Tuesday, 23 December 2014

conservation laws - Why doesn't precessing a spin cause a measurement?


When an electron is placed in a magnetic field, its spin precesses. Why doesn't this reveal the spin via angular momentum being transferred into the environment?




Impractical Thought Experiment


Suppose we have an electron with a spin that's either exactly $|\text{left}\rangle$ or exactly $|\text{right}\rangle$, but we don't know which. We apply a magnetic field pointing upward just long enough for the spin to precess by a half turn. In effect, we negated the direction of the electron's spin.


But doesn't just negating the spin violate conservation of angular momentum? If the electron's spin was $|\text{right}\rangle$ then it started with +1/2 angular momentum along the X axis but now it is -1/2. There's a missing +1-along-X bit of angular momentum; presumably it went into the surrounding system?



So, in principle, if we could know the total angular momentum of the relevant-parts-of-system-except-electron before and after precessing by a half turn, we would have determined the spin of the electron. Meaning it was measured, or at least entangled.


But that clearly can't be right, or we wouldn't describe what-an-eletron's-spin-does-when-hit-by-a-magnetic-field as precession. A partially measured/entangled spin doesn't act like a partially rotated spin.


I realize that I must be overlooking a very basic piece of information.



Answer



You are right that the magnetic field, or rather the apparatus used to generate it, absorbs some angular momentum from the quantum spin. This apparatus includes, for example, some coils of wire containing more than $10^{23}$ electrons, as well as many other macroscopic components. The upshot is that increasing the angular momentum of this apparatus by an amount of order $\hbar$ leaves the apparatus in an almost indistinguishable state. However, in order for this process to constitute a decent measurement, the possible final states of the apparatus (depending on whether the spin was initially $\lvert \mathrm{left}\rangle$ or $\lvert \mathrm{right}\rangle$) must be distinguishable, i.e. almost orthogonal. If you want to think in terms of entanglement, this means that the entanglement generated between the magnetic field and the spin is negligibly small. This is why, so long as we only care about the dynamics of the quantum spin itself, we can reduce all the complexity of the field and the apparatus used to generate it into a single external, classical parameter entering the spin's Hamiltonian.


PS. You could ask essentially the same question, with essentially the same answer, about many different experimental setups, e.g. why doesn't the recoil momentum of a photon bouncing off the mirrors reveal the which-way information in a Mach-Zehnder inteferometer?


general relativity - Bending of light - photon's inertia instead of mass


Using classical mechanics, the formula for gravitational attraction is


$$F = G\frac{m_1m_2}{r^2}.$$


This formula does not work for photons, and we need to use Einstein's theory of gravity to account for that, as the photon is massless. What if, instead of using the mass of the photon, we rather used the inertia of it?


The momentum of a photon is


$$p=\frac{h}{\lambda}.$$



Thus, using that, we can calculate its supposed 'mass' (inertia) as momentum is also equal to mass times velocity. So 'mass' of a photon is


$$m=\frac{p}{v}=\frac{h}{\lambda c}.$$


If we use this mass as the mass of a photon, can we use Newton's equation for gravitational attraction?



Answer



In Newtonian gravity the acceleration due to gravity is independant of the mass of the object - a falling elephant accelerates downwards at the same speed as an accelerating gnat (ignoring air resistance). That means the orbit of an object does not depend on the object's mass (provided the object is much lighter than the star).


The deflection of an object by a massive body is just a hyperbolic orbit, and like any other orbit the trajectory doesn't depend on the mass of the orbiting object, just its velocity and initial position. This means that if we calculate the angular deflection of an object travelling at $c$ in a hyperbolic orbit the result turns out to be independant of the mass of the object:


$$ \theta \approx \frac{2GM}{r_0 c^2} $$


where $M$ is the mass of the star/planet/whatever and $r_0$ is the distance of closest approach.


The point is that assuming some hypothetical value for the photon mass doesn't affect the Newtonian prediction because the Newtonian prediction doesn't depend on mass. So the answer to your question is that no, using an effective photon mass of $m = h/\lambda c$ does not give the correct result.


