What is the exact use of the symbols ∂, δ and d in derivatives in physics? How are they different and when are they used? It would be nice to get that settled once and for all.
∂y∂x,δyδx,dydx
- For what I know, d is used as a small infinitisemal change (and I guess the straight-up letter d is usual notation instead of italic d, simply to tell the difference from a variable).
- Of course we also have the big delta Δ to describe a finite (non-negligible) difference.
- And I have some vague idea that ∂ is used for partial derivatives in case of e.g. three-dimensional variables.
- Same goes for δ, which I would have sworn was the same as ∂ until reading this answer on Math.SE: https://math.stackexchange.com/q/317338/
Then to make the confusion total I noticed an equation like δQ=dU+δW and read in a physics text book that:
The fact that the amount of heat [added between two states] is dependent on the path is indicated by the symbol δ...
So it seems δ means something more? The text book continues and says that:
a function [like the change in internal energy] is called a state function and its change is indicated by the symbol d...
Here I am unsure of exactly why a d refers to a state function.
So to sum it up: down to the bone of it, what is δ, ∂ and d exactly, when we are talking derivatives in physics.
Addition
Especially when reading a mathematical process on a physical equation like this procedure:
δQ=dU+pdV⇒Q=ΔU+∫21pdV
It appears that δ and d are the same thing. An integral operation handles it the same way apparently?
Answer
Typically:
- d denotes the total derivative (sometimes called the exact differential):ddtf(x,t)=∂f∂t+∂f∂xdxdtThis is also sometimes denoted via DfDt,Dtf
- ∂ represents the partial derivative (derivative of f(x,y) with respect to x at constant y). This is sometimes denoted by f,x,fx,∂xf
- δ is for small changes of a variable, for example minimizing the action δS=0 For larger differences, one uses Δ, e.g.: Δy=y2−y1
NB: These definitions are not necessarily uniform across all subfields of physics, so take care to note the authors intent. Some counter-examples (out of many more):
- D can denote the directional derivative of a multivariate function f in the direction of v: Dvf(x)=∇vf(x)=v⋅∂f(x)∂x
- More generally DtT can be used to denote the covariant derivative of a tensor field T along a curve γ(t): DtT=∇˙γ(t)T
- δ can also represent the functional derivative: δF(ρ,ϕ)=∫δFδρ(x)δρ(x)dx
- The symbol d may denote the exterior derivative, which acts on differential forms; on a p-form, dωp=1p!∂[aωa1…ap]dxa∧dxa1∧⋯∧dxap which maps it to a (p+1)-form, though combinatorial factors may vary based on convention.
- The δ symbol can also denote the inexact differential, which is found in your thermodynamics relationdU=δQ−δW This relation shows that the change of energy ΔU is path-independent (only dependent on end points of integration) while the changes in heat and work ΔQ=∫δQ and ΔW=∫δW are path-dependent because they are not state functions.
No comments:
Post a Comment