recast in abstract terms as $i\dot\Psi=H\Psi$ for a certain $H$.





  • Probabilities: Classical statistical mechanics does also deal with probabilistic concepts. Also, one could argue that standard QM is not inherently probabilistic, but that probabilities are an emergent property due to the measurement process and our choice of observable degrees of freedom.




  • Planck's constant: It's just a matter of units. You can eliminate this constant by means of the redefinition $t\to \hbar t$. One could even argue that this would be a natural definition from an experimental point of view, if we agree to measure frequencies instead of energies. Conversely, you may introduce this constant in classical mechanics by a similar change of variables (say, $F=\hbar\tilde F$ in the Newton equation). Needless to say, such a change of variables would be unnatural, but naturalness is not a well-defined criterion for classical vs. quantum.




  • Realism/determinism: This seems to depend on interpretations. But whether a theory is classical or quantum mechanical should not depend on how we interpret the theory; it should be intrinsic to the formalism.





People are after a quantum theory of gravity. What prevents me from saying that General Relativity is already quantum mechanical? It seems intuitively obvious that it is a classical theory, but I'm not sure how to put that intuition into words. None of the criteria above is conclusive.



Answer



I think this is a subtle question and I think it depends somewhat on how you choose to represent quantum mechanics. To see one extreme of this, consider the viewpoint put forth by Kibble in [1]. For simplicity I will be thinking of finite-dimensional quantum systems here; there are some subtleties in infinite dimensions but as far as I know the basic picture still holds. In this, he shows that if we describe the theory in terms of physical states (rays in the Hilbert space), then the dynamics of Schrödinger evolution correspond exactly to Hamiltonian evolution via the symplectic form from the Kähler structure on the projective Hilbert space (which is to say, the evolution is that of a classical system). However there are two distinctions which make quantum mechanics different from classical mechanics:



  • The phase space must be a projective Hilbert space (as opposed to just a symplectic manifold), and the Hamiltonian is restricted to being a quadratic form in the homogeneous coordinates on projective space. In classical mechanics any (sufficiently smooth) function is admissible as a Hamiltonian.

  • Composite systems are described differently. In classical mechanics the phase space of a composite system is the Cartesian product of the phase spaces. In quantum mechanics, it is the Segre embedding (which descends from the tensor product of Hilbert spaces). This is parametrically different; if the phase spaces of the two subsystems are $2m$ and $2n$, then in classical mechanics the composite system has dimension $2m+2n$, whereas in quantum mechanics it has dimension $2(n+1)(m+1)-2$. The extra states are the entangled states. Virtually all the observable consequences of QM come here, e.g. Bell inequalities. Of course if we consider identical particles things get even a bit more complicated.


If you ignore the second point, and focus only on a single quantum system, the surprising conclusion is that every quantum mechanical system is a special case of classical mechanics (with the provision that again I haven't checked the details in infinite dimensions but it is at least morally true). However, part of the structure of quantum mechanics is how it describes composite systems so you can't just ignore this second point. A mathematician would say that this gives an injective functor from the category of quantum mechanical theories to the category of classical theories which is not compatible with the symmetric monoidal structures on the two.


I want to point out that this is emphatically not how we typically think of the correspondence principle in quantum mechanics. That is, it is a mapping from a finite-dimensional quantum mechanical system to a finite-dimensional classical system (of the same dimension). Normally, if we think about e.g. a free particle in one dimension, the Hilbert space for that quantum system is infinite dimensional, yet it corresponds to a 2-dimensional classical phase space. But the point is that, at least in this question, we can't restrict to the ordinary notion of correspondence since we don't have a physical interpretation for the system of equations describing the theory.


