Monday, 9 December 2019

newtonian mechanics - Simple Pendulum Why Generalized Coordinate Always Angle?


Sample Figure


When writing the equations of motion for the simple pendulum, why do textbooks always choose $\theta$ to be the generalized coordinate? The force of gravity is in the y-direction so wouldn't it be natural to write everything in terms of y instead of $\theta$? Since the string is of fixed length $l$, we can write $x=\sqrt{l^2-y^2}$ and so shouldn't we be able to write the Equations of Motion completely in terms of $y$?



Answer



Peter Green's answer already showed you the error ($x=\sqrt{l^2-y^2}$ isn't generally true), but you can also directly see that $y$ isn't a sufficient coordinate:


No matter how fast the pendulum moves, at the bottom we always have $y=-l$ and $\dot{y}=0$. Therefore, you can't describe the state of the system just by $y$ and $\dot{y}$.





Edit: It's also worth pointing out that the other answers are indeed correct that $\theta$ is used instead of cartesian coordinates also because it actually is the choice that gives the simplest (and, subjectively, most natural) equations.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...