Saturday, 3 January 2015

quantum mechanics - Wannier Functions as Discrete Basis


In solid state physics, using Bloch's theorem we know that the one-electron energy eigen-function can be written as $\psi_{\lambda,\vec{k}}(\vec{r})$ where $\lambda$ indexes eigenvalues of $\hat{H}$ and $\vec{k}$ indexes eigenvalues of $\hat{T}_\vec{R}$, the translation by lattice-vector-$\vec{R}$ operator.


Because of Bloch's theorem, we know that $\psi_{\lambda,\vec{k}}(\vec{r})$ is periodic in $\vec{k}$ by reciprocal-lattice-vectors $\vec{K}$ and so we may write a Fourier series of it as: $$\psi_{\lambda,\vec{k}}(\vec{r})=\sum_{\vec{R}}\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})\exp\left({i\vec{R}\cdot\vec{k}}\right)$$



$\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})$ are called Wannier functions. One can prove that $\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})$ depends only on the difference $\vec{R}-\vec{r}$ as well as show that the Wannier functions are orthogonal between different values of $\lambda$ or $\vec{R}$.


As a result we may write an arbitrary wave-function $\psi(\vec{r})$ as $$ \psi(\vec{r}) = \sum_{\lambda,\,\vec{R}} \alpha_{\lambda,\,\vec{R}}\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})$$


where $\alpha_{\lambda,\,\vec{R}}=\int_{\mathbb{R}^3}\psi(\vec{r})\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})d^3\vec{r}$ are the expansion coefficients in the Wannier basis.


My question is:


1) Expressed in the Wannier basis $\left\{\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})\right\}_{\lambda,\,\vec{R}}$, why is it true that the potential energy of the electron is proportional to a delta-function?


$$ V_{\lambda,\lambda',\vec{R},\vec{R'}} \propto \delta_{\vec{R},\vec{R'}} $$


It is clear intuitively because $$ V_{\lambda,\lambda',\vec{R},\vec{R'}} \equiv \int_{\mathbb{R}^3}\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})^{\ast}V(\vec{r})\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda',\vec{R'}}(\vec{r})d^3\vec{r}$$


and coming from the tight-binding model (or alternatively using some dubious claim that the Wannier functions can always be chosen to be maximally-localized using the gauge-freedom in the definition of the wave functions) we know that $\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})$ is "sort of" around one particular lattice site $\vec{R}$ and so the integrand is non-zero only if the two lattice sites match.


But I would like a more rigorous (or hopefully much more direct) derivation of this. I am assuming that there is a simple easier reason I don't see.


2) My second question is how to express the kinetic energy, $\frac{-\hbar^2}{2m}\vec{\nabla}^2$, in the Wannier basis? I can't think of how to proceed from $$ T_{\lambda,\lambda',\vec{R},\vec{R'}} = \frac{-\hbar^2}{2m} \int_{\mathbb{R}^3}\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda,\vec{R}}(\vec{r})^{\ast}\vec{\nabla}^2\tilde{\psi}_{\lambda',\vec{R'}}(\vec{r})d^3\vec{r}$$




Answer



So it turns out that Adam was correct. Even when using the maximally localized Wannier functions, the answer to question 1) is that it is merely an approximation, and the answer to the second question is that there is nothing further to do with that expression as it stands. Thanks Adam.


What are the criteria for determining the difficulty of Sudoku puzzle?


What are the criteria for determining the difficulty of Sudoku puzzles?


Is it a subjective estimation based on the author's experience, or are there any precise guidelines?


For example, there are some sudokus, where in each step there's always at least one digit that, if you look on some line, must be exactly in that position. Some, however, require to determine that field A can hold 2 values, but assuming it contains X, there's a contradiction in next step, so it must be Y... in other words, require either memorizing or making notices in the corner of the fields.




Are strings in string theory actually little black holes?



I sometimes read that strings in string theory are actually little black holes, or can be interpreted that way. Is this true? How is that consistent with that the particle that a string represents depends on the oscillation of the string? I have read that here:


http://www.staff.science.uu.nl/~hooft101/gthpub/BH_interpretation_stringtheory.pdf


here: What is your simplest explanation of the string theory?



(Maimon's answer)


And this: Does gravity require strings? (Also Maimon's answer)


Maimon is refering to a paper in "Under the spell of the gauge principle" by 't Hooft.


