Sunday 1 July 2018

Total mechanical energy concept


I was solving a true or false question regarding total mechanical energy and the following was the problem.



It is possible for a moving object to have negative total mechanical energy.




This is my claim.


Total mechanical energy is defined as


$$M=K+U$$


where $K=\frac{1}{2}mv^2$ and $U=mgh$.


No matter which direction the object is moving $K$ must be positive due to the $v^2$. (I am assuming that mass is also never negative.)


Potential energy is also positive because $g=9.8$ and height is a distance, which is also non-negative.


And yet, the problems says that the answer is true, as in the total mechanical energy is allowed to be negative.


What am I not seeing here ?



Answer



As Kyle implies in the comments, mechanical energy is generally defined only up to a constant. Therefore, if you choose your constant as a large, negative number, you could have a total energy that is negative even with a very fast moving particle. Likewise, if you choose your potential energy to equal zero at, say, the top of a cliff, then anything you throw off the cliff will have negative potential energy once it falls below your feet.



This is not strictly a duplicate, but it is probably worthwhile to link to this answer I posted a while back.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...