Friday, 2 January 2015

mathematical physics - Lie bracket for Lie algebra of $SO(n,m)$


How does one show that the bracket of elements in the Lie algebra of $SO(n,m)$ is given by


$$[J_{ab},J_{cd}] ~=~ i(\eta_{ad} J_{bc} + \eta_{bc} J_{ad} - \eta_{ac} J_{bd} - \eta_{bd}J_{ac}),$$


where $\eta$ has is the definite symmetric form with signature $(n,m)$?



Answer



By definition, the metric tensor $\eta_{ij}$ transforms trivially under the defining rep of $SO(n,m)$. $$ \eta_{ij}=[D(g^{-T})]_{i}^{\ k}[D(g^{-T})]_{j}^{\ l}\eta_{kl} =[D(g^{-1})]^{k}_{\ i}[D(g^{-1})]^{l}_{\ j}\eta_{kl} $$ and this holds for all $g\in SO(n,m)$. Consider a one-parameter subgroup of the defining rep with matrices $D(g)=e^{tJ}$ where $J^{i}_{\ j}$ is an element of the Lie algebra and $t$ is a real parameter. Substitute into the above equation, $$ \eta_{ij}=[e^{tJ}]^{k}_{\ i}[e^{tJ}]^{l}_{\ j}\eta_{kl} $$ and differentiate wrt $t$ at the identity $t=0$. $$ 0=J^{k}_{\ i}\delta^{l}_{\ j}\eta_{kl}+\delta^{k}_{\ i}J^{l}_{\ j}\eta_{kl} =J^{k}_{\ i}\eta_{kj}+J^{k}_{\ j}\eta_{ik} $$ This is the condition that the elements of the Lie algebra must obey. The Lie algebra elements can be generated by an antisymmetrized pair of vectors $x^{i}$, $y^{j}$. $$ J^{i}_{\ j}=x^{i}y_{j}-y^{i}x_{j} $$ where lowering is performed by the metric tensor $x_{i}=\eta_{ij}x^{j}$. The Lie algebra condition is automatically satisfied by generating the Lie algebra elements in this way. The Lie algebra elements $J_{ab}$ in the question are just made by choosing the vectors $x$ and $y$ as the basis vectors $x^{i}=\delta{^i}_{a}$, $y_{i}=\eta_{ij}\delta^{j}_{b}=\eta_{ib}$. $$ [J_{ab}]^{i}_{\ j}=\delta^{i}_{a}\eta_{jb}-\delta^{i}_{b}\eta_{ja} $$ Now compute the commutator (hopefully two different uses of square brackets is not too confusing), $$ [J_{ab},J_{cd}]^{i}_{\ j}=[J_{ab}]^{i}_{\ k}[J_{cd}]^{k}_{\ j}-[J_{cd}]^{i}_{\ k}[J_{ab}]^{k}_{\ j} $$ and a few lines of straightforward calculation gives, $$ [J_{ab},J_{cd}]^{i}_{\ j}=\eta_{bc}[J_{ad}]^{i}_{\ j}-\eta_{ac}[J_{bd}]^{i}_{\ j}-\eta_{bd}[J_{ac}]^{i}_{\ j}+\eta_{ad}[J_{bc}]^{i}_{\ j} $$ as the commutator for the defining rep. The Lie algebra is the same for all the group reps. The question asks for the commutator for a unitary rep of the group. To do this, the one-parameter unitary subgroup is $D(g)=e^{itJ}$ and so the Lie algebra elements of the defining rep are redefined as belonging to a unitary rep by the replacement $J\rightarrow iJ$. The commutator now becomes, $$ [iJ_{ab},iJ_{cd}]=\eta_{bc}iJ_{ad}-\eta_{ac}iJ_{bd}-\eta_{bd}iJ_{ac}+\eta_{ad}iJ_{bc}\\ -[J_{ab},J_{cd}]=i\eta_{bc}J_{ad}-i\eta_{ac}J_{bd}-i\eta_{bd}J_{ac}+i\eta_{ad}J_{bc} $$ which is the commutator in the question apart from an overall sign change. This is easily fixed by changing the definition of the Lie algebra elements of the defining rep to, $$ [J_{ab}]^{i}_{\ j}=\delta^{i}_{b}\eta_{ja}-\delta^{i}_{a}\eta_{jb} \ . $$



quantum mechanics - Tensor product of two different Pauli matrices $sigma_2otimeseta_1 $


I'm solving problem 3.D in H. Georgi Lie Algebra etc for fun where one is to compute the matrix elements of the direct product $\sigma_2\otimes\eta_1$ where $[\sigma_2]_{ij}\text{ and }[\eta_1]_{xy}$ are two different Pauli matrices in two different two dimensional spaces.


