Tuesday, 21 April 2020

quantum mechanics - Entangled particles


So we have two particles (A and B) that are entangled.


From what I understand, entanglement isn't destroyed, it is only obscured by subsequent interactions with the environment.


Particle A goes zooming off into outer space.


10 years later, Particle B becomes incorporated into my brain.


The day after that, an alien scientist measures the entangled property on Particle A.



This will have some immediate non-local effect on Particle B won't it?


And since B's state has been altered (in some sense), and it is part of my brain, then my brain state has been altered as well, hasn't it?


Maybe only a tiny amount, obscured by the many environmental interactions that the two particles have been subjected to since the initial entanglement, but in a way that is real and at least conceivably significant.


And if that is true, then to the extent that mental states supervene on brain states, my mental state would also have been altered by non-local effects.


Or is that wrong?


Thanks!



Answer




From what I understand, entanglement isn't destroyed, it is only obscured by subsequent interactions with the environment.




Depends on how you view it. There is an explanation of quantum measurement (called decoherence) in which this is true. I will not be using that explanation in this post because it's unnecessarily complicated.



This will have some immediate non-local effect on Particle B won't it?



Nope. When an alien scientist measures particle A, it does not have an effect on particle B. Specifically, it does not induce any sort of change in particle B that can be detected.


Of course, we would say that the quantum state of particle B (technically: the combined quantum state of the pair AB) has changed, but changes of this nature in the quantum state can't be detected. For example, suppose the entangled state, written in a basis of energy levels, is


$$|\psi_1\rangle = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\left(|1\rangle|2\rangle + |2\rangle|1\rangle\right)$$


so that if particle A has an energy of 1 (in unspecified units), particle B will have an energy of 2, and vice versa. Suppose the alien scientist measures the energy of particle A to be 1. The state of the pair AB becomes


$$|\psi_2\rangle = |1\rangle|2\rangle$$


Then, the next day, when your brain measures the energy of particle B, it will get 2 as the result. But as far as your brain is concerned, the energy of particle B could have just been 2 all along. Or it could have had some arbitrary probability distribution with 2 as one of the possible results. The fact that the state changed from $|\psi_1\rangle$ to $|\psi_2\rangle$ has no effect, and could not have been detected by your brain.




And if that is true, then to the extent that mental states supervene on brain states,



If by that you mean that your thoughts are determined by quantum states, that's definitely false.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...