I've been looking at the Heisenberg uncertainty relations, and something that sticks out to me is the use of momentum rather than velocity. Shouldn't electrons have the same mass? And if they do, why is momentum used?
Answer
Because the uncertainty principle applies to all particles, regardless of their mass (and even for some massless particles). Thus, you could, if you insisted, phrase the uncertainty principle for electrons as $$ \Delta v\,\Delta x\geq \frac12\frac{\hbar}{m_e} $$ and the uncertainty principle for protons as $$ \Delta v\,\Delta x\geq \frac12\frac{\hbar}{m_p} $$ and the uncertainty principle for neutrons as $$ \Delta v\,\Delta x\geq \frac12\frac{\hbar}{m_m} $$ and the uncertainty principle for helium atoms as as $$ \Delta v\,\Delta x\geq \frac12\frac{\hbar}{m_\mathrm{He}} $$ and so on and on and on, but why would you do that when you can just issue a single principle that applies for all particles, $$ \Delta p\,\Delta x\geq \frac12\hbar, $$ and be done with it?
No comments:
Post a Comment