Wednesday 7 January 2015

electromagnetism - What happens in circuits where the propagation time of the electric field is significant?


Kirchhoff's current law assumes "that whenever current flows into one end of a conductor it immediately flows out the other end".


I want to understand what happens when we cannot make this assumption.


In the circuit below, imagine that $S1$ has been open (disconnected) for a long time. At a time $t = 0$ the switch is instantaneously closed. If we assume that the LEDs have instantaneous switching time, at what time $t$ will $D1$ and $D2$ emit light?


Do the LEDs begin to emit light simultaneously? Do they emit light after 3 light-seconds, 1.5 light-seconds, or some other time?


My guess is that $D1$ will emit light at $t = 1s$ and $D2$ will emit at $t = 3s$. It should be impossible for $D1$ to emit light when $t < 1s$ and for $D2$ to emit light when $t < 3s$. If this were not the case then this would result in superluminal communication, which violates causality.


Circuit with a single switch in series with two LEDs


What happens when a second switch $S2$ is introduced to the circuit below? Imagine that both switches have been open for a long time. At time $t=0$ both $S1$ and $S2$ are simultaneously closed.



At what time $t$ do the LEDs emit light? What changes compared to first circuit?


Circuit with two switches that open and close simultaneously


Assumptions:



  • The LEDs and switches are placed in close proximity to each other, although the length of the wires separating them may be very long. For example, $S1$ and $D1$ are separated by a 1 light-second length of wire, however, we assume that they are physically placed close together relative to a human observer looking at the circuit. Only the electrical paths have significant propagation times.

  • The electric field propagates through the circuit at c

  • All circuit elements are ideal

  • Switches and LEDs have instantaneous switching time

  • When a switch is open, it is physically disconnected from the circuit.

  • There are no parasitic resistances, capacitances, or inductances





No comments:

Post a Comment

Understanding Stagnation point in pitot fluid

What is stagnation point in fluid mechanics. At the open end of the pitot tube the velocity of the fluid becomes zero.But that should result...