Sunday 16 November 2014

homework and exercises - Loop-the-Loop with Friction



Let's consider a track that begins vertically becomes a 450 degree loop, and level off. (See diagram) enter image description here


We drop a block from height $H$ that falls and goes around the loop. Ignoring air resistance, but taking into account a friction coefficient of $\mu$ against the track, find the smallest $H$ for which the block will complete the loop.


By conservation of energy I have obtained the following equation:


$$ mgH = \frac{m v(\theta)^2}{2}+mgR(1+\mu-\sin(\theta)) + m\mu R \int_0^\theta\left( g \sin(\theta) + \frac{v(\theta)^2}{R}\right) d\theta $$


Where $v(\theta)$ the the block's speed at $\theta$, and $\theta$ is an angle measured between the block's position (centred at loop center) and a horizontal line going left-wards.


The left hand side is gravitational potential energy, the first term on the right is kinetic energy, the next one is also gravitational potential energy, and the last one - the work done by friction.


Dividing by $m$, differentiating with respect to $\theta$, and using the chain rule on the first term on the right hand side we obtain:



$$ 0=v(\theta)\frac{dv(\theta)}{d\theta} +gR(\mu\sin(\theta) -cos(\theta)) + \mu v(\theta)^2$$


Assuming the block doesn't make it, because it lost's its speed to friction, let's find $\theta$ for which $V(\theta) = 0$. Substituting we get:


$$ 0 = \mu \sin(\theta) - \cos(\theta) $$


But it is totally counter intuitive (and incorrect by experiment), that this point depends only on $\mu$ and not on the initial height $H$. So where did I make the mistake? Could somebody please clarify.




No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...