Sunday, 3 December 2017

thermodynamics - Is there a way to split a black hole?



Classically, black holes can merge, becoming a single black hole with an horizon area greater than the sum of both merged components.


Is it thermodynamically / statistically possible to split a black hole in multiple black holes? If the sum of the areas of the product black holes would exceed the area of the original black hole, it seems to be a statistically favorable transition by the fact alone that would be a state with larger entropy than the initial state



Answer



I) Let us choose units where $c=1=G$ for simplicity. Recall that a Kerr-Newman black-hole with mass $M > 0$, charge $Q\in [-M,M]$, and angular momentum $J\geq 0$, has surface area given by


$$\frac{A}{4\pi}~:=~ r^2_+ +a^2~=~ M^2+ \delta + 2M \sqrt{\Delta}, \tag{1}$$


where


$$ r_+~:=~M+\sqrt{\Delta}, \qquad \Delta~:=~ \delta -a^2~\geq~0,\qquad \delta~:=~M^2-Q^2~\geq~0, \qquad a~:=~\frac{J}{M}.\tag{2}$$


The entropy


$$S~=~\frac{k_B}{\ell_P^2}\frac{A}{4}\tag{3}$$


is proportional to the area $A$.



II) An interesting question asks the following.



If we merge $n$ Kerr-Newman black-holes
$$(M_i>0, Q_i, J_i),\qquad i\in\{1,\ldots,n\},\tag{4}$$ into one Kerr-Newman black-hole $(M>0,Q,J)$, such that mass and charge are conserved$^1$ $$ M~=~\sum_i M_i , \qquad Q~=~\sum_i Q_i , \qquad J~\leq ~\sum_i J_i, \tag{5}$$ and the angular momentum satisfies the triangle inequality; would the discriminant $$ \Delta~\geq~0 \tag{6}$$ for the merged black hole be non-negative, and would the Kerr-Newman area formula (1) respect the second law of thermodynamics $$ A~>~ \sum_i A_i~? \tag{7}$$



The answer is in both cases Yes! The ineq. (7) in turn shows that the opposite splitting process is impossible, cf. OP's question.


Proof of ineqs. (6) & (7): First note that


$$ \delta~\stackrel{(2)}{=}~(M+Q)(M-Q)~ \stackrel{(5)}{=}~\sum_i(M_i+Q_i)(M_i-Q_i) +\sum_{i\neq j}(M_i+Q_i)(M_j-Q_j)$$ $$~\stackrel{(2)}{\geq}~\sum_i(M_i+Q_i)(M_i-Q_i) ~\stackrel{(2)}{=}~ \sum_i \delta_i , \tag{8}$$


and hence


$$ \frac{\delta}{2}~\stackrel{(8)}{\geq}~\frac{\delta_i +\delta_j}{2}~\geq~ \sqrt{\delta_i \delta_j}, \tag{9}$$



due to the ineq. of arithmetic & geometric means. Next consider


$$ M^2\Delta - \left(\sum_i M_i\sqrt{\Delta_i}\right)^2 ~\stackrel{(2)}{=}~(M^2\delta -J^2) - \sum_i M_i^2\Delta_i - \sum_{i\neq j}M_i\sqrt{\Delta_i}M_j\sqrt{\Delta_j} $$ $$~\stackrel{(2)+(5)}{\geq}~\left(\delta \sum_i M_i^2 + \delta\sum_{i\neq j} M_iM_j -J^2\right) - \sum_i (M_i^2\delta_i -J^2_i) - \sum_{i\neq j}M_i\sqrt{\delta_i}M_j\sqrt{\delta_j} $$ $$~\stackrel{(8)+(9)}{\geq}~ \sum_{i\neq j}M_i\sqrt{\delta_i}M_j\sqrt{\delta_j} +\sum_i J^2_i -J^2 ~\stackrel{(2)}{\geq}~ \sum_{i\neq j}J_iJ_j +\sum_i J^2_i -J^2 $$ $$~=~\left(\sum_i J_i\right)^2 -J^2 ~\stackrel{(5)}{\geq}~0. \tag{10}$$


Ineq. (10) implies ineq. (6) and


$$ M\sqrt{\Delta} ~\stackrel{(10)}{\geq}~ \sum_i M_i\sqrt{\Delta_i}. \tag{11}$$


Together with


$$ M^2 ~>~ \sum_i M^2_i,\tag{12} $$


eqs. (8) & (11) yield ineq. (7). $\Box$


--


$^1$ We assume that the system can be treated as isolated. In particular, we ignore outgoing gravitational radiation. As we know from recent gravitational wave detections, this assumption is violated in practice for black hole merges. However, for the opposite hypothetical splitting process, which OP asks about, this is a reasonable assumption.


Relationship between Energy and Time



Is there a relationship between energy and time? What is it?




special relativity - What's the name for the relativistic paradox with the train/car travelling over a gap?


There is a relativistic paradox I was introduced by a friend in Ithaca (Courtenay Footman). It involves a vehicle travelling over a ravine relativistically, so it's in the general family of ladder paradoxes. There are many ways to phrase it, but here's a simple one.


A three-car train with each car of length $L$ is travelling over a bridge across a ravine. (Assume that the couplings between cars are stiff: this train does not bend.) Unfortunately, some evil genius has precisely removed a length $6L$ of the track. The train however is relativistic, travelling at a speed such that $\gamma \approx 12$.


In the reference frame of the ground, the train should appear to be 1/24th the size of the gap, which suggests that it will fall a little and should crash into the bridge opposite. But in the reference frame of the train, each car of the train is at least twice as long as the gap and aside from the very front wheel and the very back wheel, which need to be supported by rigidity, everything is constantly well-supported. This suggests that the train makes it. Who is right?