Additionally, despite the above example, whether a theory is classical or quantum has essentially nothing to do with where the states live. Indeed, if we just want to consider a free particle in one dimension again, we would typically describe its state as a self-adjoint trace class unit trace operator $\hat \rho$ on the Hilbert space $L^2(\mathbb R)$. In contrast, in classical mechanics we would describe a state as a probability distribution $\rho$ on the phase space $\mathbb R^2$ (note that in the above example we had only pure classical states i.e. only those described by a $\delta$ function on the phase space whereas now we have mixed states). However we could just as easily describe the quantum state by its Wigner function, in which case it lives in exactly the same affine space as the classical distribution. However the Wigner function satisfies slightly different inequalities than the classical probability distribution; in particular it can be slightly negative and cannot be too positive. The details of this were first worked out in [2]. In this case, it is the dynamics that give away the quantum nature. Specifically, to go from classical to quantum mechanics, we must replace the Poisson bracket by the Moyal bracket (which has $O(\hbar^2)$ corrections), indicating the failure of Liouville's theorem in the phase space formulation of quantum mechanics: (quasi)probability density is not conserved along trajectories of the system.



All of this is to say that it seems difficult (and maybe impossible) to try to find a single distinguishing feature between classical and quantum mechanics without considering composite systems, so if that is what you want, I'm not sure I have an answer. If you do allow for composite systems though, it is a pretty unambiguous distinction. Given this, it is perhaps not surprising that all the experimental tests we have which demonstrate that the world is quantum and not classical are based on entanglement.


References:


[1]: Kibble, T. W. B. "Geometrization of quantum mechanics". Comm. Math. Phys. 65 (1979), no. 2, 189--201.


[2]: H.J. Groenewold (1946), "On the Principles of elementary quantum mechanics", Physica 12, pp. 405-460.


antimatter - Are antiparticles just particle-shaped holes?


If particles are simply regions of space where certain quantum fields have non-zero divergence, are anti-particles simply the corresponding regions of opposite divergence?


This seems like the intuitive answer, especially when considering the process of annihilation. I have heard before that anti-particles are analogous to particles moving through time in reverse, which seems to indicate that an annihilation event is just a point of symmetry in that (arguably, single) particle's history. This analogy breaks down, however, when it comes to gravitation, since there seems to be no evidence of a negative-mass particle.


So what then is the meaning of an anti-particle, when their symmetry is preserved across certain fields, but not other?




Tuesday, 2 January 2018

special relativity - Understanding the difference between co- and contra-variant vectors


I am looking at the 4-vector treatment of special relativity, but I have had no formal training in Tensor algebra and thus am having difficulty understanding some of the concepts which appear.



One such concept is the notion of contra- and co-variant vectors. Wikipedia describes a contra-variant vector as varying with the co-ordinates, i.e. the inverse of the reference axes. It gives the example of a change of basis matrix $\mathbf{M}$, and a contra-variant vector $\vec{v}$ and states that in the new set of co-ordinates, we have:


$$\vec{v}'=\mathbf{M}\vec{v}$$


It then states that a covariant vector varies with the co-ordinate axes.



Does this mean that for a covariant vector $\vec{u}$ and change of basis matrix $\mathbf{M}$ we have: $$\vec{u}'=\mathbf{M}^{-1}\vec{u}?$$



I am also having problems understanding the concept of raising and lowering indices. For instance, Wikipedia states that for two four-vectors $\vec{A},\vec{B}$ and using Einstein summation we have:


$$\left\langle \vec{A} \middle|\vec{B} \right\rangle=A^{\mu}B_{\mu}=A_{\nu}B^{\nu}$$


And I am having difficulty understanding how this relates to the other definition of the inner product:


$$\left\langle \vec{A} \middle|\vec{B} \right\rangle =\mathbf{A}^{T}\mathbf{\eta}\mathbf{B}$$



If anyone could help give me a more intuitive understanding of these concepts I would be grateful.



Answer



Contravariant vectors are "standard" vectors. Covariant vectors are linear applications on contavariant vectors producing scalars.


Let us start form the former case. If you fix a couple of bases $\{e_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ and $\{e'_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ in the finite dimensional vector space $V$ with dimension $n$, such that $e_i = \sum_j {A^j}_i e'_j$ for set of coefficients ${A^j}_i$ forming a (necessarily) non-singular matrix $A$, you have for a given vector $v \in V$: $$v = \sum_i v^i e_i = \sum_j v'^j e'_j$$ and thuso $$\sum_i v^i \sum_j {A^j}_i e'_j = \sum_j v'^j e'_j$$ so that: $$\sum_j \left( \sum_i {A^j}_i v^i\right) e'_j = \sum_j v'^j e'_j\:.$$ Uniqueness of components of $v$ respect to $\{e'_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ eventually entails: $$v'^j = \sum_i {A^j}_i v^i\qquad \mbox{where}\quad e_i = \sum_j {A^j}_i e'_j\tag1$$ This is nothing but the standard rule for transforming components of a given contravariant vector when one changes the decomposition basis.


