Wednesday 11 December 2019

Physics terminology about smeared and unsmeared fields


Let $M$ be a smooth manifold and denote $C^\infty_0(M)$ the space of smooth functions with compact support. In Mathematics a distribution is defined to be a continuous linear functional $\phi : C^\infty_0(M)\to \mathbb{R}$. The space of distributions is usually denoted $\mathfrak{D}'(M)$.


So a distribution is a map that takes a function and outputs a number in a linear and continuous way. The Delta distribution centered at $x\in M$ is for example


$$\delta_x[f]=f(x).$$



Another way to create distributions is to pick $f\in C^\infty_0(M)$ and define


$${f}^\diamond[g]=\int_M fg.$$


That much is fine. The problem is the following: in Physics one often forgets all this and treats distributions as functions. So a Physicst will almost never bother writing $\phi[f]$ or just $\phi$. They write $\phi(x)$ which is not really correct, since $\phi$ isn't a function on $M$ at all.


The issue though is that there is a terminology around which makes me quite confused. One often talks about "smeared" fields written as


$$\varphi[f]=\int_M\varphi(x)f(x)$$


and talks about the field in "unsmeared form" writting it just $\varphi(x)$. This confuses further, because it is known that it is not true that given $\varphi$ there is $f$ such that $\varphi = f^\diamond$.


This terminology may be found for example in Fewster's notes on QFT on curved spacetime, but I've seem it elsewhere.


This seems to imply that when one picks $\phi\in C^\infty_0(M)$ it is unsmeared and when one picks $\phi^\diamond\in \mathfrak{D}'(M)$ and apply it to a function it is smeared (but notice that $\phi^\diamond[f]$ is a real number, not even a field anymore after applying to $f$).


So what really is this smeared and unsmeared terminology about and how does this makes contact with distribution theory from mathematics?




No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...