Friday, 1 June 2018

newtonian mechanics - Defining gravitational potential


I recently came across the definition of gravitational potential where .....




Suppose a particle of mass $m$ is taken from a point $A$ to $B$. Let $U(A)$ and $U(B)$ denote the gravitational potential energy when the mass $m$ is at point $A$ and point $B$ respectively ..Also $V(B) - V(A)$ is the change in potential, then $$V(B) - V(A) =\frac{U(B) - U(A)}{m}$$



My teacher then said that if we take $A$ to be the reference point then $V(A)$ becomes equal to $0$ while I have no problem with this but why can't we also say that $U(A)$ is also equal to zero? After all we are taking $A$ as the origin? But my teacher says that we cant take $U(A)$ as equal to zero. Can anyone please explain why?


My book(Concepts of Physics by HC verma) also says the same thing.


enter image description here



Answer



Your teacher is wrong. The gravitational potential $V(x)$ is generally defined as potential energy per unit mass i.e. $V(x) \equiv \dfrac{U(x)}{m}$. So for the points where $U(x)$ is zero, $V(x)$ is zero and vice-versa by definition.


EDIT: After you added the comment and a snapshot of the book, I realized your book has defined Gravitational Potential in a different manner as $V(B)-V(A)=\dfrac{U(B)-U(A)}{m}$ than the standard $V(r)=U(r)/m$. This allows the room to choose different references for both $V(r)$ and $U(r)$. So to solve your confusion, the reference of $U(r)$ might be different than that of $V(r)$ so $U(A)$ need not be equal to $mV(A)$.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...