Let us pass to consider covariant vectors. As I said above, a covariant vector is nothing but a linear map $\omega : V \to R$ ($R$ can be replaced by $C$ if dealing with complex vector spaces or the corresponding ring when considering modules). One easily proves that the set of real valued linear applications as above form a vector space, $V^*$, the so-called dual space of $V$. If $\{e_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ is a basis of $V$, there is an associated basis $$\{e^{*i}\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$$ of $V^*$, the dual basis, defined by the requirements (in addition to linearity): $$e^{*k}(e_i) = \delta^k_i\tag2$$ Therefore, a covariant vector $\omega \in V^*$ can alway decomposed as follows: $$\omega = \sum_k \omega_k e^{*k}$$ and, using linearity, (2), and $$v = \sum_i v^i e_i$$ one sees that $$\omega(v) = \sum_k \omega_k v^k\:.$$ The RHS doe not depend on the choice of the basis $\{e_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ and the corresponding $\{e^{*i}\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ even if components of covariant and contravariant vectors $\omega$ and $v$ depend on the considered bases. Obviously, changing the basis in $V$ and passing to $\{e'_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ related to $\{e_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ through (1), $\{e'_i\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$ turns out to correspond to a dual basis $\{e'^{*i}\}_{i=1,\ldots,n}$. A straightforward computation based on (2) shows that $$e^{*i} = \sum_j {B_j}^i e'^{*j}$$ where $$B= \left(A^T\right)^{-1}\:.\tag3$$ Consequently, for a covariant vector $$\omega = \sum_i \omega_i e^{*i} = \sum_j \omega'_j e'^{*j}$$ where $$\omega'_j = \sum_j{B_j}^i \omega_i\:.\tag4$$ This relation, together with (3) is nothing but the standard rule for transforming components of a given covariant vector when one changes the decomposition basis.


This structure rarely appears dealing with classical physics, where one usually deals with orthonormal basis. The reason is that when changing basis and passing to another orthonormal basis, the matrix $A$ associating the bases is in the orthogonal group, so that: $$B= \left(A^T\right)^{-1} =A\:.\tag3$$ and one cannot distinguish, working in components, between covariant and contravariant vectors, since the former in (1) and (4) are, in fact, identical. For instance, for a fixed force $F$ applied to a point with velocity $v$, the linear map associating the force with its power as a function of $v$ defines a covariant vector that we could indicate by $"F\cdot"$ $$\pi^{(F)}: v \mapsto F\cdot v$$ where $\cdot$ denotes the standard scalar product in the Euclidean rest space of a reference frame.


If the (real finite dimensional!) vector space $V$ is equipped with a, generally, indefinite, scalar product, that is a non-degenerate symmetric bi-linear map $g : V \times V \to R$, a natural identification of $V$ and $V^*$ arises. It is nothing but the linear and bijective map associating contravariant vectors with covariant vectors: $$V \ni v \mapsto g(v, \:\:)\in V^*$$ Where, obviously $g(v, \:\:) : V \ni u \mapsto g(v, u)\in R$ turns out to be linear and thus define an element of $V^*$ as said. In components, if $u= \sum_i u^i e_i$ and $s= \sum_i s^i e_i$, one has in view of the bilinearity property fulfilled by $g$: $$g(u,s) = \sum_{i,j} g_{ij} u^is^j\qquad \mbox{where}\quad g_{ij} := g(e_i,e_j)\:.$$ The matrix of elements $g_{ij}$ is symmetric and non-singular (as $g$ is symmetric and non-degenerate). With this definition, one easily sees that, if $u\in V$ is a contravariant vector, the associated covariant one $g(u,\:\:)\in V^*$ has components: $$g(u, \:\:\:)_k= \sum_ig_{ki}u^i$$ so that, the scalar product $g(u,v)$ of $u$ and $v$ can also be written: $$g(u,v)= \sum_{ij} g_{ij}u^iv^j = \sum_i v_i u^i\:.$$


Finally, changing basis one has that: $$g(u,s) = \sum_{i,j} g'_{lm} u'^ls'^m\qquad \mbox{where}\quad g'_{lm} := g(e'_l,e'_m)\:,$$ and $$g'_{lm} = \sum_{ij}{B_l}^i {B_m}^j g_{il}\:.$$


electromagnetism - Could there be equivalence between anisotropic space and the presence of a field?