The GR calculation gives the deflection of light as:



$$ \theta \approx \frac{4GM}{r_0 c^2} $$


which is twice the Newtonian result. But this isn't some special case that applies only to light because GR gives different results to Newtonian gravity for all objects regardless of mass - the deflection of light is just a limiting case.


quantum mechanics - Disproof of Bell’s Theorem



The half-page arxiv doc by Joy Christian of Oxford Uni, UK has the Title and Abstract:


Disproof of Bell’s Theorem



We illustrate an explicit counterexample to Bell’s theorem by constructing a pair of dichotomic variables that exactly reproduce the EPR-Bohm correlations in a manifestly local-realistic manner.



As The Bell's theorem is often cited it seems important to clarify this short doc.
Is the doc OK?


This recent paper Comments on "Disproof of Bell's theorem" by Florin Moldoveanu (July 06,2011)

can shed light in the interpretation and importance of the work of Joy and may be the case that the answers could benefit from it.


One conclusion that seems relevant, imo, is that Geometric Algebra is very promising to model the physical world.


LM post @TRF pointed to a pre-print of Gill (Simple refutation of Joy Christian's simple refutation of Bell's simple theorem)
and the Joy answer (Refutation of Richard Gill's Argument Against my Disproof of Bell's Theorem)
(thanks LM)




electromagnetism - What is the mechanism behind the slowdown of light/photons in a transparent medium?



So light travels slower in glass (for example) than in a vacuum. What causes light to slow down? Or: How does it slow down? If light passes through the medium, is it not essentially traveling in the "vacuum" between the atoms?



Answer



The easiest way to get the exact behavior is from thinking about light as a classical wave interacting with the atoms in the solid material. As long as you're far away from any of the resonant frequencies of the relevant atoms, this picture isn't too bad.


You can think each of the atoms as being like a little dipole, consisting of some positive and some negative charge that is driven back and forth by the off-resonant light field. Being an assemblage of charges that are accelerating due to the driving field, these dipoles will radiate, producing waves at the same frequency as the driving field, but slightly out of phase with it (because a dipole being driven at a frequency other than its resonance frequency will be slightly out of phase with the driving field). The total light field in the material will be the sum of the driving light field and the field produced by the oscillating dipoles. If you go through a little bit of math, you find that this gives you a beam in the same direction as the original beam-- the waves going out to the sides will mostly interfere destructively with each other-- with the same frequency but with a slight delay compared to the driving field. This delay registers as a slowing of the speed of the wave passing through the medium. The exact amount of the delay depends on the particulars of the material, such as the exact resonant frequencies of the atoms in question.


As long as you're not too close to one of the resonant frequencies, this gives you a really good approximation of the effect (and "too close" here is a pretty narrow range). It works well enough that most people who deal with this stuff stay with this kind of picture, rather than talking in terms of photons. The basic idea of treating the atoms like little dipoles is a variant of "Huygens's Principle," by the way, which is a general technique for thinking about how waves behave.


Monday, 22 December 2014

what physical quantity do real scalar field operators create/destroy?


Let $\phi(\textbf{x}) \neq \phi^\dagger(\textbf{x})$ be a complex scalar field, and let $\varphi(\textbf{x}) = \varphi^\dagger(\textbf{x})$ be a real scalar field.


$\phi(\textbf{x})$ destroys a particle and/or creates an antiparticle at $\textbf{x}$. Equivalently, $\phi(\textbf{x})$ destroys a single charge quantum at $\textbf{x}$, while $\phi^\dagger(\textbf{x})$ creates it. Reinterpreting this in terms of "particles" and "antiparticles" gives the same results as above because to create a charge I could equally well create a particle with that charge or destroy the corresponding antiparticle.


This is perfectly compatible with the fact that complex/non-hermitian fields represent charged particles, and from this reasoning we can expect that a chargeless particle must be represented by a real/hermitian field $\varphi$, as in this case there is no charge to create or destroy hence no way to distinguish $\varphi$ from $\varphi^\dagger$, which are thus the same thing (which is related to the lack of $U(1)$ gauge simmetry in the real case, and that of the related conserved charge). These reasonings raise a few questions:



  1. The fact that $\phi$ represents creation and destruction of a particle can be naturally interpreted saying that $\phi$ destroys a charge quantum. What does the operator $\varphi$ represents then? What quantity does $\varphi$ destroy that is equivalently achieved by destruction and creation of a chargeless "particle"?

