Is Newton's third law valid at the General Relativity?
Newton's second law, the force exerted by body 2 on body 1 is: F12 The force exerted by body 1 on body 2 is: F21
According to Newton's third law, the force that body 2 exerts on body 1 is equal and opposite to the force that body 1 exerts on body 2: F12=−F21
Answer
First, let's note that newton's third law is really equivalent to conservation of momentum, by example of object one exerting a force on object two, and vice versa, and these two forces being the only forces in the universe:
F12=−F21m2a2=−m1a1∫m2a2dt=−∫m1a1dtm2v2f−m2v2i=m1v1i−m1v1fm1v1f+m2v2f=m1v1i+m2v2i∑pf=∑pi
Now, we know that we are looking for conservation of momentum, rather than just Newton's third law (and conservation of momentum is a more general concept anyway--Newton's third law will come up false in a variety of electromagnetic applications, but conservation of momentum will still be true). How do we get conservation of momentum? Well, the motion of a particle can be found by looking for the minium of something known as the Lagrangian:
L=KE−PE
It turns out that there is a result called Noether's theorem that says that if the Lagrangian is doesn't change when you modify your variables in a certain way, then the dynamics defined by that Lagrangian will necessarily have a conserved quantity associated with that transformation. It turns out that conservation of momentum arises when the invariance is a translation of the coordinates: xa′=xa+δa. Now, let's go back to general relativity. Here, the motion of a particle is the one that maximizes the length of:
∫ds2=∫gab˙xa˙xb
If the metric tensor gab has a translation invariance, this motion will necessarily have a conserved momentum associated with it, and will not otherwise. Note: common solutions, like the Schwarzschild solution of GR are NOT translation invariant--that's because the model assumes that the central black hole does not move. A more general solution that included the back-reaction of the test particle's motion WOULD have a conserved momentum (and would end with a moving black hole after some orbiting was completed).
No comments:
Post a Comment