Wednesday 5 June 2019

newtonian mechanics - Height of Water 'Splashing'


Suppose from a height $H$, I throw a ball of mass $M$ and radius $R$ with initial velocity $u$ into a pool of depth $x$ having a liquid with density $\rho$ and coefficient of viscosity $\eta$.



Upto what height will the Water Splash?



enter image description here


This may be a silly question! (Source : my brain)



Assume every condition to be identical with no air resistance.


Feel free to assume any other parameters if needed.




P.S. $\rightarrow$ I've see similar questions but some of them want an exact answer and some are not so direct while some are incomplete questions...




Small Note : We do not have to consider the highest 'single' drop... Just assuming almost every water droplet jumped upto a height $h$. Ideal conditions...




Feel free to assume the liquid as WATER if required!



Answer



Basically the whole kinetic energy is transfered to pressure, and then this pressure will be transfered to kinetic energy again; this time only the direction is as defined by hydrostatic pressure; perpendicular to surface.



This above gives a following basis;


Kinetic energy of the ball is also it's potential energy (no friction on fall) Ekin = m g H This is then transferred to pressure through the ball surface; A = 4 pi r^2


This pressure then splashes the fluid up;


enter image description here


In optimal case the diameter of the ball is almost zero, and viscosity of the fluid is such, that the ball would stop in a distance of slightly more than r. This would lead to a situation where the vertical velocity of the water is very low, and thus the water would jump almost directly upwards. This doesn't actually matter too much, if the air friction is not considered.


Ok, so an answer, if the density of the ball is same as the density of the fluid. Then the fluid would jump to same height as the ball was dropped, if we also consider that there is no viscous losses. This is never true, and thus the ball drops deeper in the fluid and the losses reduces the available energy.


enter image description here


This all could be calculated. But the interesting thing is that there is a hole in the water when it goes deeper; And this means that the fluid which has maximum pressure has now a surface with no pressure. And therefore the fluid goes with even higher velocity back to fill this hole; as the velocity come from pressure difference, what happens;


enter image description here


It collides in the middle of the hole, but this time there is many velocities reaching the same point at the same time. Again all these velocities are transferred to pressure and the fluid takes new direction.



enter image description here


In 2-dimensional world this new velocity component would be 2-times the original. In 3-D reality it's more, and in true reality it's limited by viscous losses, surface tensions, etc. etc.


So to conclude this all; The splash hight can be anything.



  • The "Round splash" could theoretically reach the Height H, but it can never be more.

  • The Middle-splash can be even higher then the the Height H.


At this video found from comments, there is a golf-ball used to do the splash. And such a Golf ball makes a higher middle-splash than a round ball, because the boundary layer of the ball makes less losses, but also disturbs the fluid less. And therefore the returning middle splash is so big in this video; the collision happens with minimal disturbances; and the velocity vectors really hits against each others.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...