I vaguely remember that as an undergraduate knowing only a little relativity, I trusted the train's perspective because it's at rest in that perspective, and Courtenay said that this was ultimately correct after a lot of details got resolved. But I do not remember all of these details such that I could work it out for myself. So I'm looking for some discussion that's a little more well-sourced or authoritative.


What is this paradox called, and what literature has addressed the issue?



Answer



This is Wolfgang Rindler's "grid paradox", discussed on Wikipedia here and both proposed and resolved on this PDF by Rindler. Its resolution is the exact opposite of what you're saying; if you remember being "right" then you must have instead trusted the ground's perspective, not the train's.


The problem is essentially that our notion of "rigid" does not continue into the relativistic framework, since it requires instantaneous information transmission. Suppose we simply have two atoms which are attached together by some potential $U(|\vec r_2 - \vec r_1|)$ with a strong minimum at a distance $a,$ maybe we can say $U(L) = \frac12 k (L - a)^2.$



In Newtonian mechanics this would create rigidity for large $k$, but in special relativity, we have a time $\tau = a/c$ during which we can manipulate the one atom without any effect on the other atom. Let us just assume that both particles have mass $m$ and are at rest in the center-of-mass frame; then we give the "right" one an instantaneous impulse $\Delta p$. Then the particles attain a spacing of $\ell = \tau\Delta p/m$ before any signal reaches the "left" one informing it about our impulse. When this happens, a powerful restoring force should draw the "left" particle forward and the "right" particle backward, and to conserve momentum we're probably going to need a field in the middle to carry the momentum as it gets transferred back and forth. The mathematics here are complicated and I don't know that I've ever actually seen the full example worked out. However, the point would be that there is a certain "flexibility" mandated by relativistic information limits, and possibly an increase in the gradient of the gravitational field due to length contraction, which might both drive the leading edge of the train to bend sharply down into the gap, causing the inevitable carnage.


Saturday, 2 December 2017

homework and exercises - Magnetic monopole and vector potential


Does anyone know how to prove (in a simple way if possible) that it is impossible to define a single-valued globally defined magnetic vector potential $\vec{A}$ on the manifold $M=\mathbb{R}^3\backslash\{0\}$ for a static magnetic monopole placed at the origin?


Hypothesis: $\vec{B} = g \vec{r}/(4\pi r^3)$




general relativity - Two "devil's advocate" questions related to LIGO measurement results interpretation



"If you would be a real seeker after truth, it is necessary that at least once in your life you doubt, as far as possible, all things."


Rene Descartes


Laymen like me typically refers to Wikipedia for basic definitions ...



"In physics, spacetime is any mathematical model that combines space and time into a single interwoven continuum."



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacetime



"Gravitational waves are radiant energy produced in certain gravitational interactions. They are ripples in the curvature of spacetime that propagate as waves, travelling outward from the source."




http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_wave#Effects_of_passing


and from the same source



"As a gravitational wave passes an observer, that observer will find spacetime distorted by the effects of strain. Distances between objects increase and decrease rhythmically as the wave passes, at a frequency corresponding to that of the wave."



Why it is assumed above that it is particular distance component (in its three dimensional space sense) of the spacetime continuum and not the time component of the spacetime continuum - which is changing under the effect of gravitational wave passage?


Let me push my question's logic further in very non-orthodox and ignorant manner and also ask, playing the role of "devil's advocate" (while risking to be accused in lack of confidence in basic concepts of General Relativity):


why one can not interprete the measurement results during LIGO detection, as a manifest of speed of light variations (versus considering the speed of light being absolutely invariant under any possible circumstances, such as the case of gravitational wave passage)?



Answer



A gravitational wave has a polarization. So when one direction transverse to the wave is expanded, the other direction transverse to the wave is contracted. Thus if you try to explain the expansion and contraction as a naïve consequence of time expansion or of time contraction then you'd have a hard time making that effect cause both an expansion and a contraction in two different directions at the same time and place.



Now I'm sure some people would prefer to have a coordinate speed of light that is different in different directions. But coordinate speeds aren't physical so that's just a model effect not a physical effect. You can do General Relativity and make your predictions without even picking any coordinates, ever. So they aren't part of physical reality, just part of how some people manipulate some mathematical models.


In reality the metric determines the lengths along 4d paths and that tells us how (where and when) clocks tick and how (where and when) tape measures have their marks. Which is what we actually see.


optics - Fate of light ray


enter image description here


This question has been on my mind since I first learned optics. Where will the light ray go?


First, I thought of it taking a U turn. But, I don't think that will happen. Now I have studied a bit about wave optics and I think that the light will go... everywhere? Can someone please explain it in realm of ray optics? I wouldn't mind a bit about wave optics. Just don't go deep down there.


Thanks.




thermodynamics - Effusion of Ideal Gas



I just calculated that for an ideal gas inside a container, the average kinetic energy for molecules that are striking the walls of the container is larger than the average kinetic energy of the molecules comprising the entire gas. Specifically, my result was $$\frac{E_{walls}}{E} = \frac{4}{3}$$ where $E=\frac{3}{2}T$. I am pretty sure that this is correct. My question is then if I have a container of gas in vacuum and I poke a hole in it, let some gas escape, and then close the hole before all of it escapes, am I right in thinking that due to my result above, the molecules that escape are more likely to have higher energy than the average energy of the whole gas, and as a result the energy and temperature of my system will have decreased?




Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...