  2. Consider the Fourier expansion of $\varphi$ (neglecting constants ecc.): $$ \varphi(\textbf{x}) = \sum_{\textbf{k}} \left( e^{i\textbf{k} \cdot \textbf{x}} a_\textbf{k} + e^{-i\textbf{k} \cdot \textbf{x}} a_\textbf{k}^\dagger \right)$$ For this to be hermitian we must have $a_{-\textbf{k}} = a_\textbf{k}^\dagger$, which I can interpret saying that "adding a momentum quantum $\textbf{k}$" is equivalent to "removing a momentum quantum $-\textbf{k}$". This makes me thing that the $a_\textbf{k}$ operators do not represent the "creationg of a particle with momentum $\textbf{k}$" but rather the addition of a momentum quantum $\textbf{k}$ to the field. However, I can think of a situation in which I have 2 chargeless particles each one with momentum $\textbf{k}$ (we are talking of bosons so this should be acceptable), and this reasoning leads me to the conclusion that this situation would be equivalent to a single particle with momentum $2\textbf{k}$, which is not what I would expect. I suspect that this is due to the fact that the particle interpretation here is misleading, and we should just talk of "field excitations" throught creation/destruction of quanta of physically measurable quantities. I cannot measure "a particle" but rather its momentum (or whatever), so I should just talk of momentum quanta and forget the "particles". Are this reasonings correct? (SPOILERS: NO)




Answer




  1. The field theory is fully analogous for Hermitian and non-Hermitian fields


The Hermitian operator $\varphi$ still creates and/or annihilates particles and the number of these particles $N$ is still well-defined (at least if we ignore interactions and problems with loops and divergences).


The only difference from the non-Hermitian field is that the particles and the antiparticles are the same things, so instead of two different "counts" of a particle species – one for an electron and one for a positron, for example – we only have one species (e.g. the Higgs boson) and one operator $N$.


If the operator $\varphi$ acts on an $N$ eigenstate with the eigenvalue $n$, it produces a superposition of two states, one of which is an $N$ eigenstate with the eigenvalue $n+1$ and the other one has the eigenvalue $n-1$.


In the charged, non-Hermitian case, there is usually a simple quantity that is conserved, the "charge" – it's the difference of the number of positrons minus the number of electrons, for example. In the case of the Hermitian field, there is no analogous operator (except for the discrete $(-1)^N$) that is conserved. But otherwise there is no difference between the two cases.




  1. It is not true that the modes with opposite momenta are linked


Your conclusion that $a_k=a^\dagger_{-k}$ is simply incorrect. If you rewrite the sum you wrote as the sum of two sums, then the second sum is self-evidently the Hermitian conjugate of the first sum (I didn't want to talk about the terms for a fixed value of $\vec k$, to avoid discussions about the difference between $\vec k$ and $-\vec k$), so the total expression for $\varphi(x)$ is Hermitian without any additional conditions just like $z+\bar z$ is real without any additional conditions on a complex $z$.


Obviously, it can't be true that a creation operator is equal to an annihilation operator. They are qualitatively different (each annihilation operator annihilates the vacuum, while no creation operator does so) so they cannot be equal.


newtonian mechanics - Pressure in deodorant can


Pressure in a deodorant can is greater than the surrounding pressure but still the can is in equilibrium with the surrounding . Why does this happen. If we apply $F = PA$ then $P_{in}A= P_{atm}A$ and since both the areas are equal then both pressures must also be equal.


Please explain enter image description here




wordplay - The 5000th Question


This is a good one, a rebus as I like it. Plus, this is the Question #5000.


  1. Mon
2. Tue
3. Wed
4. Thu
5. Fri
6. Sat
7. Sun


Happy Solving. :)



Answer



My guess is



Your days are numbered



Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...