Wednesday 7 August 2019

interactions - Static fields - are properties of single objects, or do exist only between two interacting objects?


I apologize for seeming to return on a same question, but I don't have the feeling that the things are clear.


In a former question, "where is the potential energy stored", the conclusion was that this energy is stored in the field of mutual interaction between two objects. But it seems to me that this conclusion doesn't arrange well with other facts.


To shorten the story, my question is : if an asteroid approaches the Earth, does it find the gravitational field of the Earth there, ready, or the field appears between the two objects?


The thing is analogous with a big electric charge A. When a point charge B is brought in the neighborhood of A, does B find the field of A ready or the field appears between the two bodies?



One should not let oneself eluded by the fact that the Earth is a big and the asteroid is small. If the Earth has around itself a field, so has the asteroid.


And, if possible, what kind of matter is the static field? A travelling field is photons, gravitons, neutrinos, other particles. But the static field? It contains energy, the energy is stored in matter.



Answer



This question can be rephrased like the following. Suppose we created a big electric charge somewhere, and after a second passed, we created a small test charge in two light-seconds from the first one. Now the question would be: what time has to pass before the test charge begins accelerating?


If the field appeared only because of both bodies, then it'd mean that the test charge wouldn't start accelerating until the big charge "knows" the test charge is there. This means four seconds in our setup — two for the "message" to reach the big charge and another two for "response" to reach the test charge.


But actually, according to theory of electromagnetism, the test charge will accelerate just after one second, because the field of big charge has already travelled one light-second when we created our test charge, and had only to travel yet another light second to reach the test charge.


Moreover, if, when we created the test charge, we simultaneously removed our big charge, the test charge would still begin accelerating after one second as if the big charge was still there, and only after another one second would the acceleration end because the change of electrostatic field due to removal of its source has now reached the test charge.


So, the field is already there when the test charge probes it, not created due to both charges being present.


See also an illustration for evolution of static field of a uniformly moving charge in this answer to another question.


Having said this, I have to note that this is the most straightforward interpretation of the theory of electromagnetism. The other is Wheeler-Feynman absorber theory, in which the field is indeed created by both emitter and absorber, but this is actually somewhat tricky and experimentally indistinguishable from what I've said above.



No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...