Thursday 11 June 2020

metric tensor - Why does the $L_2$ norm give the shortest path between 2 points?


Why not the $L_1$ or $L_3$ distances? Is there some deep reason why the universe (at least at human scales) looks pretty much Euclidean?


Could we imagine a different universe where a different $L_p$ metric would seem "natural"?


I know it's kind of a deep question, but the specialness of 2 here has always made me wonder.



Answer



If we want a sense of localness (or calculus to work), we'd like to be able to obtain the length by adding up the length from pieces of the path (for example using a ruler, or counting paces as we walk along the path between two points).


However, even considering just two dimensions we see something interesting for $L_p$.


$$\left(|x|^p + |y|^p\right)^{1/p} = \sum_{i=1}^N \left(\left|\frac{x}{N}\right|^p + \left|\frac{y}{N}\right|^p\right)^{1/p}$$



This trivially works with $p=1$, and due to a special symmetry at $p=2$ it works there as well. This will not work for other $p\neq 0$ (I am unsure of how to extend the definition to check $p=0$).


The special symmetry at $p=2$ is that the distance measurement becomes rotationally invariant. So the seemingly mundane reasons of



  • space has more than one dimension

  • locality

  • uniformity


seem to already select $L_2$ as special. Any other choice would give a preferred coordinate system, and possibly break locality.


So what would a different universe in which $L_1$ or something else is the natural choice? If you imagined an N dimensional Cartesian lattice world, so one with discrete lengths, and a clearly preferred coordinate basis, this would make $L_1$ a more natural choice.


I'm not sure of a good picture for a universe in which $L_p, p>2$ would be a natural choice. There would be preferred directions, and you could only consider an object as a whole (not in parts), which seems to suggest in such a hypothetical universe you couldn't even experience your life as a sequence of moments (which I guess would make sense if we have highly non-local physics and therefore causality is out the window).



Interesting question.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...