Action is defined as,
S = ∫L(q,q′,t)dt,
but my question is what variables does S depend on?
Is S=S(q,t) or S=S(q,q′,t) where q′:=dqdt?
In Wikipedia I've read that S=S(q(t)) and I think that suppose, q and t are considered as independent coordinates. Then S should depend on q′ also because, for the typical Lagrangian
L = q′22−V(q).
Answer
1) Firstly, the Lagrangian L(q(t),v(t),t) at some time t is a function of:
- the instantaneous position q(t) at the time t;
- the instantaneous velocity v(t) at the time t; and
- the time t (also known as explicit time-dependence).
2) Secondly, the (off-shell) action
S[q] := ∫tftidt L(q(t),v(t),t)|v(t)=˙q(t)
is a functional of the full position curve/path q:[ti,tf]→R for all times t in the interval [ti,tf].
3) Thirdly, if one imposes boundary conditions (B.C.), e.g. Dirichlet B.C.,
q(ti) = qiandq(tf) = qf,
then there is also a notion of a (Dirichlet) on-shell action 1
S(qf,tf;qi,ti) := S[qcl]
where qcl:[ti,tf]→R is the classical path, which satisfies Euler-Lagrange equations with the Dirichlet B.C. (2). The on-shell action S(qf,tf;qi,ti) is a function of
- the initial time ti;
- the initial position qi;
- the final time tf; and
- the final position qf.
--
1 See also e.g. MTW Section 21.1. For the on-shell action S(qf,tf;qi,ti) to be well-defined, there should exist a unique classical path with the B.C. (2). (Here the words on-shell and off-shell refer to whether the Euler-Lagrange equations are satisfied or not.)
No comments:
Post a Comment