I encountered an assertion that a massless particle moves with fundamental speed c, and this is the consequence of special relativity. Some authors (such as L. Okun) like to prove this assertion with the following reasoning:
Let's have p=mγv,E=mc2γ⇒p=Ec2v(.1)
and E2=p2c2+m2c4.(.2)For the massless case (.2) gives p=Ec. By using (.1) one can see that |v|=c.
But to me, this is non-physical reasoning. Relation (.1) is derived from the expressions of impulse and energy for a massive particle, so its scope is limited to massive cases.
We can show that a massless particle moves with the speed of light by introducing the Hamiltonian formalism: for a free particle
H=E=√p2c2+m2c4,
Answer
For the reasons given in the comment above, I think the argument from the m→0 limit is valid. But if one doesn't like that, then here is an alternative. Suppose that a massless particle had $v
No comments:
Post a Comment