What if we are so used to the curvature of space caused by mass and the range of its effects that we totally ignore the possibility of the existence of "opposite" curvature1, i.e. objects that bend space opposite to mass and cause repulsion by creating local space anisotropy?


What if we are so used to space curvature caused by mass that we invent a force that has no charge to explain possible effects of opposite curvature (repelling force - diamagnetism)?


What if the oscillating electric field has the ability to cause tiny local (anisotropy) fluctuations in space and its effects on objects are interpreted as "magnetic field"?


Could magnets be just an example of objects with anomalous gravitational fields due to their ability to distort the isotropy of space?


I guess my question boils down to:


How do we know that the force at the poles of a magnet is not gravitational (large but local curvature caused by anisotropy) with opposite signs, rather than what we call magnetic?


Can space curvature arise from something else different than mass?


What would change on the r.h.s of the Einstein's equation (components of stress-energy tensor) if we assume a connection with torsion?





1. Same size of the volume element $dV$, but with stretch in one element, say $dx$ and proportional compression in the other two $dy$, $dz$.




atomic physics - Why do the electron in Bohr's principal quantum levels or ground state do not emit radiation?




Bohr said that only certain orbits of definite energy are allowed inside the atom. He said that the electrons in their ground state do not emit radiation and that they will emit radiation when they fall from higher energy levels to lower energy levels. My question is what does orbits with definite energy mean? and why do the electron in their ground state not emit radiation?



Answer




what does orbits with definite energy mean?



It means that each orbit has an amount of energy associated with it. If you move between 2 orbits, it requires a certain amount of energy. It will be the same amount of energy for the same transition in the same atoms. Different transitions have different amounts of energy and different atoms have different orbits (resulting in different energies).



why do the electron in their ground state not emit radiation?



The ground state is defined as when all the electrons are in the lowest energy configuration for the atom (or ion). Electrons emit radiation (photons) when they drop down in energy levels in the atom. If the electrons are in the ground state, they cannot drop lower in energy, thus emitting a photon.



quantum mechanics - Angular momentum for 3D harmonic oscillator in two different bases


I know that the energy eigenstates of the 3D quantum harmonic oscillator can be characterized by three quantum numbers: $$ | n_1,n_2,n_3\rangle$$ or, if solved in the spherical coordinate system: $$|N,l,m\rangle$$


The relationship between capital $N$ and the little $n_i$'s is straightforward: $N=n_1+n_2+n_3$, but this can't be said for the other quantum numbers. I want to find a way of relating the two representations, but I'm not sure how to go about doing this (my linear algebra background is pretty weak).


Let's say I fix the energy to be $\frac{5\hbar \omega}{2}$, which is equivalent to saying $N=1$. There are three states corresponding to this situation in the first representation: $| 1,0,0\rangle, |0,1,0\rangle,| 0,0,1\rangle$. But what are the corresponding states in the second representation? If $N$ is fixed to be $1$, what are the allowed values of $l$ and $m$? I remember that $l=0,...,N-1$, and $-l\leq m\leq l$, but this makes no sense, since it would mean both $m$ and $l$ would have to be $0$...