The abstract of this paper is:



"ABSTRACT


We explain the principles of the laws of physics that we believe to be applicable for the quantum theory of black holes. In particular, black hole formation and evolution should be described in terms of a scattering matrix. This way black holes at the Planck scale become indistinguishable from other particles. This S-matrix can be derived from known laws of physics. Arguments are put forward in favor of a dlscrete algebra generating the Hilbert space of a black hole with its surrounding space-time including surrounding particles."





general relativity - Is there a geometric reason why two merging black holes never “decay” into two separate black holes


All black hole mergers seem to result in one Kerr black hole after ring-down.


Could it be possible, that two initial black holes with two separate event horizons form an “intermediate compound state” with one event horizon, which - at a later time - “decays” in two final black holes?


I know that the answer to this question is “no” when applying Bekenstein-Hawking entropy where the decay would violate the second law which postulates $dA/dt > 0$.


And the answer seems to be “no” when relying on numerical relativity for black hole mergers.


My question is if there is a more elegant, geometrical proof following entirely from general relativity, which rules out such a decay.


Thanks



Answer



This geometric reason for that statement is that there is only one null geodesic lying on the horizon going through each point of the horizon. If the black hole have split into two, then there would be a point on the horizon from which two different null geodesics lying within the horizon would start, which is impossible. So black holes could form (starting with one point from which all of the horizon springs into existance) and merge, but not bifurcate.


This is not a consequence of the Hawking area theorem but was also formulated by Hawking:




  • Hawking, S. W. (1972). Black holes in general relativity. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 25(2), 152-166, doi, OA text at ProjectEuclid. (section 2, p. 156).


See also the Book:



  • Hawking, S. W., & Ellis, G. F. R. (1973). The large scale structure of space-time. Cambridge University Press, Chapter 9.



As $\tau$ increases, black holes can merge together, and new black holes can form as the result of further bodies collapsing. However, the following result shows that black holes can never bifurcate.




The following result is a proposition 9.2.5 which simply formally states that.


Incidentally, it seems that this property has no generalization in higher dimensions where for example black strings (extended black holes with horizon topology of, say, $R_2\times S_2$ for 5D gravity) would fragment into many snaller black holes as a result of Gregory–Laflamme instability.



  • Lehner, L., & Pretorius, F. (2011). Final state of Gregory-Laflamme instability. arXiv:1106.5184.


Universal reference frame based on the speed of light/special relativity


Everything I've read has said that there is no universal static reference frame, but based on my understanding of special relativity I don't understand why it can't be determined.


Here is an experiment I can think of that would seem to determine "universal static", what am I missing? Assuming 1 dimensional space for a second, our reference frame (a spaceship) is moving and an indeterminate speed $V_0$. We take two probes with atomic clocks and send one in each direction at some fraction of the speed of light ($V_0+V_p$ and $V_0-V_p$). After a period of time, the probes return at a slower speed than they left (taking advantage of the fact that time dilation effects increase exponentially with velocity). Upon returning, the clock in the probe sent in the positive direction ($V_0+V_p$) should show less time past than the clock on our spaceship, and the probe sent in the opposite direction ($V_0-V_p$) should show that more time has past than the clock on our spaceship, this tells us which direction we are moving with respect to "universal static", and with repeated experiments we can determine our exact velocity relative to it.




Friday, 2 January 2015

electromagnetism - Legal values of spin-1 field can take: $mathbb{R}$, $mathbb{C}$, $mathbb{H}$, ..?



For the spin-1/ boson field $A_\mu$, we may choose it to be a vector which needs to be




  • real $\mathbb{R}$ usually for photon field. The field strength $F= dA$ is also real. Same for the nonabelian case $F= dA+A^2$ is also real.




  • but can $A$ be complex $\mathbb{C}$?




  • but can $A$ be quaternion $\mathbb{H}$?





What are the legal values of spin-1 field can take? real $\mathbb{R}$, complex $\mathbb{C}$, quaternion $\mathbb{H}$ , ..? And what may be the QFT like in these cases?




quantum mechanics - The relationship between angular and linear momentum


Why is orbital angular momentum not 0 when spin and linear momentum are not collinear?


Why can it be 0 when spin and linear momentum are parallel?


Like in the example of a scalar field at rest decaying into an electron and a positron via interaction $\frac{1}{2}g\phi \bar{\Psi}\Psi $



If spin is along x axis and three-momenta is along z axis, decay rate will be 0 if two spins are opposite because orbital momentum is not 0 after decaying.




Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...