Tuesday, 27 October 2015

quantum mechanics - Some questions about anyons?


(1) As we know, we have theories of second quantization for both bosons and fermions. That is, let $W_N$ be the $N$ identical particle Hilbert space of bosons or fermions, then the "many particle" Hilbert space $V$ would be $V=W_0\oplus W_1\oplus W_2\oplus W_3\oplus...$ , and further we can define creation and annihilation operators which satisfy commutation(anticommutation) relations for bonsons(fermions).


So my first question is, do we also have a "second quantization theory" for anyons like bosons and fermions?



(2) Generally speaking, anyons can only happen in 2D. Is this conclusion based on the assumption that the particles are point-like?


In Kitaev's toric code model, the quasiparticles are point-like due to the local operators in the Hamiltonian. My question is, in 3D case, whether there exists a simple model whose Hamiltonian contains local operators and spatially extended operators, so that it has both poit-like quasiparticles(say, $\mathbf{e}$) and knot-like quasiparticles(say, $\mathbf{m}$), then the $\mathbf{e}$ and $\mathbf{m}$ particles have nontrivial mutual statistics in 3D?



Answer



(1) For anyons to be created locally in a physical model they must be created in groups such that the local excitation is a boson or a fermion. However, the local excitation can fractionalize into anyonic parts which can propagate independently. In terms of second quantized operators the expectation is that the the local fermionic/bosonic degree of freedom can be written as a product of anyon creation/annihilation operators. This can be explicitly realized in exactly solvable models such as the Toric Code or the Kitaev Honeycomb model. So the answer to whether anyons have creation and annihilation operators is yes.


However, as pointed out by @delete000, we need knowledge of the exclusion statistics to characterize the Fock space of an anyon type. In exactly solvable models this is apparent if there is a direct algebraic fractionalization as just described. But, I don't think there is a complete understanding of exclusion statistics for an anyon given set of fractional quantum numbers so I cannot completely answer part (1) of your question, although there is a recent discussion for the special case of parafermions.


(2) As pointed out in the comments, there are Toric Code models whose quasiparticles are extended operators that realize non-trivial mutual statistics. One good example is the recent exactly soluble 3D models by Lin and Levin realizing realizing braiding between points and loops.


The particle-loop braiding picture is also important for the gapless phase of the 3D variants of the Kitaev Honeycomb model (although gaplessness makes it difficult to identify the anyon in the wavefunction, it exists at the operator level) where the confinement transition takes place at finite temperature on the 3D lattice because the loops need not only to exist, but be very large to lead to the cancellation between spinon paths through about around the loops [cite: 1309.1171 and 1507.01639]. This is unlike the 2D case where a point defect already does the job, making the 2D Kitaev spin liquid unstable to finite temperatures.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...