Sunday 19 April 2020

homework and exercises - "Redshifting" of forces in stationary spacetime


Here's the problem statement: Let $(M,g_{ab})$ be a stationary spacetime with timelike killing field $\xi ^{a}$. Let $V^{2} = -\xi _{a}\xi ^{a}$ ($V$ is called the redshift factor). (a) Show that the acceleration $a^{b} = u^{a}\triangledown _{a}u^{b}$ of a stationary observer is given by $a^{b} = \triangledown^{b}\ln V$.


(b) Suppose in addition that $(M,g_{ab})$ is asymptotically flat. Then, the "energy as measured at infinity" of a particle of mass $m$ and 4 - velocity $u^{a}$ is $E = - m\xi _{a}u^{a}$. Suppose a particle of mass $m$ is held stationary by a (massless) string, with the other end of the string being held by a stationary observer at infinity. Let $F$ denote the magnitude of the local force exerted by the string on on the particle. According to part (a), we have $F = mV^{-1}(\triangledown ^{a}V\triangledown _{a}V)^{1/2}$. Use conservation of energy arguments to show that the magnitude of the force exerted on the other end of the string by the observer at infinity, is $F_{\infty } = VF$.


My attempt: (a) A stationary observer's 4 - velocity must be proportional to the time - like killing vector and it must be normalized to -1 so we find that for a stationary observer, $$u^{a} = \frac{\xi ^{a}}{(-\xi ^{c}\xi _{c})^{1/2}}$$. Now we compute, $$\triangledown _{b}u^{a} = \frac{\triangledown _{b}\xi ^{a}}{(-\xi ^{c}\xi _{c})^{1/2}} + \frac{\xi ^{a}\xi ^{c}\triangledown _{b}\xi _{c}}{(-\xi ^{c}\xi _{c})^{3/2}}$$ so $$u^{b}\triangledown _{b}u^{a} = \frac{\xi^{b}\triangledown _{b}\xi ^{a}}{(-\xi ^{c}\xi _{c})} + \frac{\xi ^{a}\xi^{b}\xi ^{c}\triangledown _{b}\xi _{c}}{(-\xi ^{c}\xi _{c})^{5/2}} = -\frac{\xi^{b}\triangledown ^{a}\xi _{b}}{(-\xi ^{c}\xi _{c})}$$ where the second term vanishes because it is a contraction of a symmetric tensor with an anti - symmetric one and I have swapped the indices in the first expression using killing's equation. Therefore, $$a^{a} = u^{b}\triangledown _{b}u^{a} = \frac{1}{2}\frac{\triangledown ^{a}(-\xi^{b}\xi _{b})}{(-\xi ^{c}\xi _{c})} = \frac{1}{2}\triangledown ^{a}\ln V^{2} = \triangledown ^{a}\ln V$$ as desired.


(b) This is where I'm totally stuck. As far as conservation of energy goes, we know that $E$, as defined above, is a conserved quantity along the worldline of the stationary particle; physically $E$ is the energy needed to bring in the particle from infinity to its orbit. Here we have a stationary observer at infinity holding this particle stationary by a long thread. There is a tension force at the end the observer holds and at the end the particle hangs by. Let's say the observer exerts the force $F_{\infty }$ at event $P_{1}$ and the particle feels the local force $F$ at event $P_{2}$. As far as I can tell, all we know is that in between these events, $E$ is constant. But how do I relate $E$ to $F_{\infty}$ and how do I do this using the conservation of energy explained above?


I should note that I tried something on a whim and looked at $\triangledown _{b}E$. We know that for the stationary particle hanging from the string, to which this total energy is attributed, $$E = -m\xi _{a}u^{a} = -\frac{m\xi_{a}\xi^{a}}{(-\xi _{c}\xi^{c})^{1/2}} = m(-\xi^{c}\xi_{c})^{1/2}$$ so if we compute the derivative we get $\triangledown _{b}E = mV\triangledown _{b}\ln V$ thus $(\triangledown ^{b}E\triangledown _{b}E)^{1/2} = mV(\triangledown ^{b}\ln V\triangledown _{b}\ln V)^{1/2} = VF$ but I have NO idea how this quantity is related to $F_{\infty }$, if at all. If it is related somehow I have no idea how one uses conservation of energy to arrive at the relation. Thanks in advance!




No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...