Defining the basis in our four dimensional tensor product space $$\tag{1}\left|1\right\rangle = \left|i=1\right\rangle\left|x=1\right\rangle\\ \left|2\right\rangle = \left|i=1\right\rangle\left|x=2\right\rangle\\ \left|3\right\rangle = \left|i=2\right\rangle\left|x=1\right\rangle\\ \left|4\right\rangle = \left|i=2\right\rangle\left|x=2\right\rangle$$



Now we know that when we multiply representations, the generators add in the sense of


$$\tag{2}[J_a^{1\otimes2}(g)]_{jyix} = [J_a^1]_{ji}\delta_{yx} +\delta_{ji}[J_a^2]_{yx}, $$ where the $J$s are the generators corresponding to the different representations $D_1$ and $D_2$ ($g$ stands for the group elements).


Using all of this I find that in the basis of $(1)$ the matrix representation of the tensor product is given by


$$\tag{3}\sigma_2\otimes\eta_1 = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & \mathbf{1} & -i & 0 \\ 1 & 0 & 0 & -i \\ i & 0 & 0 & 1 \\ 0 & i & 1 & 0 \end{pmatrix}$$


(The bold $\mathbf{1}$ is just notation, see below!) I am not asking you to redo the calculations for me but does $(3)$ make sense?


Appendix. My calculations were done in the following fashion [using equation $(2)$]: $$\tag{4}\langle 1| \sigma_2\otimes \eta_1 |1\rangle = \\ \langle j=1,y=1| \sigma_2\otimes \eta_1 |i=1,x=1\rangle \\ = [\sigma_2]_{11}\delta_{11}+\delta_{11}[\eta_1]_{11} \\ = 0.$$ Similarly for eg $$\tag{5} \langle 1| \sigma_2\otimes \eta_1 |2\rangle = \\ \langle j=1,y=1| \sigma_2\otimes \eta_1 |i=1,x=2\rangle \\ = [\sigma_2]_{11}\delta_{12}+\delta_{11}[\eta_1]_{12} \\ = 1. $$ This is how the bold $\mathbf{1}$ was obtained.


So are my calculations $(4), (5)$ totally wrong?


The Pauli matrices $$\begin{align} \sigma_1 &= \begin{pmatrix} 0&1\\ 1&0 \end{pmatrix} \\ \sigma_2 &= \begin{pmatrix} 0&-i\\ i&0 \end{pmatrix} \\ \sigma_3 &= \begin{pmatrix} 1&0\\ 0&-1 \end{pmatrix} \,. \end{align} $$




particle physics - What came first, neutrons or electrons?



I wonder if electrons were first (at an early stage of the cosmos) embedded into neutrons, making it easier to understand why they would fit so well with protons later, or if the genesis of electrons and protons are seen as two parallel but independent evolutions.


Spinoff: Why saying that during electron capture the electron is converted to a neutrino?


Spinoff: Are fundamental particles more than their properties?



Answer



Electrons came first. In the early universe, during the so-called electroweak epoch, the temperature was so high that large numbers of heavy particles (W, Z, and Higgs bosons, for instance) were created. Once the temperature cooled down enough, all of these bosons decayed into quarks and leptons (electrons, muons, and tau particles).


At this point, during the so-called quark epoch, the universe was still too hot for protons and neutrons to form- instead the universe was filled with a quark-gluon plasma, which consisted of quarks, gluons, and leptons. It wasn't until later that the universe cooled down enough to allow for protons and neutrons to form.



Neutrons do not contain electrons. Electrons aren't really "captured" by protons in the usual sense of the word. The electron is converted to a neutrino via the weak process, while the proton is converted to a neutron. The same interaction occurs between quarks and electrons, such as in the process $\rm eu\to\nu_ed$.


This doesn't mean that the neutron contains an electron. Indeed, the neutron is perfectly happy to capture a positron and turn back into a proton, and this doesn't mean the proton contains a positron.


quantum mechanics - What does it mean (how is it visualized) for a particle to act as a wave?


I have no background in physics. This isn't for homework, just for interest.


In quantum physics, it's described that a particle can act as both a particle and a wave.


Quoted from HowStuffWorks "Wave-Particle Duality"




Today, physicists accept the dual nature of light. In this modern view, they define light as a collection of one or more photons propagating through space as electromagnetic waves. This definition, which combines light's wave and particle nature, makes it possible to rethink Thomas Young's double-slit experiment in this way: Light travels away from a source as an electromagnetic wave. When it encounters the slits, it passes through and divides into two wave fronts. These wave fronts overlap and approach the screen. At the moment of impact, however, the entire wave field disappears and a photon appears. Quantum physicists often describe this by saying the spread-out wave "collapses" into a small point.



