thermodynamics - How slow is a reversible adiabatic expansion of an ideal gas?

A truly reversible thermodynamic process needs to be infinitesimally displaced from equilibrium at all times and therefore takes infinite time to complete. However, if I execute the process slowly, I should be able to get close to reversibility. My question is, "What determines when something is slow?"

For definiteness, let's take an insulating cylindrical piston with cross-sectional area $A$ and original length $L_0$. There is an ideal gas inside with $n$ molecules of gas with mass-per-molecule $m$. The temperature is $T_0$, and the adiabatic index is $\gamma$.

I plan to expand the piston adiabatically to length $L_1$, taking a time $t$ to do so. If I take $t$ to be long enough, the process will be nearly-reversible. However, $t$ being long does not mean "one minute" or "one year". It means $t >> \tau$ for some

$$\tau = f(A, L_0, L, n, m, T, k_B, \gamma)$$

What is $\tau$?

From purely dimensional considerations, I guess the relationship is something like

$$\tau = \sqrt{\frac{mLL_0}{k_bT}}f(n, L/L_0, A/L^2, \gamma)$$,

but I don't have a strong physical explanation.

Edit A meaningful answer should let me do the following: I take a certain example piston and try expanding it a few times, putting it in a box so I can measure the heat released to the environment. I calculate the entropy change in the universe for the expansions. After doing several expansions, each slower than the last, I finally get $\Delta S$ for the universe down to a number that I think is sufficiently small. Next, I plan to repeat the experiment, but with a new piston that has different dimensions, different initial temperature, etc. Based on my results for the previous piston, how can I figure out how long I should take to expand the new one to achieve a similar degree of reversibility on the first try?

For reference, the pressure is

$$P = \frac{nk_BT}{V}$$

and the speed of sound is

$$v = \sqrt{\frac{\gamma k_b T}{m}}$$,

and I'm happy to have an answer in terms of these or other derived quantities. Formulas for entropy and thermodynamic potentials can be found in the Wikipedia article.

Answer

I am a student so please point out in gory detail anything I did wrong.

For a process to be quasistatic, the time scales of evolving the system should be larger than the relaxation time. Relaxation time is the time needed for the system to return to equilibrium.

We have an adiabatic process, so equilibrium must be preserved at each point, that is to say

(Working within the validity of the kinetic theory for ideal gases and ignoring friction)

$(A L(t))^\gamma P(t) = (A L_0)^\gamma P(t_0)$

Momentum gained by the piston:

$\Delta p = 2 m v_x$

A molecule would impact the piston every

$\delta t = \frac{2(L_0+ \delta x) }{v_x}$

The force exerted on the piston is $F =\frac{\Delta p}{\delta t} = \frac{m v_x^2}{L_0+\delta x}$ Pressure would be $P = \frac{P}{A}$ and for $N$ such molecules

$P = \frac{N m ^2}{A (L_0+\delta x)} = \frac{N m ^2}{3A (L_0+\delta x)}$

So at the instant $t=t'$ where the piston has been displaced by $\delta x$, we have

$(A L(t))^\gamma P(t) = \frac{N m ^2}{3A^{1-\gamma}} (L_0+\delta x)^{\gamma -1}$

Expanding in series

$ = \frac{N m ^2 L_0^{\gamma-1}}{3A^{1-\gamma}} (1 + \frac{(\gamma-1) \delta x}{L_0}+ O(\delta x^2) ) $

Substituing $\frac{\delta x}{L_0} = \frac{\delta t v_x}{2 L_0} -1$

$(A L_0)^\gamma P(t_0) = (A L_0)^\gamma P(t_0) (1 + (\gamma-1) (\frac{\delta t v_x}{2 L_0} -1))$

If we want our process to be reversibly adiabitic atleast to first order, we must have from above

$\delta t = \frac{2 L_0}{}$

Now, this is time until collision for the starting case. Investigating second orders

$ (A L_0)^\gamma P(t_0) = (A L_0)^\gamma P(t_0) (1 + \frac{(\gamma-1) \delta x}{L_0}+ \frac{1}{2} (\gamma-1)(\gamma-2) (\frac{\delta x}{L_0})^2 +O(\delta x^3) ) $

Looking at just the series terms

$ 1 + (\gamma-1)\frac{\delta x}{L_0} (1 +\frac{1}{2} (\gamma -2) \frac{\delta x}{L_0}) \approx 1$

This would be true for

$\delta t = \frac{4 L_0}{} (\frac{1}{2-\gamma} -1)$

Now, this is the "time until next collision" for a gas molecule hitting the piston. To maintain reversibility, at least to second order, the piston should be moved from $L_0$ to $L_0 + \delta x$ in time $\tau = \delta t$ so that the system variables follow the adiabatic curve.

The $$ can be calculated from the maxwell distribution