Friday, 19 July 2019

general relativity - Photon pair production at relativistic speeds?


This is probably an obvious question, but I don't see it answered anywhere.


Imagine we have an object in the Universe that is traveling, relative to the Milkyway at about .99999999999999999999999999c and I realize that's not possible, but imagine.


Speed is relative, so to the object, the Milkyway is flying past it and to us, the object is flying past us. That's all good and relative.



But the photons that our superfast object encounters are gonzo blue-shifted, and relativity says that's OK too. But lets say the object is traveling so fast, the photons it encounters are energetic enough to spontaneously undergo pair production. That seems difficult to explain. A relatively low energy visible light photon to our perception won't split into an Electron and a Positron, but a very energetic photon can, but it's the same photon just observed by 2 different reference frames?


I understand that observers won't agree on when things happen or on energy but the two observers should agree on events that take place and pair production for one but not the other seems impossible.


Is there a simple layman's way that this can be explained?



Answer



Yes, there is a simple explanation! The pair production process $\gamma \to e^+ + e^-$ is forbidden by energy-momentum conservation, so it doesn't happen in either frame.


One way to see this is that, as a massless object, the photon has "the most possible momentum for its energy", as it doesn't have the extra rest mass-energy. So if you try to make the momentum in this equation balance, the electron and positron will have too much energy, and vice versa.


However, a slightly modified version of your idea holds. Our universe is full of low-energy photons from the Cosmic Microwave Background. As you suggested, a very fast moving charged particle will see these photons as heavily blueshifted, and pair production is possible if the photons scatter off the object. (This is a $2 \to 2$ reaction, so the argument in the previous paragraph doesn't hold.)


The scattering steals some of the particle's energy, slightly slowing it down. This places a limit on the energy of cosmic rays, called the GZK bound.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...