I have trouble visualizing a particle transforming into a wave and vice-versa. The quote says that light travels away from a source as an electromagnetic wave. What does that even look like? How can I visualize "a wave"? Is that supposed to look like some thin wall of advancing light? And then, the quote says, at the moment of impact, the wave disappears and a photon appears. So, a ball of light appears? Something that resembles a sphere? How does a sphere become something like an ocean wave? What does that look like?


My (completely uneducated) guess is, by a particle becoming a wave, does that mean that this expansive wave is filled with tons of ghost copies of itself, like the one electron exists everywhere in this expansive area of the wave, and then when it hits the wall, that property suddenly disappears and you're left with just one particle. So, this "wave", is really tons of identical copies of the same photon in the shape and form and with the same properties of, a wave? My guess comes from reading about how shooting just one photon still passes through two slits in the double-slit experiment. So the photon actually duplicated itself?




statistical mechanics - Isn't the second law of thermodynamics just the law of large numbers in disguise?


Loosely speaking,





  • The second law of thermodynamics (SLT) says that as a closed system evolves, its macrostate tends toward the one with the greatest possible number of indistinguishable microstates.




  • The law of large numbers (LLN) says that as the number of observations of a random event increases, the average of the observed values tends toward their expected value... which is precisely $1/n$ of the value that has the greatest possible number of ways in which it could be obtained through summing $n$ observations.1




The way I see it, if you realize that "evolution" (passage of time, a physical concept) is really just "having more opportunities for observations" (observing more samples, a mathematical concept), then these statements are saying the same thing.


Or, to put it another way, the SLT is implied by the LLN. Or to be completely blunt:
It is mathematically impossible for the 2nd law of thermodynamics not to hold.



Based on this, my questions are:




  1. Am I correct in my reasoning/intuition here?




  2. If yes: Why is the 2nd law of thermodynamics even considered a physical law at all? Provable statements aren't physical laws (nobody calls the Pythagorean theorem a physical law), so what sense does it make to regard this as one?


    If no: Why not?







Edit:


I just remembered there's also the data-processing inequality (DPI), which states that, if $X \to Y \to Z$ is a Markov chain (formally meaning that $X$ and $Z$ are conditionally independent given $Y$, and informally meaning that "$X$ only influences $Z$ via an intermediate $Y$"), then $H(Z \vert Y) \leq H(Z \vert X)$, meaning that the additional entropy (information content) of knowing $Z$ is lower if we already know $Y$ rather than if we only know $X$. I feel like this might help with the above interpretation but it's not entirely obvious to me exactly how.


1 For what it's worth, the asymptotic equipartition property (AEP) in information theory is the analog of the LLN in that field, and given that it directly deals with entropy just like the SLT, it might make more sense for those familiar with it to use that as a comparison point, but I'll focus on the LLN here since it's more accessible (including to myself!).




thermodynamics - water spheres on a hot pan


Today accidently I poured a little bit of water on a very hot pan , and something weird happened , where the quantity of water split into smaller spheres that moved around fast in the pan. I'm wondering about the physics concept behind that..



Answer



This is called the Leidenfrost effect. When water is sprinkled on the hot pan, the water surface immediately in contact with the hot pan vapourises. This vapour surface insulates the rest of the droplet from vapourising. Now a liquid droplet exists over vapour. The hot vapour has a lot of energy and moves around rapidly, the water droplet moves along with the vapour.


newtonian gravity - Why are people weightless whilst in orbit around the Earth? ISS? Satellites?



Had physics for 2 years now on highschool, but there is a thing I am wondering about.


You know the in the height above the earth surface around where the satellites are (Or the ISS), I've calculated that there actually is a big amount of gravity-forces, even up there. (9.1 - 9.2 m/s^2) - How come that things aren't dragged down to earth, and why are you even weightless?


Why doesn't satellites fall down more frequently, and does it have something to do with their orbit-speed?


Okay, many questions here, but just a curious guy.



Answer



These are two different effects. Satellites don't fall down because they are moving on a circular orbit. Actually, they are falling down all the time, since circular motion is accelerated (though the velocity doesn't change absolute value, it changes direction!), so it is kind of "falling around the earth".


The second question is, why doesn't an astronaut in a space station fall down to the floor? That's because, both the station and the astronaut feel the same force which holds both of them on a circular orbit. But for falling down to the floor the astronaut should feel a stronger force than the space station, otherwise there is no net force driving the astronaut and the stations floor into each other.



Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...