Answer



We introduce the ladder operators $a^\dagger_i, a_i$ such that \begin{align}x_i & = \sqrt{\frac{\hbar}{2m\omega}} (a^\dagger_i + a_i) \\ p_i & = i\sqrt{\frac{\hbar m\omega}{2}} (a^\dagger_i - a_i) \end{align} where $i = 1,2,3$. The commutators are of course $$[a_i, a^\dagger_j] = \delta_{ij}.$$


Then the angular momentum operator is $$L_i = \epsilon_{ijk}x_j p_k$$ with $\epsilon_{ijk}$ the Levi-Civita symbol and sums over $j, k$ implied. On expanding $x_j p_k$ only $-a^\dagger_j a_k$ and $a_j a^\dagger_k$ contribute, since $a_k a_j$ is symmetric in $k,j$. These two terms give equal contributions since their commutator is symmetric in $k,j$. It follows that $$L_i = -i\hbar\epsilon_{ijk} a^\dagger_j a_k.$$


Now defining $$a_+ = \frac{-1}{\sqrt 2} (a_x - ia_y) \qquad a_- = \frac{1}{\sqrt 2}(a_x + ia_y)$$ we have $[a_\pm, a_\pm^\dagger]= 1$ and $$L_z = \hbar(a^\dagger_+ a_+ - a^\dagger_- a_-).$$ It is rather clear that $a^\dagger_\pm$ raise $N$ by $1$, and $a_\pm$ adds an excitation with $L_z = \pm\hbar$: $L_z$ is the difference between the number operators corresponding to $a_\pm$.


Using these operators you can in principle work out the matrix for $L_z$ (and also $L_x$ and $L_y$) and $L^2$. Since the $L_i$ operators contain only products one creation and one annihilation operator they do not connect states with different $N$. It follows that neither does $L^2$, so you can consider each $N$ separately. Once you have these matrices, diagonalizing them will tell you how to express the $|N, l, m\rangle$ in terms of the $|n_x,n_y, n_z\rangle$.


Note that for each $N$ there are $(N+2)(N+1)/2$ states, so you probably don't want to do this by hand except maybe for $N = 2$ (the $N = 0,1$ cases are trivial). Maybe you can get Mathematica or Maple to do it for you for some larger $N$.




For $N = 1$ we can calculate as follows. $$a_+ |0,0,1\rangle =\frac{-1}{\sqrt 2}(a_x - ia_y)|0,0,1\rangle = 0.$$ What we have used here is that $$a_x |n_x, n_y, n_z\rangle = \sqrt{n_x}|n_x-1,n_y,n_z\rangle$$ and similarly for $y,z$. We obtain the same with $a_-$, so this means that $L_z |0,0,1\rangle = 0$, so the state $|0,0,1\rangle$ has $m = 0$. For $|1,0,0\rangle$, we have $$a_+|1,0,0\rangle = -a_- |0,1,0\rangle = -\frac{1}{\sqrt 2} |0,0,0\rangle$$ from which we get $$a^\dagger_+ a_+ |1,0,0\rangle = \frac{1}{2} \big( |1,0,0\rangle + i |0,1,0\rangle\big)$$ $$a^\dagger_- a_- |1,0,0\rangle = \frac{1}{2} \big(|1,0,0\rangle - i|0,1,0\rangle\big).$$ Thus $$L_z |1,0,0\rangle = i\hbar |0,1,0\rangle.$$ Now you can probably work out on your own that $L_z |0,1,0\rangle = -i\hbar |1,0,0\rangle.$ This gives the matrix for $L_z$ on $N = 1$ states as $$L_z = \begin{pmatrix}0 & i & 0 \\ -i & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & 0 & 0 \end{pmatrix}.$$ The eigenvalues of $L_z$ are given by the solutions to $$m(m^2-1) = 0$$ which are $m = 0, \pm 1$. We already know that $|0,0,1\rangle$ is the eigenvector corresponding to $m = 0$. To find the eigenvector corresponding to $m = \pm 1$, we have to solve the system of linear equations \begin{align}iy & = \pm x \\ -ix & = \pm y\end{align} which just says $x = \pm i y$ (the two equations are equivalent). Thus $$L_z \big( |1,0,0\rangle \pm i |0,1,0\rangle\big) = \pm\hbar \big( |1,0,0\rangle \pm i |0,1,0\rangle\big).$$


Since we found three states, with $m = -1,0,1$, we must have $l = 1$.


Of course in this simple case we could also have reasoned like this: $a^\dagger_\pm$ adds an excitation with angular momentum $\pm \hbar$. Knowing that $L_z|0,0,0\rangle = 0$, we get states with $m = \pm 1$ just by acting with $a^\dagger_\pm$ on $|0,0,0\rangle$. Indeed up to a normalization this is just what we found.



Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...